Skip to main content

William James (1842 to 1910) came to philosophy by a winding road. He trained as a painter, then as a doctor, and suffered a long depression in his twenties. He became a celebrated Harvard teacher and the author of The Principles of Psychology (1890). Where Peirce wrote for logicians, James wrote for anyone, in a warm, vivid style, and his lectures Pragmatism: A New Name for Some Old Ways of Thinking (1907) made the word famous.

Going round the squirrel

James opened with a story from a camping trip. A squirrel clings to one side of a tree trunk while a man on the other side tries to see it. The man walks around the tree, but the squirrel keeps moving too, always keeping the trunk between them. Does the man go round the squirrel? James's friends had split angrily over the question.

James settled it with a distinction. It depends on what you practically mean by "going round." If you mean passing from north of the squirrel to east, south and west of it, then yes. If you mean being first in front of it, then to its side, then behind it, then no, because the squirrel keeps its belly turned toward him. Once the practical meaning is fixed, nothing remains to argue about. James offered this as a small model of the pragmatic method: settle a dispute by asking what practical difference it would make if one side or the other were right. If none, the dispute is idle.

Cash value

James put the same idea in a commercial metaphor that later caused him trouble. Do not treat a big word such as "God," "Matter" or "Reason" as if naming it ended the inquiry, he said. Instead, "you must bring out of each word its practical cash-value, set it at work within the stream of your experience." Critics in Europe took this as proof that pragmatism was a philosophy of American business. James meant only that an idea, like a banknote, should be redeemable in something real.

Tender and tough minds

James also offered a portrait of philosophical temperament. The tender-minded are rationalistic, idealistic and religious; the tough-minded are empiricist, materialistic and skeptical. Most people, he thought, want something from each side: the facts of science and also hope, freedom and moral meaning. He presented pragmatism as a mediator that could satisfy both, by keeping close to facts while allowing that beliefs about religion or freedom can be judged by what they do in a life.

He borrowed from the Italian writer Giovanni Papini an image for this role. Pragmatism is like a corridor in a hotel, with many rooms opening off it. In one room a person writes an atheist book, in another someone prays, in a third a chemist studies a substance. All must pass through the corridor if they want a practical way in and out of their rooms.

Truth that happens

James's most controversial claims concerned truth. "True ideas are those that we can assimilate, validate, corroborate and verify. False ideas are those that we cannot." He added that truth is not a fixed property sitting inside an idea: "Truth happens to an idea. It becomes true, is made true by events." An idea becomes true as it guides us successfully through experience, connecting one part of it to another without surprises.

Critics were quick. The British philosophers Bertrand Russell and G. E. Moore argued in 1908 and 1909 that James had confused truth with usefulness. A belief might be useful to hold and still be false, and useful to one person but not another. Russell objected that on James's view the claim that other people exist would mean something like "it is useful to believe other people exist," which plainly is not what we mean. James replied in The Meaning of Truth (1909) that he had never meant that any comforting belief counts as true; usefulness had to include fitting all the facts and all our other beliefs over the long run.

The difference with Peirce is real. Peirce tied truth to the long-run agreement of a community of inquirers; James stressed how ideas work out in individual experience. Peirce thought James let personal satisfaction slip into the theory of truth. James thought Peirce's view was too abstract to help people live.

Worked example: is the car reliable?

Two friends argue over whether a used car is "reliable." One points to its famous brand; the other to an old complaint online. James would first ask what practical meaning "reliable" has for them. For a commuter who drives forty minutes each way, it means starting every winter morning and rarely needing a tow.

Once that is fixed, the belief "this car is reliable" can be tested: by its repair record, an inspection, a few months of use. In James's language, the belief will be made true, or false, by events as the owner drives it. Russell's objection still bites, though. A buyer who badly wants a bargain may find it comforting to believe the car is reliable. James's defenders reply that he too would call that belief false the first time the car leaves its owner stranded, because it failed to fit experience.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. In James's squirrel story, what does the answer to the dispute depend on?
2. What did James say we must bring out of each big word such as Reason?
3. How did James describe the tender-minded temperament?
4. Which image did James borrow from Papini for pragmatism?
5. According to James, what are true ideas?
6. What did James mean by saying that truth happens to an idea?
7. What was Russell's main objection to James on truth?
8. How did Peirce's view of truth differ from James's?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia