Skip to main content

In 1097 the grandsons of Yaroslav met at Lyubech, a town on the Dnieper north of Kyiv, and kissed the cross to seal a promise of peace. Within days, two of them had seized a third, Prince Vasylko of Terebovl, and put out his eyes. The century and a half after Yaroslav is a story of brilliant towns, endless family feuds and a slow drift from one Rus toward many.

The problem of succession

Yaroslav's sons inherited a family business without a clear rule for passing it on. In principle Kyiv went to the senior member of the dynasty, and the other princes moved up a ladder of cities as their elders died. In practice, uncles and nephews quarreled over who was senior, and princes whose fathers died before reaching Kyiv lost their claim and had every reason to fight.

New nomads, new pressures

The steppe changed too. From the 1060s the Pechenegs gave way to a new confederation of Turkic nomads, the Cumans, whom the Rus called Polovtsians. In 1068 they defeated Yaroslav's sons on the Alta River. The people of Kyiv gathered in assembly and demanded weapons and horses to fight on. When Prince Iziaslav refused, they freed a captive prince, Vseslav of Polotsk, and made him their ruler. Townspeople could make and unmake princes when they felt betrayed. The Cumans were not only enemies. Princes hired them as allies in their own wars and married the daughters of Cuman khans, so that many Rus rulers had Cuman mothers or wives.

Lyubech and Monomakh

At Lyubech the princes agreed that each should hold his father's lands, his patrimony. This was meant to end the fighting by giving each branch of the family a fixed home. Instead it pointed toward a land of separate principalities, and the blinding of Vasylko showed how fragile oaths were.

The prince most associated with holding things together was Vladimir Monomakh, whose mother is usually said to have been a relative of the Byzantine emperor Constantine Monomachos. He led joint campaigns that pushed the Cumans back. In 1113, after riots broke out in Kyiv against the officials and moneylenders of the late prince, the townspeople invited him to rule, and he issued rules limiting interest on loans. Monomakh also left an Instruction for his children, a rare personal text in which a medieval ruler looks back on his life. He recalls his campaigns and hunts, and urges his sons to protect widows and orphans and not let the strong destroy the weak. He told them not to put anyone to death, even someone who deserved it.

The breakup

After Monomakh's son Mstislav died in 1132, the Rus lands split into a dozen or more principalities ruled by branches of the dynasty. Kyiv stayed the most prestigious prize and the seat of the metropolitan, but it changed hands again and again. In 1169 an army sent by Andrei Bogoliubsky sacked Kyiv. Andrei, prince of Vladimir in the northeast, did not move there; he stayed in his own capital and handed Kyiv to a junior relative. Seniority now came from power, not from sitting in Kyiv.

The regions went different ways. In Novgorod, the town assembly called the veche chose the city's officials and its archbishop, and invited princes on contract, expelling them when they displeased the city; the town grew rich on Baltic trade. In the northeast, Vladimir-Suzdal grew under strong princes in newer towns where the old landed nobility was weak. In the southwest, Galicia-Volhynia had powerful boyars and close ties to Poland and Hungary, and its prince Daniel was crowned king by a papal envoy in 1253. Meanwhile the phrase "the Rus land" in twelfth-century chronicles often meant the region around Kyiv, Chernihiv and Pereiaslav. A Novgorod chronicler could write of someone traveling "to Rus" when he went to Kyiv.

Worked example: the Tale of Igor's Campaign

In 1185 Prince Igor of Novgorod-Siverskyi led a raid against the Cumans without his cousins. His army was destroyed and he was captured, though he later escaped. A poem about the disaster, the Tale of Igor's Campaign, calls on the princes to stop feuding and defend the Rus land together. It is the most famous work of early Rus literature, and it has a strange history. A collector, Count Aleksei Musin-Pushkin, found a single manuscript in the 1790s and published it in 1800. The manuscript then burned when Moscow was set on fire in 1812.

With no original to check, some scholars argued the poem was an eighteenth-century forgery. The French scholar André Mazon and later the Soviet historian Aleksandr Zimin made the strongest case, pointing to parallels with a later text about a fourteenth-century battle. Defenders answered with linguistic evidence. In 2004 Andrei Zaliznyak argued that the poem follows fine rules of twelfth-century grammar that no one in the 1790s understood, so a forger would have needed knowledge scholars gained only later. Most specialists now accept the poem as medieval. The case shows how historians test a source with no physical original: they ask what a forger could have known, and whether the text contains knowledge that only an author of the claimed date could have had.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who replaced the Pechenegs on the steppe from the 1060s?
2. What did Kyivans do when Iziaslav refused them arms in 1068?
3. What did the princes agree at Lyubech in 1097?
4. What did Monomakh urge in his Instruction to his sons?
5. What happened to Kyiv in 1169?
6. What was the veche of Novgorod?
7. Who was crowned king by a papal envoy in 1253?
8. What did "the Rus land" often mean in twelfth-century chronicles?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia