
A woman who carried bricks on her head at a kiln in southern India for decades was paid less than the men beside her and never promoted, and she did not regard any of it as unfair. Should her contentment settle the matter? A small circle of economists and philosophers, led by Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum, said no, and in saying so they changed how the United Nations ranks nations and how many governments think about poverty, gender and disability.
Their proposal sounds modest: judge lives by what people are actually free to do and be, not by what they own or how satisfied they claim to feel. Pressed hard, it unsettles old questions. How can a richer group die younger than a poorer one? Is a ramp charity or justice? Can one number rank the world fairly? The result is a sharper eye for development statistics, the means to argue both sides of a live dispute with Rawlsian and resourcist critics, and the habit of asking of any policy the question this tradition makes hard to dodge: free to do what, exactly?
CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia