
Ask a room of people who they are and almost nobody answers with a list of preferences. They say a nurse, a Catholic, a Glaswegian, somebody's daughter. In 1971 John Rawls built a theory of justice around people who, for fairness's sake, set all of that aside, and within a decade a handful of philosophers were asking whether anyone really can. The quarrel that followed turned on chess and candy, French shop signs, Civil War draft fees and a nation's apology to children taken from their parents, as much as on abstract principle.
Nobody won, which is part of the value. Both sides gave ground, and what survives is a sharper sense of what rights can and cannot do without the families, crafts and towns that teach people to care about them. Hear a politician praise community or individual freedom after this, and the follow-up questions should come quickly: whose community, which freedom, and who gets to leave.
CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia