Skip to main content

Not everyone accepts that lying is wrong in itself. Two other great traditions in ethics reach a similar conclusion by different roads. One asks what lying does to the world. The other asks what lying does to the person who does it. Both end up treating honesty as close to essential, even if neither treats it as absolute.

Counting the costs

Consequentialists judge actions by their results. At first glance, this looks like a license to lie whenever lying produces a better outcome. If a lie spares someone pain and harms no one, why not tell it? Critics have long pressed this objection, and it is a fair one. But the most careful consequentialists noticed that the costs of a lie are usually much larger than they look in the moment.

The English philosopher John Stuart Mill made this point in Utilitarianism, published in 1863. Mill argued that even a small departure from the truth weakens what he called "the trustworthiness of human assertion, which is not only the principal support of all present social well-being" but also the thing whose absence does more than almost anything else to hold back civilization. Every lie draws down a shared account of trust. The liar gets the benefit; everyone else pays a little of the cost, because the next honest statement is a little less believable.

Mill did not think honesty was exceptionless. He named cases where withholding the truth might be right, such as keeping information from a person bent on doing wrong, or keeping bad news from someone dangerously ill. But he insisted that such exceptions be defined narrowly and in advance, so that the general rule stays strong. A rule that bends whenever bending looks convenient is no rule at all.

The hidden bill

There is a second, more personal cost. A liar must remember what he said, to whom, and keep it consistent with everything else. And a lie that is found out costs far more than the lie itself. Once a person is caught in a lie, listeners begin to doubt even the true things that person says. A manager caught lying about one deadline finds that the team no longer believes any of the deadlines. The lie was about one thing; the damage is to everything.

This is why many consequentialists end up defending honesty as a firm habit rather than a case by case calculation. People are bad at predicting the long chain of effects from a single lie, and very good at persuading themselves that the lie they want to tell is the harmless kind.

Aristotle's truthful person

Aristotle, writing in Athens in the fourth century BC, approached ethics by asking what a good person is like. In the Nicomachean Ethics he described many virtues as a middle point between two vices. Truthfulness about oneself, he said, is such a mean: the truthful person stands between the boastful person, who claims more than he has, and the mock modest person, who pretends to less. Both extremes misrepresent reality, and both are a kind of falsehood about the self.

Aristotle was clear about where he stood. In W. D. Ross's 1925 translation, he wrote that "falsehood is in itself mean and culpable, and truth noble and worthy of praise." He also made an observation about how honesty grows. A person who loves truth and is truthful when nothing is at stake will be still more truthful when something is at stake. Honesty in small matters is training for honesty in large ones.

That fits Aristotle's general view of how character forms. Virtues are not something we are born with or decide on once. They are built by practice. As Ross translated him, "we become just by doing just acts, temperate by doing temperate acts, brave by doing brave acts." The same holds for honesty and dishonesty. A child who is praised for clever lies is being trained in a skill, and the skill becomes part of who the child is.

Confucius and the crossbar

The same insight appears in the Chinese tradition. Confucius, who taught in the sixth and early fifth centuries BC, placed great weight on xin, a word usually translated as trustworthiness or good faith: xin means standing by your word, so that what you say and what you do match. In the Analects, the collection of his sayings, he compared a person without it to a cart without the crossbar that yokes it to the animals. In James Legge's translation of 1861: "I do not know how a man without truthfulness is to get on. How can a large carriage be made to go without the cross-bar for yoking the oxen to?"

The image is precise. A cart without its crossbar cannot be pulled, however strong the oxen; a person without good faith cannot be relied on, however talented. Ability without trustworthiness goes nowhere, because no one can safely harness it.

Where the traditions meet

These are very different philosophies. Mill cared about outcomes, Aristotle about character, Confucius about the harmony of persons in relationships. Yet all three treated honesty as a foundation, not an ornament. Mill saw that trust is a shared resource that each lie depletes. Aristotle saw that each lie shapes the liar. Confucius saw that a person whose word cannot bear weight cannot carry anything else. The strict absolutists of the previous level, and the more flexible thinkers here, disagree about rare emergencies. They largely agree about ordinary life.

Worked example: the padded résumé

A job seeker is tempted to add a degree she did not finish to her résumé. She reasons like a crude consequentialist: she can do the job, the employer will be happy, and no one will check. Each tradition offers a reply.

Mill's reply looks beyond the single hire. If padding résumés is common, employers stop trusting résumés, add expensive background checks, and lean on personal connections instead. Honest applicants without connections lose out. Her lie draws down a shared resource that other job seekers depend on. And if she is caught, her real skills will be doubted too.

Aristotle's reply looks at her. The first false line on a résumé makes the second one easier. She is practicing a habit of presenting herself as more than she is, the very vice of boastfulness, and habits become character.

Confucius's reply looks at her relationships. An employee whose credentials cannot be trusted is a cart without its crossbar. However capable she is, her employer can never fully rely on her, and she knows it, which puts a quiet strain on the whole working relationship.

None of the three needs a rule handed down from above to reach the same conclusion. Each sees, from its own angle, that the lie costs more than it pays.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Mill say even a small lie weakens?
2. Which case did Mill offer as a possible exception to truth telling?
3. What did Mill insist about exceptions to truth telling?
4. Between which two vices did Aristotle place truthfulness?
5. What did Aristotle say about truthfulness in small matters?
6. How do people become just, according to Aristotle?
7. What does the Confucian term xin mean?
8. What was Confucius's point about the cart's crossbar?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia