Skip to main content

A government without a chancellor

After Hongwu's purges there was no chief minister to run the government for the emperor. In theory the ruler did everything himself. In practice no human being could read every report from an empire of tens of millions, so a new body grew up in the palace: the Grand Secretariat. Its members were senior scholars from the Hanlin Academy, the empire's elite literary institution.

The Grand Secretaries had no formal power to command anyone, but they controlled something vital. When a memorial, or official report, reached the palace, the secretaries drafted a proposed reply on a slip of paper attached to it. The emperor then wrote his decision in red ink. Whoever drafted the reply shaped the outcome, and over time the senior Grand Secretary became the most powerful official in the empire.

The eunuch bureaucracy

Alongside the scholars stood a second government made up of eunuchs. Castrated men served in the inner palace because they could not father rival dynasties, and their numbers grew enormously, to many thousands by the late Ming. Their most important office was the Directorate of Ceremonial, which controlled the flow of documents to the emperor and could write his red-ink decisions for him. A lazy or young emperor might let a trusted eunuch decide matters in his name. Officials raised on Confucian classics despised eunuchs as servants who had stepped out of their place, though some eunuchs were capable administrators and generous patrons of temples and charities.

Disaster at Tumu

The danger showed itself in 1449. The eunuch Wang Zhen had great influence over the young Zhengtong emperor and persuaded him to lead an army in person against Esen, leader of the Oirat Mongols, who had been raiding the frontier after a dispute over trade and tribute. Badly planned and badly supplied, the army was caught near a post station called Tumu, northwest of Beijing. Much of it was destroyed, Wang Zhen was killed, and the emperor was taken prisoner.

In Beijing some officials urged the court to flee south to Nanjing. The minister of war, Yu Qian, opposed abandoning Beijing and insisted the capital be defended. He had the captured emperor's brother placed on the throne as the Jingtai emperor and organized the city's defense, and Esen's attack failed. With a new ruler in Beijing, the prisoner had lost his value as a hostage, and in 1450 Esen sent him home. The former emperor lived under guard in a palace in the capital.

In 1457, while Jingtai lay ill, a group of officers and officials restored the former emperor in a palace coup. Among the first acts of the restored ruler was to have Yu Qian executed on charges of treason. Yu was later cleared and honored, and he became a model of the loyal minister who saved the state and was repaid with death.

The duty to speak

Confucian officials believed a minister's highest duty was to remonstrate, to tell the ruler when he was wrong. The Ming had a whole branch of officials, the censors, whose job included criticizing policy and impeaching wrongdoers. Speaking out could be fatal.

In 1521 the Jiajing emperor came to the throne as a cousin of the previous ruler, who had died without a son. Officials wanted him to treat himself as the adopted heir of the line. Jiajing instead wanted to honor his own father, a prince who never reigned, with the full rites of an emperor. The quarrel, known as the Great Rites controversy, lasted years. In 1524 more than two hundred officials knelt and wept at a palace gate in protest. The emperor had them arrested and beaten, and more than a dozen died.

Four decades later, in 1566, the official Hai Rui sent Jiajing a memorial accusing him of neglecting the government for Daoist rituals in pursuit of immortality. According to a famous account, he had bought himself a coffin, expecting to be put to death. He was jailed, and was released after the emperor's death soon afterward.

Worked example: one report, two governments

Follow a single memorial in the 1520s. A provincial governor reports that floods have ruined the harvest in his region and asks for tax relief. His report travels to the capital and enters the palace through the eunuch-run offices.

A Grand Secretary reads it and drafts a reply granting half the relief requested. The draft goes inward to the emperor, but a senior eunuch of the Directorate of Ceremonial reaches it first and, knowing the treasury is short, suggests a smaller sum. The emperor, busy with the Great Rites dispute, accepts the eunuch's version and marks it in red. The scholar's draft and the eunuch's advice have competed, and the eunuch won because he stood closer to the throne.

Nobody in this story broke a law. The system simply put enormous power in the hands of whoever controlled access to one man. When that man was diligent, the rival offices checked each other. When he was distracted, the people of a flooded province depended on the judgment of a palace servant they would never see. Officials like Yu Qian and Hai Rui mattered because they insisted, at great personal risk, that the government existed for those people and not for the court.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Grand Secretaries do with memorials sent to the emperor?
2. What could the eunuchs of the Directorate of Ceremonial do?
3. What did Yu Qian oppose after the disaster at Tumu?
4. Why did Esen release the captured emperor in 1450?
5. What happened to Yu Qian after the former emperor was restored in 1457?
6. What was the Great Rites controversy about?
7. What happened to the officials who protested at the palace gate in 1524?
8. Why, according to a famous account, did Hai Rui buy a coffin?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia