Skip to main content

The case for dishonesty rests on a picture of the world as a contest in which every gain for an honest stranger is a loss for my family. That picture is partly true in the short run and badly wrong in the long run. This level answers the argument in four ways: by asking what dishonesty does to the dishonest person, what it does to the community, how it looks when people deal with each other more than once, and whether it really serves the family it claims to protect.

Plato's reply: the soul of the tyrant

Plato spends most of the Republic answering Thrasymachus and Glaucon. His answer is that justice is a kind of health of the soul, in which reason governs desire, and injustice is a kind of disease. The tyrant who gets everything he wants is, on Plato's account, the most miserable of men, enslaved to his own appetites and surrounded by people he cannot trust. He can never relax, never be sure of a friend, never know whether the flattery around him is real.

A person need not accept all of Plato's theory to see the force of this. The successful con artist has to watch his back. The person who lies for a living cannot afford close friends who might see through him. Even inside the family, the habit of manipulation is hard to switch off.

What Banfield's critics saw

Many scholars challenged Banfield's explanation. They argued that the outlook he described was a response to poverty, insecure land tenure and a long history of untrustworthy government, not a free-floating cultural trait. If landlords and officials had exploited the villagers for generations, distrust was a reasonable lesson. Others found that families in such villages helped each other a great deal, and that cooperation existed where conditions made it safe.

This criticism is fair, and it also points to the deeper problem. If distrust is a reasonable reaction to an untrustworthy world, and distrust also makes the world untrustworthy, then people can get stuck.

The trap of mutual suspicion

Suppose everyone in a town assumes everyone else cheats. Each person cheats in self-defense. Their cheating confirms everyone else's assumption, so everyone keeps cheating. Each person's distrust is sensible given what the others do, yet everyone ends up worse off than if all had been honest. Social scientists call this kind of situation a low-trust trap. Its cruelty is that no single person can escape it by changing alone, and so the person who tries looks, in the short run, like a sucker.

The sucker argument mistakes being caught in the trap for being clever. The honest person in a low-trust town does lose in the short run. But the dishonest person is not winning. Everyone is losing together, and the dishonest are helping to keep the trap shut.

The price of distrust

The American economist Kenneth Arrow, a Nobel laureate, made this point in a 1972 essay. He noted that nearly every commercial exchange contains an element of trust, and he argued that much of the economic backwardness in the world could be explained by a lack of mutual confidence. Where people cannot trust each other, every deal needs locks, guards, lawyers, inspectors and hostages. Many deals never happen at all.

The political scientist Francis Fukuyama extended the argument in his 1995 book Trust. He noted that where people trust only relatives, businesses tend to stay small and family-run, because owners will not hand responsibility to outsiders. The family firm that cannot grow beyond its cousins is a direct cost of the family-first ethic.

Reputation and the long game

The sucker argument imagines life as a single encounter: one deal, one cashier, one benefits office. In a single encounter, cheating can pay. But real life is mostly repeated encounters with the same neighbors, employers, landlords and customers. When people deal with each other again and again, a reputation for honesty becomes valuable, because it brings offers, credit and second chances that the known cheat never receives. The honest mechanic gets the referrals. The honest tenant gets the good reference. Over a lifetime, honesty is usually the better strategy even on purely selfish terms.

Family first, rightly understood

Now return to the family. The deepest problem with "lie for your family" is that lies do not stay where they are put. A child taught to lie to outsiders learns that lying is a skill, that rules are for suckers and that love is shown by deceit. In a 2020 study, researchers led by Peipei Setoh surveyed young adults about lies their parents had told them as children. Those who recalled more lies from their parents reported lying more to their parents as adults, and they reported more difficulty with problems such as guilt, selfishness and impulsiveness.

There is also a moral distinction the argument blurs. Partiality allows you to favor your family with your own time, money and love. It does not allow you to take from others by deceit and call it love. Giving your child your last coin is devotion. Taking a stranger's coin by fraud is theft, whatever the motive. Every family is also a stranger to every other family, and an ethic that licenses each to cheat the rest leaves all of them poorer.

Worked example: two market towns

Imagine two towns of the same size, with the same land and the same weather. In the first, people mostly assume their neighbors are honest. A farmer can sell on credit. A shopkeeper can hire someone outside the family. Parents can trust a teacher with their children. When the town needs a new bridge, people pool money, and almost no one skims.

In the second town, everyone assumes everyone cheats. The farmer demands cash, so poorer buyers go without. The shopkeeper hires only cousins, even untalented ones, so the shop stays small. Every public project is suspected of theft and so never gets funded. Families spend money on locks and favors that in the first town would have gone to schooling.

A family in the second town that teaches its children to cheat is not escaping the trap. It is helping to build it. Its children grow up in a poorer town, with fewer jobs, fewer partners and less help when trouble comes. The parents meant to protect their children from suckers. They ended up raising them in a world where no one can afford to be trusted, including by their own family.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Plato describe the tyrant who gets all he wants?
2. How did many critics explain the outlook Banfield described?
3. What defines a low-trust trap?
4. What did Kenneth Arrow argue in 1972?
5. What did Fukuyama say happens where people trust only kin?
6. Why does a reputation for honesty pay in repeated dealings?
7. What did Setoh's team find in adults whose parents lied to them?
8. What limit on partiality toward family does this level draw?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia