Skip to main content

Trust in cadres

Leonid Brezhnev, who led the party from 1964 until his death in 1982, offered the officials who had removed Khrushchev what they wanted most: security. His slogan was "stability of cadres", which meant that officials kept their posts for years, even decades. Purges ended, reorganizations stopped and regional bosses built lasting networks of clients. By the early 1980s the average age of the Politburo was around seventy, and the country was governed by men who had made their careers under Stalin.

Reform was tried and then shelved. In 1965 Prime Minister Alexei Kosygin introduced measures that gave factories more freedom and judged them partly by profit and sales. The changes were cautious, and after the Prague Spring of 1968 showed how economic reform could feed demands for political change, they quietly faded.

Oil, grain and the second economy

The discovery of huge oil and gas fields in western Siberia, and the jump in world oil prices after 1973, gave the regime a cushion. Oil and gas exports paid for grain imports and Western machinery. By the late 1970s the Soviet Union, once a great exporter of grain, had become one of the world's largest buyers of it. Economic growth slowed decade by decade, and many economists now date the start of serious decline to the 1970s.

Daily life was predictable but threadbare. Shops were often empty while warehouses held goods no one wanted. People relied on blat, the web of favors and connections that got you a car part or a hospital bed, and on a second economy of private dealing, moonlighting and pilfering. A popular joke held that workers pretended to work while the state pretended to pay them. Alcohol consumption rose, and the life expectancy of men fell from the mid 1960s. When infant mortality began to rise in the 1970s, the government stopped publishing the figures. Gorbachev's supporters later called the whole period the era of stagnation.

The dissidents

A small but remarkable movement grew in these years. In February 1966 the writers Andrei Sinyavsky and Yuli Daniel were tried for satirical works published abroad under pen names, and sentenced to seven and five years in camps. Their trial provoked open protest, petitions and the idea, startling at the time, that citizens should simply demand that the state obey its own constitution and laws.

From 1968 a typed bulletin called the Chronicle of Current Events recorded arrests, trials and prison conditions in plain, factual language, without commentary, and was passed from hand to hand. Its calm tone was itself a statement. The authorities answered with prison, exile and, increasingly, psychiatry. Dissenters were diagnosed as mentally ill and confined in psychiatric hospitals, often under a vague label of slow-moving schizophrenia, a diagnosis that implied that anyone who opposed the system must be sick.

Other groups pressed claims of their own. Jews who were refused permission to emigrate became known as refuseniks. In the United States the Jackson to Vanik amendment of 1974 tied trade benefits to the freedom to emigrate, and Soviet emigration rose and fell with relations between the two powers. Crimean Tatars campaigned to return to the homeland from which Stalin had deported them, and believers organized to defend their churches.

The end of the Brezhnev era

In December 1979 Soviet troops entered Afghanistan, beginning a costly war. Brezhnev himself, visibly ill, died in November 1982. His successor, Yuri Andropov, a former head of the KGB, launched a discipline campaign in which police raided shops, cinemas and bathhouses to catch people absent from work. Andropov died in February 1984, and his successor, Konstantin Chernenko, died in March 1985. Three funerals in under three years made the gerontocracy impossible to ignore.

Worked example: eight people on Red Square

On 21 August 1968, Warsaw Pact armies invaded Czechoslovakia to end the reforms of the Prague Spring. Four days later, at noon on 25 August, eight people sat down on Red Square near the old stone platform called Lobnoye Mesto and unfurled small banners. One read "For your freedom and ours", an old slogan of nineteenth century Polish rebels. Among the protesters was the poet Natalya Gorbanevskaya, who had brought her infant son in a pram. Within minutes plainclothes police tore down the banners, beat several protesters and drove them away.

The outcome followed the pattern of the time. One protester was released after claiming to be a passerby. Several were sentenced to exile or labor camp. Viktor Fainberg, who had teeth knocked out during the arrest, was sent to a psychiatric hospital. Gorbanevskaya was at first released because of her baby and later confined in a psychiatric hospital too.

Was such a protest pointless? It changed nothing in Prague. But it showed that the official claim of unanimous support was false, and in later years many Czechs said it mattered to them that a few Soviet citizens had spoken. The protesters knew they would be arrested. They acted anyway, on the idea that a person keeps their dignity by refusing to lend their silence to a wrong.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Brezhnev's "stability of cadres" mean in practice?
2. What paid for Soviet grain imports in the 1970s?
3. What did the government do when infant mortality rose in the 1970s?
4. Why were Sinyavsky and Daniel put on trial in 1966?
5. What did the Chronicle of Current Events do?
6. How did the state use psychiatry against dissenters?
7. What did the Jackson to Vanik amendment of 1974 do?
8. What did Andropov's discipline campaign involve?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia