Skip to main content

The little platoon

The liberal-communitarian debate cooled in the academy after the 1990s, but its questions moved into public life. Who do we belong to? What do we owe the place we come from? Can a society built on individual choice keep the loyalties it needs? These questions echo a much older voice. Edmund Burke wrote in 1790: "To be attached to the subdivision, to love the little platoon we belong to in society, is the first principle (the germ as it were) of public affections." For Burke, love for the little platoon we belong to was where wider loyalty begins, not a rival to it.

What holds a nation together

Nationalism is the most powerful form of belonging in modern politics, and its relation to communitarian ideas is uneasy. In 1882 the French historian Ernest Renan asked what makes a nation and answered that it is not race, language or geography but shared memories and a present will to live together. He called the existence of a nation a daily plebiscite, a choice renewed each day by its members.

Some liberal philosophers built on this. Liberal nationalism holds that national belonging and liberal rights can support each other. The Israeli philosopher Yael Tamir argued in 1993 that people have a legitimate interest in living within a culture they recognize as their own, and that a sense of shared nationhood helps sustain the trust that welfare states and democratic sacrifice require. The nation, on this view, must stay open to newcomers and respect minorities.

Others feared any national loyalty that went beyond law. Constitutional patriotism is loyalty centered on a constitution's democratic principles, not on ethnicity or a shared past. The German thinker Dolf Sternberger coined the term in 1979 and Habermas developed it for a Germany that had good reason to distrust older nationalism. Critics replied that principles alone are too thin to inspire sacrifice, and that every constitution lives inside a particular history anyway.

MacIntyre sharpened the conflict in a 1984 lecture, Is Patriotism a Virtue? He argued that patriotism makes sense within a morality of particular ties, in which I owe special loyalty to my own people, and that patriotism and liberal impartiality are in deep tension. A morality that judges all persons from nowhere leaves little room for love of one's own country.

Merit, work and dignity

Sandel carried the debate into the age of populism. In The Tyranny of Merit (2020) he argued that societies which hand rewards to those who win credentials and then tell everyone they deserve their place create a corrosive attitude. Meritocracy breeds hubris in winners and humiliation in others. People without degrees hear that their lower standing is their own fault, and many turn against the elites who say so.

His remedy draws on a communitarian idea of the common good. Contributive justice emphasizes people's need to be valued for what they contribute, not only to receive a fair share of income. Work that keeps a community running, such as stocking shelves, driving trucks and caring for the sick, deserves honor as well as pay.

The British writer David Goodhart offered a related map in 2017, contrasting rooted "somewheres" with mobile, degree-holding "anywheres". The second group, he argued, dominated politics and culture while dismissing the first group's attachment to place and familiar ways. Critics answered that such labels flatten real people and can be used to excuse hostility to immigrants.

The guardrail of equal worth

These echoes cut in more than one direction. Some writers on the right, sometimes called post-liberals, now argue that liberalism itself has dissolved family, faith and locality and should be replaced. The American political theorist Patrick Deneen made this case in 2018, arguing that liberalism had failed precisely by succeeding at freeing individuals from every unchosen bond. Liberals answer that past communities often excluded and coerced, and that the freedom to leave a community is what makes belonging a gift rather than a cage. The best communitarian thinkers never denied that answer. Sandel, Taylor, Walzer and Etzioni each accepted that community claims must respect the equal dignity of persons. The debate's lasting lesson may be that people need both: rights that protect each person's worth, and shared lives in which that worth is recognized.

Worked example: when the mill closes

A paper mill that employed a third of a small town shuts down. Unemployment benefits arrive and retraining is offered, perhaps at a college two hours away. By liberal measures of fair distribution, the response may be adequate. Yet the town falls apart: churches close, the high school team folds, young people leave.

Each thinker sees something different. Sandel sees lost contributive dignity. MacIntyre sees the death of practices that gave lives a narrative. Taylor sees a group misrecognized by distant elites. Walzer asks whether market power has invaded spheres it should not rule. A liberal asks whether the people who leave have been wronged at all. Holding all these views at once is harder than choosing one, and more faithful to what happened.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Burke call the first principle of public affections?
2. How did Ernest Renan describe the existence of a nation?
3. What does liberal nationalism hold?
4. What is constitutional patriotism?
5. What did MacIntyre argue in Is Patriotism a Virtue?
6. What did Sandel argue in The Tyranny of Merit?
7. What does contributive justice emphasize?
8. What did David Goodhart contrast in his 2017 book?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia