Skip to main content

Utilitarianism was never only a theory. Its founders were reformers who used it to attack cruelty and privilege, and its record includes some of the boldest moral stands of the nineteenth century, along with some blind spots that critics have not let it forget.

Against slavery

Bentham condemned slavery, and Mill fought its defenders in public. In 1849 the Scottish writer Thomas Carlyle published an essay arguing that freed Black workers in the West Indies should be compelled to labor for white planters. Mill's "The Negro Question" (1850) replied to Carlyle's essay defending forced labor of freed Black workers, insisting that no one is born a master and that differences between peoples come from circumstance, not nature. Carlyle's essay was also where his phrase "the dismal science" for economics first appeared, aimed at economists who refused to treat human beings as property.

In 1865 a rising at Morant Bay in Jamaica was crushed under martial law; hundreds of Black Jamaicans were killed and a mixed-race politician, George William Gordon, was hanged after a hasty military trial. Mill chaired the Jamaica Committee, which sought to prosecute Governor Edward John Eyre for these killings. The prosecution failed, and Mill received threatening letters, but he counted the campaign among the most important things he did in public life.

Sex, law and privacy

Around 1785 Bentham wrote an essay on the laws that made sex between men punishable by death. Applying his tests, he argued there was no utilitarian case for punishing consensual sex between men, but the essay stayed unpublished for nearly two centuries. He feared, with reason, that publishing it would ruin his influence on other reforms. It finally appeared in 1978.

Women

Bentham argued in private that women had as strong a claim to political rights as men, and Mill, with Harriet Taylor, made women's equality a central cause of his life. The reasoning followed from the theory: if each person counts for one, there is no ground for counting half the population as less.

Animals

Utilitarians were among the first philosophers to count animal suffering. When the Cambridge philosopher William Whewell argued that human pleasures could not be put on a level with those of animals, Mill defended counting animals' pleasures and pains against William Whewell in an 1852 review. Any practice that caused more pain to animals than pleasure to people was, Mill wrote, immoral, and he declared himself "perfectly willing to stake the whole question on this one issue."

Prisons and poverty

Bentham spent years and much of his fortune on his panopticon prison. The government first supported the plan, then let it lapse, and Parliament paid Bentham £23,000 in 1813 as compensation after dropping the panopticon prison. His influence on government ran instead through disciples. His last secretary, Edwin Chadwick, helped write the New Poor Law of 1834, which forced most able-bodied paupers into deliberately harsh workhouses, and later led the campaign for public sanitation. The same mind could produce a cruel system for the poor and a reform that saved countless lives.

The critics

Many Victorians saw utilitarianism as cold. In Hard Times (1854), Charles Dickens created Thomas Gradgrind, a man who trusts only facts and calculation, whose children grow up starved of imagination and feeling. Carlyle called the theory a philosophy fit for pigs.

A harder charge concerns empire. Mill wrote in On Liberty (1859) that his principle of liberty applied only to peoples he thought ready for it, and that despotism is legitimate over "barbarians" if it aims at their improvement. Critics see here how utilitarian reasoning could serve colonial rule: whoever controls the calculation decides whose welfare counts and what improvement means. Defenders reply that the error lay in Mill's prejudices about other peoples, not in the principle that everyone counts equally, a principle his opponents were the first to turn against him.

The legacy

Utilitarian thinking now runs through public life: in cost-benefit tests for regulations, in public health, in the reform of punishment and in the movement to reduce animal suffering. Its great gift to the idea of human dignity is the insistence that everyone's suffering matters, whatever their rank, race or sex. Its great warning is that summing welfare, unchecked by rights, can make a person into a mere means. Most humane societies have tried to keep both lessons.

Worked example: judging the 1834 Poor Law

The New Poor Law was designed on Benthamite lines. Its authors argued that generous relief encouraged idleness and kept wages low, so relief should be offered mainly inside workhouses whose conditions were worse than those of the poorest independent laborer. Fewer people would seek help, costs would fall and work would pay. A utilitarian at the time could find these arguments persuasive.

But apply the theory carefully. Each pauper counts for one, so the misery of families split up in workhouses, of the sick and the old treated as idlers, belongs in the sum. Evidence that relief caused idleness was weak, and many of the poor were poor because of illness, age or lack of work, which no deterrent could cure. Judged by its own standard, the law caused more suffering than its authors counted. The lesson is not that utilitarianism failed, but that a calculation is only as humane as the people it remembers to include.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Whose essay did Mill answer in "The Negro Question" (1850)?
2. Where did Carlyle's phrase "the dismal science" first appear?
3. What did the Jamaica Committee, chaired by Mill, try to do?
4. What happened to Bentham's essay on punishing sex between men?
5. What did Mill do in his 1852 review of Whewell?
6. What happened after the government dropped the panopticon?
7. Whom did Dickens create in Hard Times to mock a cold, calculating outlook?
8. What did Mill write about despotism in On Liberty?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia