Skip to main content

In 1223 Cuman chiefs rode into the Rus lands with news of strange invaders from the east, warning that the Rus would be next. Within twenty years Kyiv lay in ruins and the princes of Rus were traveling to the camps of steppe khans to beg permission to rule. The Mongol conquest did not destroy the Rus, but it pulled their lands apart for good.

The first warning

The Cuman khan Kotian appealed to his son-in-law, Prince Mstislav of Galich, and several princes marched into the steppe with the Cumans. They met the Mongol vanguard on the Kalka River and were routed. Captured princes, the chronicle says, were crushed under wooden boards on which the victors sat to feast. Then the invaders vanished, and the princes went back to their quarrels.

Conquest

The Mongols returned in force in the winter of 1237. Riding along frozen rivers, they took Riazan in December and the city of Vladimir in February 1238, where the grand prince's family died in a burning church. The grand prince himself fell in battle on the Sit River in March. The army turned back before reaching Novgorod, probably because the spring thaw turned the forests to swamp, while the small town of Kozelsk held out for weeks. In 1239 and 1240 the Mongols moved south, taking Pereiaslav and Chernihiv, and in December 1240 they stormed Kyiv. The townspeople's last refuge was the Church of the Tithe, and its vaults collapsed under the crowd who had climbed onto them. In 1241 the army went on into Poland and Hungary, then withdrew.

Living under the Horde

The Mongols did not occupy the forest lands. They ruled from the steppe, through the khanate later called the Golden Horde, and demanded submission, tribute and soldiers. Rus princes had to travel to the khan's camp to receive permission to rule, and the khans played them against one another. Some paid with their lives. Mikhail of Chernihiv was executed at Batu's camp in 1246 after refusing to bow before a pagan image, and the church honored him as a martyr. In the 1250s Mongol officials counted the population for taxes.

The church fared well. The khans exempted it from tribute and protected its property, and monasteries grew rich in the following centuries. The church also moved. Kyiv was half ruined, and in 1299 Metropolitan Maximus moved his residence to Vladimir in the northeast. His successor Peter spent his last years in Moscow, then a modest town, and died there in 1326. Later metropolitans stayed, and that gave Moscow's princes a prestige their small town had not earned.

Two leaders, two strategies

Alexander Nevsky of Novgorod and Daniel of Galicia faced the same dilemma. Alexander won fame fighting western enemies, defeating a Swedish force on the Neva in 1240 and crusading knights on frozen Lake Peipus in 1242. Toward the Mongols he chose cooperation with the Horde: he went to the khans, received the title of grand prince of Vladimir in 1252, and when Novgorod resisted the census he forced the city to submit. Daniel also went to Batu, in 1245, and the Galician chronicle grieves over the humiliation of a great prince made to drink mare's milk at the khan's command. Daniel then looked west, accepting a crown from the pope in hope of a crusade against the Mongols that never came. Admirers call Alexander a realist who saved what could be saved; critics call him a collaborator. Daniel's western gamble produced a kingdom that lasted less than a century.

East and west

Over the following century the old Rus lands were divided between two new powers. In the northeast, the princes of Moscow, descended from Alexander Nevsky, rose by serving the khans as tribute collectors and by buying land. Ivan I, nicknamed Kalita, "moneybag," won the grand princely title around 1330. In the west and south, the pagan grand dukes of Lithuania took over most of the Rus principalities, including Kyiv by the 1360s. Their state became largely Orthodox and Rus in population, and its chancery wrote in a Rus written language, often called Ruthenian, which stands behind modern Belarusian and Ukrainian writing. Galicia passed to the Polish crown after 1340. The heirs of Kyiv now lived in rival states.

Worked example: how heavy was the yoke?

Russian writers later called Mongol rule the "Tatar yoke," and the phrase framed the debate for centuries. The historian Nikolai Karamzin, in the early nineteenth century, blamed the Mongols for cutting Rus off from Europe, yet also thought they helped Moscow become an autocracy. In the 1920s, émigré thinkers known as Eurasianists turned the picture around, arguing that Russia was a Eurasian civilization shaped positively by steppe statecraft. Charles Halperin argued that Rus writers kept a kind of silence, rarely describing how they actually lived with the Horde. Donald Ostrowski argued that Moscow borrowed key institutions, such as its tax collection, post stations and parts of its military organization, from the Horde. Others insist that Moscow's political ideas came mainly from Byzantium and the church. The useful lesson is to separate two questions: how destructive the conquest was, which is not in doubt for 1237 to 1240, and how far Mongol rule shaped the institutions that followed, which remains genuinely debated.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What happened to princes captured at the Kalka, per the chronicle?
2. Which great city did the Mongol army of 1238 fail to reach?
3. What happened at the Church of the Tithe in December 1240?
4. Why was Mikhail of Chernihiv executed in 1246?
5. What did the khans grant the Rus church?
6. Where did Metropolitan Maximus move his residence in 1299?
7. What policy did Alexander Nevsky follow toward the Mongols?
8. What was Ivan I of Moscow's nickname?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia