Skip to main content

When Congress met in December 1865, Republicans held large majorities and refused to seat the members sent by Johnson's new Southern governments. They formed a Joint Committee on Reconstruction to study conditions in the South. Over the next two years the balance of power shifted decisively from the White House to Capitol Hill, producing laws and amendments that still shape American citizenship.

Radicals and moderates

Republicans were not united. Radical Republicans, led by Thaddeus Stevens in the House and Charles Sumner in the Senate, wanted to remake Southern society, with votes for Black men, broad protection of civil rights and, for Stevens, land taken from the largest rebel planters. Moderates, the larger group, wanted to secure basic rights for freed people and protect the Union's victory without overturning the federal balance. Johnson's choices drove the moderates toward the Radicals.

The first great vetoes

In early 1866 moderate Senator Lyman Trumbull of Illinois drafted two bills: one extending the Freedmen's Bureau, and the Civil Rights Act of 1866, which declared that people born in the United States were citizens and guaranteed them equal rights to make contracts, sue, give evidence and own property. Johnson vetoed both, calling them unconstitutional and unfair to whites. Congress overrode his veto of the Civil Rights Act in April 1866, and a revised Bureau bill passed over his veto that summer. The vetoes destroyed any hope of cooperation and left the president isolated.

The Fourteenth Amendment

Fearing that a future Congress or court might undo the Civil Rights Act, Republicans wrote its principles into the Constitution. Congress approved the Fourteenth Amendment in June 1866, and it was ratified in July 1868. Its first section made all persons born or naturalized in the United States citizens of the nation and of their state. It barred states from abridging the privileges or immunities of citizens, from depriving any person of life, liberty or property without due process of law, and from denying any person the equal protection of the laws. Its third section barred from office former officials who had sworn to support the Constitution and then joined the rebellion, unless Congress removed the bar by a two-thirds vote. Another section voided Confederate debts and denied any payment to former owners for freed slaves.

Johnson urged the South to reject the amendment, and every former Confederate state did so except Tennessee, which ratified it and was readmitted to Congress in July 1866.

The elections of 1866

Johnson took his case to voters on a speaking tour called the "Swing Around the Circle." He traded insults with hecklers and compared himself to Christ, and the tour backfired badly. In the fall elections Republicans won more than two-thirds of both houses, giving them veto-proof majorities able to override any veto. Voters had judged the president's policy, and they had rejected it.

The Reconstruction Acts

In March 1867 Congress passed the first of several Reconstruction Acts over Johnson's veto. The ten unreconstructed states were divided into five military districts, each under a general. To return to Congress, a state had to hold a convention elected by men of both races, adopt a constitution guaranteeing Black men the vote, and ratify the Fourteenth Amendment. Congress also passed the Tenure of Office Act, which barred the president from removing certain officials without Senate approval.

Impeachment

In February 1868 Johnson tried to remove Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, an ally of Congress. Days later the House impeached Johnson, chiefly for violating the Tenure of Office Act. In the Senate trial his lawyers argued that the act did not cover Stanton, whom Lincoln had appointed, and that a president could not be removed for a policy dispute. On 16 May 1868 the Senate voted 35 to 19 to convict on a key article, one vote short of the two-thirds required. Seven Republicans joined the Democrats to acquit. Some feared weakening the presidency, some disliked the man next in line, Senate president pro tempore Benjamin Wade, and some quietly received assurances that Johnson would stop obstructing Congress. Johnson served out his term with little power, and Democrats declined to nominate him for a full term that summer.

Historians still debate the trial. One view holds that Johnson's obstruction of the law was a real abuse that justified removal. Another holds that acquittal protected the separation of powers from a dangerous precedent.

Worked example: counting to conviction

Work through the arithmetic of May 1868. With ten Southern states still unrepresented, the Senate had 54 members. Two-thirds of 54 is 36. The vote was 35 guilty and 19 not guilty, which adds up to all 54. Had a single senator among the 19 voted to convict, the tally would have been 36 to 18, exactly enough.

That is why Edmund Ross of Kansas, a Republican whose vote was uncertain until he cast it, became famous. Ross was not the only Republican to acquit, so no one senator alone decided the outcome. But the example shows how a constitutional supermajority turns a close political fight into a question of individual conscience, and why each of the seven was treated by his party as a traitor.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who led the Radical Republicans in the House and Senate?
2. What did the Civil Rights Act of 1866 declare?
3. What happened to Johnson's veto of the Civil Rights Act of 1866?
4. What did the third section of the Fourteenth Amendment do?
5. What did Tennessee do that let it rejoin Congress in July 1866?
6. What was the result of the 1866 elections?
7. How did the Reconstruction Acts of 1867 organize the unreconstructed South?
8. How close did the Senate come to removing Johnson in May 1868?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia