Skip to main content

Public schools, unemployment insurance, disability support, food assistance, pensions, disaster relief: modern societies pool money to protect people from risks no one can fully carry alone. These programs are often described in terms of laws, budgets and agencies. Underneath all of that is something less visible. They work only because most people, most of the time, pay what they owe and take only what they are entitled to. When that personal integrity weakens, the programs weaken with it, and the people hurt first are usually those who need them most.

Shared pots and free riders

Many shared programs work like a common pot. Everyone pays in through taxes or contributions; people draw out when they fall on hard times. A pot like this faces a built-in temptation. A free rider is someone who takes the benefits of a shared arrangement without paying their fair share of its costs. The free rider reasons that his own contribution is tiny, that the pot will survive without it, and that he will still be covered. Each such calculation looks harmless. But if many people make it, the pot runs dry, or the honest contributors must pay far more to keep it full.

The same logic applies on the receiving side. A person who claims benefits he is not entitled to, or exaggerates a need, is drawing from the pot as if he had paid for a protection he did not need. Each false claim is small compared with the national budget. But false claims, like free riding, add up, and they change how everyone else behaves.

Conditional cooperators

Economists study this behavior with a simple laboratory game. Players each receive some money and choose how much to put into a common pot. The pot is multiplied and split evenly among everyone, whether they contributed or not. The group does best if everyone contributes everything, but each individual does best by keeping his money and taking a share of what others put in.

The results are remarkably consistent. Most groups start out cooperative, but when the game is repeated, contributions tend to decline round after round as cooperators notice free riders and pull back. In a 2001 study, Urs Fischbacher, Simon Gächter and Ernst Fehr sorted players by their strategies. About half were conditional cooperators, people willing to contribute as long as others did, while roughly a third were free riders.

This finding matters. Most people are neither saints nor cheats. They are willing to do their part if they believe others are doing theirs. A few free riders can therefore unravel the cooperation of many honest people, because they teach the honest that contributing is for suckers. In a related experiment, Fehr and Gächter found that when players could pay to punish free riders, contributions stayed high instead of collapsing. People care enough about fairness to spend their own money defending it.

Tax morale

The same pattern appears in real tax systems. Economists have long noticed a puzzle. In many countries, the chance of being audited is low and penalties are modest, so a purely selfish calculation would suggest widespread cheating. Yet most people pay most of what they owe. Researchers use the term tax morale for this inner willingness to pay taxes, beyond what fear of audits and fines alone would explain. Tax morale rises when people believe others pay too, when they think the money is spent fairly, and when they trust the government. It falls when cheating seems normal.

Who deserves help

Public support for social programs depends on whether people believe the help goes to those who deserve it. The Dutch sociologist Wim van Oorschot, in a 2000 study, identified several criteria people use to judge this. One of them he called control: people are more willing to help those whose need is not their own fault. Others concerned the recipient's attitude, whether the recipient had contributed or would contribute in return, closeness of identity, and the degree of need.

This tells us how fraud does its damage. Fraud does not just take money. It changes the public's picture of who receives help. When voters come to believe that many recipients are cheats, they stop seeing the recipients as people in genuine need, and support for the programs falls.

Slow erosion

The Swedish economist Assar Lindbeck raised a related concern. He argued that social norms against living on benefits when one could work erode slowly, so a generous system can seem to work well for years before habits change. When older generations who held strong work norms are replaced by younger ones who saw benefits claimed casually, behavior can shift, and the system becomes much more expensive to sustain. Economists still dispute how large this effect is. The point is not that generous programs must fail, but that their survival depends on norms that each generation must renew.

Perception and reality

Public belief about fraud often runs far ahead of the facts. In a 2013 British survey for the Royal Statistical Society and King's College London, respondents guessed that about 24 pounds of every 100 pounds spent on benefits was claimed fraudulently, while the official estimate was about 70 pence. This gap is itself a problem. Exaggerated beliefs about fraud can undermine support for honest claimants just as real fraud does.

Two lessons follow, and an honest course should state both. Real fraud must be taken seriously, because a few cases can damage public trust far beyond their cost. And honest claimants must not be treated as suspects. Claiming help that you are legally entitled to is not cheating; it is the program working as designed. In many programs, large numbers of eligible people never claim at all.

Worked example: pandemic unemployment insurance

When the COVID-19 pandemic struck in 2020, millions of people lost their jobs within weeks, and governments rushed to expand unemployment insurance. In the United States, many states relaxed identity checks so that money could reach people quickly. This was a humane choice: the alternative was leaving families without rent money while paperwork piled up.

The speed created an opening. The Government Accountability Office later estimated that fraud in pandemic unemployment programs was probably between 100 billion and 135 billion dollars. Some was committed by organized criminal rings using stolen identities. Some was committed by ordinary people who claimed benefits they knew they were not entitled to, telling themselves the government would not miss it.

The consequences fell on the honest. States tightened identity checks, and many genuine claimants waited weeks or months for help. Workers who had lost their jobs found accounts frozen because criminals had already filed in their names. Public debate shifted from how to help people to how to stop cheats, and some voters concluded that such programs could not be trusted.

Each person who filed a false claim may have thought only of their own family's needs. The combined effect was slower help for millions of other families, higher costs for every taxpayer and weaker support for the next emergency program. That is the free-rider problem in its real form.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What is a free rider?
2. What happens to contributions in repeated common pot games?
3. What share of players did Fischbacher and colleagues find were conditional cooperators?
4. What did Fehr and Gächter find when players could punish free riders?
5. What does the term tax morale describe?
6. What did van Oorschot's control criterion concern?
7. What did Lindbeck argue about norms against living on benefits?
8. In the 2013 British survey, how did guesses about benefit fraud compare with the official estimate?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia