Skip to main content

Charles Sanders Peirce (1839 to 1914) may have been the most original philosopher America has produced, and he died poor and nearly forgotten. He was a working scientist, measuring gravity with pendulums for the Coast Survey for some thirty years, and a pioneer of modern logic. He lost his only regular university post, at Johns Hopkins, in 1884, partly over scandal surrounding his divorce and remarriage. He spent his last decades in a farmhouse near Milford, Pennsylvania, writing tens of thousands of pages that were published mostly after his death. James quietly organized lectures and money to help him.

How to make our ideas clear

Peirce first set out the pragmatic principle in a series of articles for Popular Science Monthly in 1877 and 1878. The second of these, "How to Make Our Ideas Clear," distinguished three grades of clarity. The first is familiarity: you can use a word and recognize examples. The second is definition: you can state the word's meaning in general terms. Peirce thought philosophers had stopped there, and he proposed a third grade.

His rule, now called the pragmatic maxim, reads: "Consider what effects, that might conceivably have practical bearings, we conceive the object of our conception to have. Then, our conception of these effects is the whole of our conception of the object." In plainer words, if you want to know what you mean by a concept, list the effects you expect it to have on experience and action. That list is the meaning.

The hard diamond

Peirce's best known illustration was hardness. What do we mean by calling a thing hard? That it will not be scratched by many other substances. The whole concept lies in such expected results: try to scratch it, and it resists. He then asked a puzzling question about a diamond that forms and is destroyed without ever being tested. Was it hard? His early answer suggested the question was merely about how we choose to speak. Later he changed his mind, insisting that the diamond really would have resisted scratching. Peirce came to stress "would-be's": real tendencies that hold whether or not anyone tests them. That shift matters, because it shows his maxim was never meant to reduce reality to what actually happens to be observed.

Clearing away empty disputes

Peirce thought the maxim could dissolve many old disputes. If two theories predict exactly the same experiences under every possible test, they do not really differ in meaning, however different their words. He applied this, controversially, to the Catholic and Protestant dispute over the bread and wine of communion. Since everyone agreed that the bread looks, tastes and acts like bread, he suggested that saying it is something else entirely adds no practical meaning. It can clean up confused talk, but it can also seem to dismiss questions that matter deeply to people.

It is important to see what the maxim is not. Peirce did not say an idea means whatever is useful or pleasant to believe. He meant conceivable practical effects, including the results of experiments that may never be run. His maxim was a tool of logic, meant for scientists, and he thought it would let inquirers recognize when they were genuinely disagreeing.

A name ugly enough

When James made pragmatism popular, he gave it a broader and more personal flavor, and other writers stretched it further still. Peirce grew uneasy. In a 1905 article, "What Pragmatism Is," he announced that he would now call his own doctrine "pragmaticism," a word he said was "ugly enough to be safe from kidnappers." Peirce wanted to keep the maxim tied to scientific method and to the idea of a reality that does not depend on what any of us happens to think.

Peirce also built a large system around the maxim: a theory of signs, called semiotics, which divided signs into icons, indexes and symbols; a theory of categories; and work in logic that anticipated later developments. For the beginner, the core lesson is simple and durable: test the meaning of your words by asking what would be different if they were true.

Worked example: is the bridge safe?

A town council receives a report saying an old footbridge is "structurally sound." One councillor is reassured. Another asks what the phrase actually means. Peirce's maxim tells her how to ask. What effects would follow if the bridge is sound? It would carry a certain load without cracking, resist flood water at a certain height, and show no growing sag over the next few years.

Now the claim has content that can be checked. The engineers can say what load they tested, what flood level they assumed and how often the bridge should be inspected. If the report cannot answer such questions, the councillor has learned something important: the word "sound" was carrying more reassurance than meaning. Notice, too, Peirce's later point about would-be's. The bridge's strength is real even before the heaviest crowd ever crosses it. The maxim does not say the bridge is sound only after the test; it says the meaning of "sound" is spelled out by what tests would show.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where did Peirce first set out the pragmatic principle?
2. According to Peirce's maxim, what is the whole of our conception of an object?
3. By Peirce's account, what do we mean when we call a thing hard?
4. What did Peirce come to stress in his later view of the untested diamond?
5. What did Peirce mean by practical effects in his maxim?
6. Why did Peirce rename his view pragmaticism in 1905?
7. What was Peirce's work for the Coast Survey?
8. Which three kinds of sign did Peirce's semiotics distinguish?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia