By the late 1980s South Africa had reached a stalemate. The state could not crush the resistance, and the resistance could not overthrow the state. Secretly, both sides had started talking. From 1985 Mandela, still a prisoner, met the justice minister, Kobie Coetsee, and later other officials, and in 1987 a group of Afrikaner intellectuals met ANC leaders in Dakar, Senegal.
Opening the door
In 1989 Botha suffered a stroke, and F. W. de Klerk replaced him, first as party leader and then as president. The fall of the Berlin Wall that November weakened the government's claim that the ANC was a Soviet tool and reduced the Soviet support the ANC could count on. On 2 February 1990, in a speech to parliament, de Klerk announced the unbanning of the ANC, the PAC and the Communist Party and the release of political prisoners. Nine days later Mandela walked out of Victor Verster prison after twenty-seven years. In the Pretoria Minute of August 1990 the ANC suspended its armed struggle, and in 1991 parliament repealed the Population Registration Act, the Group Areas Act and the Land Acts.
Historians still argue over de Klerk's motives. Some see a reformer who chose to give up power; others see a leader who hoped to negotiate protections that would preserve white influence, and who gave way step by step under pressure. Both can be partly true. In 1993 Mandela and de Klerk shared the Nobel Peace Prize, an award that honored a partnership neither man much enjoyed.
Talks amid violence
Formal talks, called CODESA, began in December 1991. When the National Party lost a by-election to the far right, de Klerk called a referendum of white voters, and in March 1992 about 69 percent of them backed continuing the negotiations. Yet the talks soon stalled over how large a majority should be needed to adopt a constitution. Political violence killed thousands in these years, much of it between ANC and Inkatha supporters, and later evidence showed that elements of the security forces had armed and encouraged some attackers. After a massacre at Boipatong in June 1992 left more than forty dead, the ANC withdrew from the talks, accusing the police of complicity. In September soldiers of the Ciskei homeland shot dead marchers at Bisho. Shocked by how close the country stood to the edge, the two sides signed a Record of Understanding and returned to the table.
The interim deal
In April 1993 Chris Hani, leader of the Communist Party and a hero to young militants, was assassinated, and the country seemed ready to explode. Talks survived. In November 1993 negotiators agreed an interim constitution. An elected assembly would write the final constitution, bound by principles agreed in advance and checked by a new Constitutional Court, while a government of national unity ran the country. The far right threatened war, and an armed white militia that rode into Bophuthatswana in March 1994 was routed. Buthelezi's Inkatha Freedom Party agreed to take part only about a week before the election, and its name was added to ballots by sticker.
April 1994
Voting ran from 26 to 29 April, with long lines of people who had never voted before standing for hours in the sun. The ANC won about 62 percent of the vote, the National Party about 20 percent and Inkatha about 10 percent. On 10 May 1994 Mandela was inaugurated as president, with Thabo Mbeki and de Klerk as deputy presidents. South Africans mark 27 April as Freedom Day, the anniversary of the first election open to all adults. Some critics on the left later argued that the deal left economic power untouched; others answered that a settlement without such compromises would have meant civil war.
Worked example: the death of Chris Hani
Hani had been chief of staff of the ANC's armed wing and was among the most popular leaders in the townships. On the morning of 10 April 1993 he was shot dead in his driveway in Boksburg, east of Johannesburg, by Janusz Waluś, a Polish immigrant using a gun supplied by Clive Derby-Lewis, a Conservative Party politician. The killers hoped the murder would set off a race war and wreck the talks.
A white Afrikaner neighbor had noted the gunman's number plate and called the police, and he was arrested within the hour. That evening Mandela, who held no office, went on national television and appealed for calm, pointing out that a white woman had helped bring the killer to justice. There were riots and deaths in the days that followed, but the talks held, and within weeks negotiators fixed the election date. The case shows how an attempt to destroy a fragile process can instead speed it up, and why it matters who speaks to a frightened country when its institutions are still being built.
