Skip to main content

In 1998 Amartya Sen received the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences, partly for his work on welfare economics and the measurement of poverty. The next year he published Development as Freedom, based on lectures he had given at the World Bank. Its thesis is stated in the title: development should be understood as expanding the real freedoms people enjoy, not simply as rising income or industrial output.

Income is not the measure

Sen did not dismiss economic growth. Growth can pay for schools, clinics and pensions, and rising incomes give people more choices. But he argued that income is a poor guide to how people actually live. His most striking comparison concerned survival. Using data from around 1990, he showed that African American men were less likely to reach old age than men in China or the Indian state of Kerala, even though their incomes were far higher. Poor health care, violence and social exclusion inside a rich country could cut lives short more than low income did in much poorer places.

Another case was what Sen called the missing women. In a 1990 essay he estimated that over 100 million women were missing from the world's population, compared with the numbers one would expect if women and girls received the same care as men and boys. The shortfall was concentrated in parts of Asia and North Africa. No income figure would reveal it. It shows up only when we ask who survives.

Two roles for freedom

Sen gave freedom two roles. Its constitutive role is that freedom is itself the main end of development: being able to read, speak freely, avoid early death and take part in public life are part of what it means to be developed. Its instrumental role is that freedoms help produce one another. Education raises earnings, political voice pushes governments to act, and paid work for women improves the survival chances of girls.

Five instrumental freedoms

Sen named five kinds of instrumental freedom. Political freedoms include free speech, elections and the right to criticize authorities. Economic facilities are the opportunities to use resources for consumption, production or exchange, including access to credit and markets. Social opportunities are arrangements for schooling and health care. Transparency guarantees are the openness and trust that let people deal with one another, and they guard against corruption. Protective security is the safety net, such as unemployment benefits or emergency relief, that keeps people from falling into abject misery. These freedoms reinforce each other, so a country that pursues only one, such as markets without schools, or schools without free speech, will fall short.

Markets and the state

Sen's view of markets is often misread. He praised the freedom to exchange as valuable in itself, much as the freedom to speak is, and pointed out that bonded laborers lacked a basic freedom precisely because they could not sell their labor where they chose. But he held that markets are a freedom yet cannot supply schooling, health care or public debate alone. A good society needs both lively markets and public action, each checking the other's failures.

Public reasoning

Who decides which freedoms matter most? Sen's answer was democratic discussion. He resisted writing a fixed list of capabilities, arguing that capabilities should be selected and weighted through public reasoning in each society, which can revise its views as people learn. Critics, including Nussbaum, worried that this leaves the approach too open: without some fixed content it cannot tell a government plainly that it has failed. Sen replied that some capabilities, such as avoiding preventable death, would clearly survive any reasonable debate.

An even-handed assessment

Supporters credit Development as Freedom with changing the vocabulary of aid agencies, which now speak routinely of human development and empowerment. Critics on the left say Sen's emphasis on individual freedom pays too little attention to power and to the structure of the world economy. Critics on the right say that expanding capability through state services may crowd out the markets and growth that pay for them.

Worked example: the Kerala puzzle

Kerala, a state on India's southwest coast, has long been a test case. For decades its income per person was close to or below the Indian average, yet by the 1990s its life expectancy and literacy were far above India's as a whole and closer to those of much richer countries. Sen and his colleague Jean Drèze traced this to a long history of public action: an early spread of schooling, including for girls, active political movements, land reform, and widely available clinics and subsidized food. In Sen's terms, social opportunities and political freedoms did work that income alone did not. Critics point out that Kerala also suffered high unemployment and slow growth for many years, and that much of its later prosperity came from money sent home by workers abroad. A careful reader can accept both points. Kerala shows that capability can rise ahead of income, and it also shows that sustaining those gains needs an economy that creates jobs.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Development as Freedom define development?
2. What did Sen's survival comparison show about African American men?
3. How many women did Sen estimate in 1990 were missing?
4. What is the constitutive role of freedom, in Sen's account?
5. What are transparency guarantees?
6. What did Sen call the safety net that keeps people from abject misery?
7. How did Sen think capabilities should be selected and weighted?
8. What did Sen hold about markets?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia