By the middle of the eighteenth century the original contract had become a political slogan. English Whigs used it to justify the Revolution of 1688, when Parliament replaced James II with William and Mary. David Hume, the Scottish philosopher, thought the slogan was bad history and worse philosophy, and in 1748 he said so in an essay titled "Of the Original Contract."
History says otherwise
Hume's first blow was historical. "Almost all the governments, which exist at present, or of which there remains any record in story, have been founded originally, either on usurpation or conquest, or both, without any pretence of a fair consent, or voluntary subjection of the people." Hume argued that nearly all governments began in usurpation or conquest, not in consent.
The sleeper on the ship
What about Locke's tacit consent, given by anyone who stays? Hume answered with two images. "Can we seriously say, that a poor peasant or artisan has a free choice to leave his country, when he knows no foreign language or manners, and lives, from day to day, by the small wages which he acquires?" One might as well say, he went on, "that a man, by remaining in a vessel, freely consents to the dominion of the master; though he was carried on board while asleep, and must leap into the ocean and perish, the moment he leaves her." Hume's ship image shows that staying put is not consent when the only way out is ruin.
Why the promise adds nothing
Hume's deepest objection was logical. Suppose we do owe obedience because we promised. Then why must we keep promises? Because, Hume says, human society could not survive without trust in them. But the same answer applies directly to government: "If the reason be asked of that obedience, which we are bound to pay to government, I readily answer, Because society could not otherwise subsist." For Hume, grounding allegiance in a promise adds nothing, since both promises and obedience rest on the same need for society to survive.
In his Treatise of Human Nature (1739 to 1740) Hume had already shown how cooperation can arise without promises. "Two men, who pull the oars of a boat, do it by an agreement or convention, tho' they have never given promises to each other." Hume's rowers illustrate a convention: a shared practice sustained by mutual interest, with no promise ever made. And what keeps governments standing? "It is therefore, on opinion only that government is founded," he wrote in another essay, adding that the rule holds even for "the most despotic and most military governments." Hume held that every government, even a military despotism, ultimately rests on opinion.
Hume was not hostile to consent. Where consent really exists, he wrote, "it is surely the best and most sacred of any" foundation for government. His complaint was against treating a fiction as fact and using it to unsettle every existing order.
Kant: the contract as an idea
Immanuel Kant accepted Hume's history and changed the question. In an essay of 1793 on the relation between theory and practice, Kant called the original contract an idea of reason, not a fact. No one needs to prove that a people ever met and agreed. The idea instead gives lawmakers a test. Kant's test asks whether a whole people could possibly have agreed to a law; if they could not, the law is unjust. His own example: a law granting one class of subjects a hereditary right to rule fails, because no people could consent to its own permanent subordination. A war tax, by contrast, passes even if people grumble, since it is something a people could agree to.
Kant drew a conservative conclusion from his radical test. Since the contract is a standard for rulers to apply, not a deal that subjects can declare broken, Kant denied that subjects have a right to rebel, even against a ruler who violates the original contract. They may protest in public, and he defended the freedom of the pen as the citizen's proper weapon. He also held that people have a duty, not merely an interest, to leave the state of nature and enter a lawful order, because rights cannot be secure without one.
Worked example: two laws on the table
Imagine a legislature considering two bills. The first raises a defense tax that will fall on every household. The second exempts members of an old noble order, and their descendants forever, from all taxes, while giving them a reserved bloc of seats.
Kant's test separates them quickly. A whole people, reasoning together, could agree to share the cost of defending everyone, even though many would rather not pay. No people could agree to make some of its members permanently subordinate to others by birth, so the second bill fails. Now put Hume's question to the same country: why do people actually pay? Not because they recall a contract, but from habit, from fear of penalties, and from a settled opinion that this government is the one in charge. Both thinkers reject the literal contract, yet one turns it into a test of justice and the other explains obedience without it.
