Skip to main content

Between 1867 and 1868 something without precedent happened in the American South. Hundreds of thousands of men who had been property a few years earlier registered to vote, elected delegates, and helped write new state constitutions. In much of the region a biracial Republican party took power. For a time, one of the most unequal societies in the Western world tried to become a democracy. How it worked, what it achieved and why its critics attacked it remain at the center of debate about the era.

Writing new constitutions

Under the Reconstruction Acts, army officers registered voters in each of the ten states. Black men made up a majority of registered voters in several states, including South Carolina, Mississippi and Louisiana. Conventions met in 1867 and 1868, and about a quarter of their delegates were Black, many of them ministers, teachers, artisans and Union veterans. South Carolina's convention had a Black majority.

The constitutions they wrote were among the most democratic in the nation. They created the first statewide public school systems in much of the South, ended property qualifications for voting and office holding, abolished imprisonment for debt, expanded married women's property rights and built hospitals, asylums and orphanages. Most guaranteed equal civil rights without regard to race. South Carolina's constitution even allowed divorce for the first time in the state's history. Delegates argued over almost everything, including whether to disqualify former Confederates from voting, and many Black delegates, eager for reconciliation, opposed broad disqualification.

The Republican coalition

Southern Republicans drew support from three groups. Freed people formed the great majority of the party's voters. White Southerners who joined were called "scalawags" by their enemies; many were small farmers from hill country who had opposed secession, while others were former Whigs who hoped to attract investment. Northerners who moved South, called "carpetbaggers" after the cheap luggage they supposedly carried, included Union veterans, teachers, Bureau agents and businessmen. Both labels were insults coined by opponents, and historians now use them with care.

Black officeholders

Historians have identified about 2,000 Black men who held public office during Reconstruction, from local constables to members of Congress. In 1870 Hiram Revels of Mississippi became the first Black member of the United States Senate, and that December Joseph Rainey of South Carolina was seated in the House. Blanche K. Bruce of Mississippi served a full Senate term from 1875 to 1881. Robert Smalls, who had escaped slavery in 1862 by steering a Confederate supply ship out of Charleston harbor to the Union fleet, later served several terms in the House. In all, sixteen Black men served in Congress during the Reconstruction years. P. B. S. Pinchback briefly served as acting governor of Louisiana in 1872 and 1873. Many Black officeholders served in local posts, as sheriffs, justices of the peace and county commissioners, where they could protect neighbors from the worst abuses of courts and employers.

The Fifteenth Amendment

Ulysses S. Grant, elected president in 1868, supported a further amendment. The Fifteenth Amendment, ratified in 1870, barred states from denying the vote on account of race, color or previous condition of servitude. Some Republicans had wanted a broader guarantee, but moderates chose a narrower text. It said nothing about literacy tests, poll taxes or property requirements, leaving doors that later legislatures would use to strip Black men of the ballot.

Taxes, debts and corruption

The new governments spent heavily on schools, public buildings and railroad aid, and taxes rose, especially on land, which planters resented. Some officials took bribes, and several states issued railroad bonds that ended in fraud and default. Critics then and later called the governments wasteful and corrupt, and blamed inexperienced Black voters. Defenders answer that corruption was a national disease in these years, from New York's Tweed Ring to the Crédit Mobilier railroad scandal in Congress, and that Southern Republicans were building public institutions almost from nothing, in a region whose old rulers had spent little on ordinary people. Much of the debt, they add, came from railroad schemes that white Democrats and Northern investors had also backed.

Worked example: the South Carolina Land Commission

South Carolina offers a test of these competing judgments. In 1869 its legislature, where Black members held a majority in the lower house, created a Land Commission to buy land and resell it in small plots to settlers on easy credit. It was the only state program of its kind in the Reconstruction South.

Its early years supported the critics. Officials paid inflated prices for poor land, and some pocketed the difference. Yet the program was reorganized in the 1870s, and over the following years thousands of families, most of them Black, bought farms through it, many of which stayed in those families for generations. Ask what a fair verdict looks like. Corruption was real and harmed the very people the program aimed to help. But the program also tried something no other Southern state attempted: using public power to give freed people a share of the land they had worked. A historian who reports only one half of this record will mislead, whichever half it is.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where were Black men a majority of registered voters?
2. What was unusual about South Carolina's constitutional convention?
3. What did the new Southern constitutions create in much of the South?
4. What did opponents call white Southerners who joined the Republican party?
5. About how many Black men held public office during Reconstruction?
6. Who became the first Black member of the United States Senate in 1870?
7. What did the Fifteenth Amendment leave unaddressed?
8. What was the South Carolina Land Commission set up to do?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia