Skip to main content

Philosophers of the past mostly argued about dramatic cases: the murderer at the door, the fugitive in the attic. Most lies are not like that. They are told at work, at home, in shops and in offices, usually to avoid an awkward moment or gain a small advantage. The philosopher who did most to bring attention to these ordinary lies was Sissela Bok, a Swedish-born American thinker whose book Lying: Moral Choice in Public and Private Life appeared in 1978.

Two points of view

Bok's central move was to look at lying from both sides. From the liar's side, a lie usually seems small, isolated and justified. The liar knows his reasons, believes his intentions are good, and expects the lie to stay contained. From the side of the deceived, things look very different. People who discover they have been lied to rarely accept the liar's reasons, and they begin to wonder what else they have been told that was false. They feel that a choice was made for them without their consent, as if they could not be trusted with the truth.

This difference in perspective explains a great deal. Liars systematically underestimate the harm they do, because they never stand where the deceived stands. Bok suggested that anyone tempted to lie should try to take that other point of view seriously before acting.

A presumption against lying

Bok did not claim that lying is always wrong. She argued for what she called a principle of veracity. Truthful statements need no justification, but lies always do. Lying is not forbidden in every case, but it carries a burden of proof. The person who lies must be able to show a strong reason, and "it was easier" or "everyone does it" is not one.

She also noticed how lies multiply. One lie usually needs further lies to shore it up, and each lie makes the next one easier. Over time the threshold drops. A person who began lying only in emergencies finds himself lying out of convenience, and then out of habit. The psychological brake that made the first lie feel uncomfortable wears down.

The test of publicity

How can a person tell whether a lie is truly justified? Bok proposed a practical test. Ask whether the reasons for the lie would still seem acceptable if laid before reasonable people, including the person being deceived. If you would be embarrassed to explain your reasons publicly, or if the deceived person would clearly reject them, the justification is probably a rationalization.

This test is demanding. Most lies fail it immediately. A worker who calls in sick to go to a ball game would not want to explain that reason to the coworkers who covered for him. A company that hides a product defect would not want to explain its reasoning to its customers. The test works because it forces the liar out of his own head and into the shared world where lies have their real effects.

Are white lies harmless?

Bok took white lies seriously, without condemning every polite fiction. Many are trivial. But she pointed out that some practices people think of as harmless white lies do real damage once they spread. One example she discussed was the letter of recommendation. If every professor writes that every student is outstanding, inflated letters of recommendation become worthless, and the genuinely outstanding student can no longer be recognized. Small kindnesses, multiplied, destroy the very signal they were meant to boost.

She was also skeptical of lies told by professionals "for the patient's own good" or "for the client's own good." Such lies treat adults as children, and they wear away the trust that makes professional relationships work.

Where lies may be justified

Bok was not an absolutist. She accepted that there are times when lying may be defensible, especially in a crisis, as when lying to someone who threatens innocent life, a kind of self-defense. A person hiding refugees from a violent mob is in a different moral position from a person lying on a tax form. But she insisted these cases are rare, and that people should not use them as cover for ordinary convenience. The existence of a hard case does not justify an easy lie.

Trust as a public good

Underneath all of this was a single idea. Bok argued that trust is a social good that deserves protection as much as clean air and water. Like clean air, it is shared by everyone and owned by no one. Like clean air, it can be polluted bit by bit by many people who each think their own contribution is too small to matter. And like clean air, once it is badly damaged it is very hard to restore.

What children learn

Lies teach lessons, especially to the young. In a 2014 experiment by the psychologists Chelsea Hays and Leslie Carver, an adult told some children a small lie to get them into a room, and told others nothing false. Afterward, the children faced a temptation to cheat on a game and then were asked whether they had. Children who had just been lied to by an adult were more likely to cheat and then lie about it. Even a casual adult lie seemed to signal that lying was acceptable. Children watch what adults do far more closely than what adults say.

Worked example: the ticket counter

A parent at a museum ticket counter sees that children under 12 get in free. Her son is 13. She tells him to say he is 11 if the cashier asks. It seems trivial: a few dollars, a big institution, no real victim.

Apply Bok's tools. From the museum's point of view, its pricing is a deliberate choice, perhaps to make the museum affordable for families with young children. Free entry for the young only works if most families respect the line. If enough people lie, the museum may end the free tier for everyone or start demanding identification, which makes the visit worse for honest families.

Next, the test of publicity. Would the parent be comfortable explaining her reasoning to the cashier, or to the families behind her who paid full price for their own 13 year olds? Almost certainly not.

Finally, consider the boy. He has just learned three things: that rules are for other people, that his mother will lie for a few dollars, and that he is expected to lie on command. He has also learned that his mother's word is something she bends when it suits her. Years later, when she asks him whether he finished his homework or where he was last night, he will remember the lesson.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Bok say the deceived often do on discovering a lie?
2. What does Bok's principle of veracity hold?
3. What did Bok say tends to follow a first lie?
4. What does Bok's test of publicity ask?
5. What happens when every recommendation letter praises every student?
6. When did Bok think a lie might be defensible?
7. To what did Bok compare trust as a social good?
8. What did Hays and Carver find after an adult lied to children?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia