
Nearly twenty four centuries ago, a character in Plato's Republic complained that the honest man pays more tax on the same income and collects nothing when the city hands out goods, while the cheat pays less and takes much. Plenty of people still believe him. Some teach it to their children as plain good sense: look after your own, and leave honesty to the suckers.
Here the argument gets its strongest form, and then it meets Augustine, Aquinas, Kant, Mill, Aristotle and Confucius, against laboratory games where strangers share a common pot, and against what habitual lying does to a mind and a town. It also asks a question rarely put at the kitchen table: who keeps a school lunch program or an unemployment fund alive, if not the ordinary people who decline to cheat it? Honesty proves to be less a private nicety than load-bearing structure, and the people who mock it are leaning on it too.
CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia