A younger leader
In March 1985 the Politburo chose Mikhail Gorbachev, at fifty-four its youngest member. He believed the system could be saved by making it work better. His first big campaign, against alcohol, cut vodka production, uprooted vineyards and raised prices. Drinking fell for a time and the life expectancy of men rose, but the state lost a large share of its tax revenue, and home distilling emptied the shops of sugar.
Chernobyl
On 26 April 1986 reactor number four at the Chernobyl nuclear plant in Ukraine exploded during a safety test. The nearby town of Pripyat was evacuated about a day and a half later. Moscow said almost nothing for days, until radiation alarms went off at a nuclear plant in Sweden and the Swedish government demanded an explanation. Gorbachev did not speak about the disaster on television until 14 May. The cover-up, and the anger it caused, helped convince him that the system's habit of secrecy was itself a danger, and he pressed harder for openness in the press.
Opening up
The signs came quickly. In December 1986 the physicist and human rights campaigner Andrei Sakharov, exiled to the closed city of Gorky since 1980, was allowed to return to Moscow after Gorbachev telephoned him personally. Banned books were published, films were taken off the shelf and newspapers began to fill the "blank spots" of history. The society Memorial, founded in 1989, began recording the names of the victims of repression. The government admitted the secret protocols of the 1939 pact with Germany and, in 1990, the truth about Katyn.
Economic reform went less well. A law of 1988 allowed small private businesses to operate as cooperatives, and thousands of cafes, workshops and trading firms appeared. But prices remained controlled, the budget deficit grew, world oil prices had fallen in 1986, and the old planning system was weakened without being replaced. By 1990 shortages were worse than at any time since the war.
Elections and nations
The decisive changes were political. In March 1989 voters chose a new Congress of People's Deputies, and many seats had more than one candidate. Dozens of senior party officials were defeated, and millions watched the televised debates, in which Sakharov and others openly criticized the leadership. In 1990 the constitutional article guaranteeing the party's leading role was repealed.
The freedom to speak let long suppressed national grievances into the open. Armenians and Azerbaijanis fought over Nagorno-Karabakh from 1988. In April 1989 troops broke up a demonstration in Tbilisi, killing about twenty people. On 23 August 1989, the fiftieth anniversary of the pact that had doomed their independence, about two million people in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania joined hands in a human chain across the three countries, the Baltic Way. Lithuania declared independence in March 1990, and in January 1991 Soviet troops killed fourteen people at the television tower in Vilnius. In a referendum in March 1991, about three quarters of those who voted backed a renewed union, but six republics refused to take part. That June, Boris Yeltsin won Russia's first popular election for president.
The coup and the end
On 19 August 1991, the day before a new union treaty was to be signed, a group of hardliners declared a state of emergency. Gorbachev was held at his holiday home in Crimea. In Moscow, Yeltsin climbed onto a tank outside the Russian parliament building and called for resistance. Tens of thousands of people built barricades, three young men were killed in a clash with armored vehicles, and the army would not storm the building. The coup collapsed within three days. It had been launched to save the union, and it destroyed it.
The republics declared independence one after another. On 8 December the leaders of Russia, Ukraine and Belarus signed the Belovezha Accords, which replaced the union with a Commonwealth of Independent States. Gorbachev resigned on 25 December, and the red flag came down over the Kremlin that evening.
Why did it end?
Explanations differ in emphasis. Some stress economic decline; others stress the national movements, Gorbachev's refusal to use mass force, or officials who quietly turned state property into private wealth. The anthropologist Alexei Yurchak argued that citizens had long kept performing the official rituals while ceasing to believe their content, which is why the end seemed both impossible and, once it came, unsurprising.
Worked example: Ukraine votes, 1 December 1991
After the coup, Ukraine's parliament declared independence on 24 August 1991 and put the question to the people. On 1 December, with a turnout of about 84 percent, more than 90 percent voted yes. A majority voted yes in every region, including the Russian-speaking east and, more narrowly, Crimea. Without Ukraine, its second largest republic, no renewed union made sense, and a week later the Belovezha Accords followed.
The vote is worth weighing against the referendum of March 1991, when many of the same people had also backed a renewed union. Both results can be read honestly. In March the question was vague and the alternative uncertain; by December the coup had shown what the center might do, and independence had become a real choice. The lesson for anyone judging political legitimacy is that consent must be asked for clearly and freely, and that a state which never asks cannot know what its people want.
