Skip to main content

Winning an election was one task. Building a state that would protect everyone, including former enemies, was another, and so was deciding what to do about decades of killing, torture and disappearance. South Africa tried to do both at once, with a new constitution and a commission to uncover the truth about the past.

Writing the constitution

The two houses of the new parliament sat together as a Constitutional Assembly, chaired by Cyril Ramaphosa, and invited the public to make submissions, receiving them in huge numbers. The assembly adopted a text on 8 May 1996. Under the interim deal, the Constitutional Court had to certify that it met the agreed principles, and in September 1996 the court refused to certify the first text, finding among other things that some protections for independent bodies and for the provinces were too weak. The assembly amended it, the court approved the new version, and Mandela signed the constitution at Sharpeville on 10 December 1996. It took effect in February 1997.

What it promises

The constitution names human dignity, equality and freedom among its founding values. Its Bill of Rights bans unfair discrimination on many grounds, including sexual orientation, which made it one of the earliest constitutions in the world to say so. It also protects rights to housing, health care, food, water and social security, which the state must progressively realize within its available resources. Even before it was finished, the court had shown its independence: in 1995, in S v Makwanyane, it struck down the death penalty under the interim constitution. In 2000, in a case brought by Irene Grootboom and others evicted from land near Cape Town, the court ruled the state's housing program unreasonable because it made no provision for people in desperate need. Supporters see such rights as the constitution's moral core; critics worry that courts are drawn into decisions about budgets that elected governments should make.

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission

Parliament created the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 1995. Archbishop Desmond Tutu chaired it, with Alex Boraine as his deputy. One committee heard victims, another handled applications for amnesty and a third recommended reparations. Around 21,000 people gave statements, and from April 1996 televised hearings brought testimony into living rooms across the country. More than 7,000 people applied for amnesty, and most applications were refused. The commission's report of 1998 found that the state was the main perpetrator of gross violations, but that liberation movements, including the ANC, had also committed them, in its camps abroad and in attacks on civilians. The ANC went to court to delay the report and lost; de Klerk won an order blacking out a finding about himself.

The constitution also created independent bodies to check power, among them a Public Protector to investigate abuse in government. Their value was tested in 2016, when the Constitutional Court ruled that President Jacob Zuma had violated the constitution by ignoring the Public Protector's findings about state spending on his private home.

Judging the commission

Defenders argue that the commission did what trials could not. Many families learned how their relatives had died, and some bodies were found and reburied. Prosecutions would have produced few convictions, given destroyed records and loyal witnesses, and might have wrecked the settlement. Critics reply that reparations came late and were small: in 2003 the government paid a single grant of about 30,000 rand to each of some thousands of recognized victims, far less than the commission recommended. Few people refused amnesty were ever prosecuted. The commission's focus on gross violations against individuals also left out the everyday harms of the system, the pass arrests, removals and stolen schooling that touched millions.

The legacy remains contested. South Africa still has some of the highest inequality in the world, and land ownership remains unequal. Yet it has held regular free elections ever since, and in 2024, when the ANC lost its majority for the first time, power changed shape through coalition rather than force.

Worked example: the Biko amnesty hearing

In 1997 five former security policemen applied for amnesty for the death of Steve Biko twenty years earlier. Biko's family had already gone to court to challenge the amnesty law itself, arguing that it took away their right to sue or to see the killers prosecuted. In 1996 the Constitutional Court upheld the law, holding that the interim constitution had authorized amnesty as part of the price of a peaceful transition.

At the hearings the officers repeated that Biko had been hurt in a scuffle. In 1999 the amnesty committee refused them, finding their accounts contradictory and their claim of a political motive unconvincing. Yet in 2003 prosecutors announced that there was not enough evidence to charge anyone. The family gained a public record and a refusal, but no trial. The case captures the commission's dilemma. Partial truth was won at the price of full justice, and families like the Bikos were asked to carry much of the cost of a peace that benefited everyone.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Constitutional Court do with the first text in 1996?
2. Where did Mandela sign the new constitution in December 1996?
3. How does the constitution treat rights to housing and health care?
4. What did the court decide in S v Makwanyane in 1995?
5. What did the court rule in the Grootboom case of 2000?
6. Who chaired the Truth and Reconciliation Commission?
7. What did the commission's 1998 report find?
8. What is a common criticism of the commission's outcome?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia