Jean-Jacques Rousseau, born in Geneva in 1712, was the tradition's great insider critic. He accepted that legitimate government must rest on agreement, yet he argued that the agreements history had actually produced were mostly frauds. His Discourse on the Origin of Inequality (1755) tells how things went wrong. The Social Contract (1762) asks how they could be put right.
Hobbes's mistake
Rousseau thought earlier theorists had painted social man and called him natural. Hobbes's people are proud, fearful and greedy, but those passions, Rousseau argued, are learned in society. His natural human is solitary, peaceful and moved by two simple feelings: self-love, the plain wish to survive, and pity, a reluctance to see any sentient being suffer. What corrupts us is a different, comparative self-love that grows when people start living together and watching each other. Rousseau called it amour-propre: a self-love that depends on how we compare with others and how they see us. From it come vanity, envy and the hunger to be thought better than our neighbors.
The first fraud
"The first man who, having enclosed a piece of ground, bethought himself of saying This is mine, and found people simple enough to believe him, was the real founder of civil society." Property brought rich and poor, and with them constant conflict. Then the rich had an idea. They proposed to everyone a common government that would protect the weak and secure each person's goods. Rousseau described the first social contract as a trick by the rich to turn their holdings into rights protected by law. "All ran headlong to their chains, in hopes of securing their liberty." The contract the earlier theorists praised, in other words, was real enough, but it was written by the winners.
A form of association
The Social Contract opens with its most famous line: "Man is born free; and everywhere he is in chains." He set himself a precise problem: "to find a form of association which will defend and protect with the whole common force the person and goods of each associate, and in which each, while uniting himself with all, may still obey himself alone, and remain as free as before." Rousseau's answer was the total alienation of each person, with all his rights, to the whole community. That sounds alarming, but he reasoned that because everyone gives everything equally, no one has an interest in making the terms burdensome for others.
The general will
The community formed this way has a will of its own. The general will aims at the common interest, while the will of all is merely the sum of private wishes. A vote can express either. When citizens ask what is good for all of them, the result tends toward the general will. When they ask what is good for themselves or their faction, it does not, and so Rousseau distrusted organized parties and interest groups within the state.
This yields Rousseau's most troubling sentence. Whoever refuses to obey the general will "shall be compelled to do so by the whole body. This means nothing less than that he will be forced to be free." By "forced to be free" Rousseau meant that compelling obedience to the general will secures each citizen's freedom from private domination. Sympathetic readers stress that, for him, depending on a law we all make is freedom, while depending on another person's whim is slavery. Critics, writing after the dictatorships of the twentieth century, argued that the idea invites rulers to claim they know the people's true will better than the people do.
No one can represent you
Rousseau held that sovereignty belongs to the people and cannot be handed over. "The people of England regards itself as free; but it is grossly mistaken; it is free only during the election of members of parliament." Rousseau believed sovereignty cannot be represented, so a people is free only when it makes its own laws. Government, the executive that applies the laws, is a separate body that serves the sovereign people. This is why Rousseau favored small states where citizens could actually meet.
Worked example: a vote in an open meadow
Rousseau admired "bands of peasants" who regulated "affairs of State under an oak." Something like that still happens in Glarus, a small Swiss canton, where citizens gather each May in the town square for the Landsgemeinde and vote by raising their hands. In 2006 the assembly voted to merge the canton's many small municipalities into three.
Imagine two farmers at that vote. One reasons: "My village will lose its own council, and I like our council." The other reasons: "What arrangement will serve everyone in the canton best?" In Rousseau's terms the first expresses a private will, the second tries to discern the general will. If most voters ask the second question, the outcome has a claim on all, including the losers, since they too asked what was good for everyone. The case also shows Rousseau's limits. Assemblies of this kind work in a canton of about forty thousand people; they are hard to imagine for a nation of forty million, and the pressure to vote with one's neighbors, in full view, is not the same as free reflection.
