Skip to main content

John Locke's Two Treatises of Government appeared anonymously in late 1689, though the title page is dated 1690. He had drafted much of it years earlier, during a crisis over whether the Catholic James, Duke of York, could inherit the throne.

Answering the patriarchalists

The first treatise is now rarely read, but it explains the second. Locke's First Treatise attacked Robert Filmer, who claimed that kings inherit the fatherly authority God gave to Adam. Filmer's Patriarcha, published in 1680, held that people are born subjects, never free. Locke replied that no line of inheritance from Adam could be traced and that parental power over children ends when they reach the age of reason. Political power had to have another source.

A state of liberty, not licence

Locke's state of nature is gentler than Hobbes's. It is a state of liberty but not of licence, because it is governed by a law of nature, which is reason. That law teaches that "being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions." Who enforces it, with no government? Everyone. In Locke's state of nature, every person holds the right to punish those who break the law of nature.

The trouble is that people judge their own cases badly. Locke listed what the state of nature lacks: an established, known law; a known and impartial judge; and a power to enforce just sentences. These "inconveniences" are why people leave it. Locke also took a swipe at Hobbes. It would be strange, he said, for men to guard against "polecats or foxes" while being "content, nay, think it safety, to be devoured by lions." Locke's point about polecats and lions was that escaping small dangers by accepting an unchecked ruler is foolish.

Property and its limits

Locke thought property existed before government. God gave the earth to humankind in common, but each person owns his own labor, and mixing labor with what is unowned makes it his. There are limits. One may take only as long as there is "enough, and as good, left in common for others." Later readers call this the Lockean proviso: appropriation is legitimate only if enough and as good is left for others. A second limit forbids letting things spoil. Then money changes everything. Because money does not spoil, Locke argued, it allows people to hold far more than they can use without breaking the spoilage limit. By agreeing to use money, he says, people tacitly accepted unequal possessions.

Express and tacit consent

Locke's government rests on consent, but few people ever sign anything. His answer has two parts. Express consent, such as an oath, makes a person a full member, and someone who has given express consent, Locke held, is bound for good and cannot return to the state of nature. Tacit consent is broader. Anyone who enjoys any part of a government's territory gives it, "whether this his possession be of land... or a lodging only for a week; or whether it be barely travelling freely on the highway." For Locke, even traveling freely on a country's highways counts as tacit consent to its laws. Those who join a community also agree that the majority decides, since a body must move one way or another.

Government holds its power as a trust. When rulers betray that trust, the people may resist, and the government is dissolved. Locke's critics noticed how thin tacit consent becomes. If walking down a road counts as agreement, almost anything does.

The shadows of the text

Locke's ideals sit uneasily beside his life. He invested in the Royal African Company, which traded enslaved Africans, and he served as secretary to the proprietors of Carolina, whose Fundamental Constitutions of 1669 gave every freeman "absolute power and authority over his negro slaves." How much of that document Locke wrote is debated. His property theory also had colonial uses. "In the beginning all the world was America," he wrote, meaning land without money or settled ownership. Colonists used Locke's labor theory to treat Native lands that were not farmed in the European way as open to taking. Defenders reply that Locke's own principles, equal rights and consent, are the best tools for condemning these practices.

Worked example: two citizens, one oath

Picture two neighbors. Amira moved to the country at twenty-five, studied its laws and swore an oath of citizenship. Ben was born there and has never signed or sworn anything. Locke would say Amira gave express consent and is a full member, bound for good. Ben, by contrast, owns a house, rents out a flat and drives the roads every day, so on Locke's account he has consented tacitly. If he sold up and moved abroad, his obligation would end.

Ask whether this captures the real situation. Ben never chose his birthplace, cannot easily leave, and would face the same laws whether he agreed or not. Amira, oddly, is more strongly bound than the native-born Ben, though she has had fewer years to shape the country's rules. The case shows both what Locke got right, that membership should rest on something more than birth, and why tacit consent struggles to carry the weight he put on it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Whom did Locke's First Treatise attack?
2. Who enforces the law of nature in Locke's state of nature?
3. Which is one of the things Locke said the state of nature lacks?
4. What was Locke's point about polecats, foxes and lions?
5. What does the Lockean proviso require of anyone taking property?
6. Why did money matter so much in Locke's account of property?
7. According to Locke, what does even traveling freely on a highway show?
8. How did colonists use Locke's labor theory of property?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia