Skip to main content

Uncle against nephew

Hongwu died in 1398. His eldest son had died before him, so the throne passed to a grandson, who reigned as the Jianwen emperor. Hongwu had given his other sons princedoms with their own guards, and Jianwen's advisers feared them. The young emperor began removing princes one by one.

The most powerful, Zhu Di, Prince of Yan, held Beijing, then called Beiping, with seasoned frontier troops. In 1399 he rebelled. He called his war the Jingnan campaign, meaning to clear away disorder, presenting it as a rescue of the throne from evil advisers rather than a seizure of power. After three years of hard fighting his army entered Nanjing in 1402. The palace burned, and Jianwen was never seen again. Rumors that he had escaped disguised as a monk circulated for centuries.

Making the seizure look legal

Zhu Di reigned as the Yongle emperor, and he worked hard to look legitimate. He wanted the respected scholar Fang Xiaoru to write the proclamation announcing his accession. Fang refused, and he was executed for refusing to draft the accession edict. Later tradition added that hundreds of his relatives and students died with him; the numbers grew in the retelling and cannot be checked. Yongle also tampered with time itself. He abolished Jianwen's reign title and had those years recorded as a continuation of Hongwu's reign, as though his nephew had never ruled. The official records of the period were rewritten under his eye.

A new capital

Yongle's power base was the north, and the Mongols remained the chief danger. He decided to move the capital to Beijing, and the move was formally completed in 1421. Building the new palace and walls took hundreds of thousands of workers and vast quantities of timber floated from the southwest.

A northern capital needed southern food. Beijing lay far from the rice lands of the Yangzi delta, and shipping grain by sea was dangerous. From 1411 engineers rebuilt the summit section of the Grand Canal in Shandong, solving the problem of keeping water in the highest stretch. The repairs mattered because the canal could now carry southern grain north to feed the capital and its armies, and in 1415 the court stopped sending tax grain by sea. For the rest of the dynasty, fleets of canal barges were Beijing's lifeline.

The great encyclopedia

Yongle also hired scholars on a giant scale. More than two thousand worked on a compendium of all existing knowledge, gathering whole texts on history, philosophy, medicine, farming, drama and much else. Finished in 1408, the Yongle Encyclopedia ran to 22,877 chapters bound in more than 11,000 volumes. It was so large that it was never printed and existed only as handwritten copies, one made in the 1560s. Fires, neglect and the fighting in Beijing in 1860 and 1900 scattered or destroyed them, and today only a few percent of the work survives, about four hundred volumes held in libraries around the world. Even so, scholars have rebuilt hundreds of otherwise lost books from its pages.

Eyes everywhere and wars abroad

Yongle trusted palace eunuchs, who had helped him during his rebellion, more than he trusted officials. In 1420 he created the Eastern Depot, a secret police agency run by eunuchs that spied on officials and could arrest and torture suspects. He sent eunuch envoys abroad too: the great fleets that sailed the Indian Ocean in his reign were led by eunuch commanders.

He was also a soldier. He led five campaigns in person into Mongolia, and he occupied what is now northern Vietnam from 1407, a war his successors abandoned in 1427. In 1424, aged sixty four, he died on the march home from his fifth Mongolian campaign.

Worked example: reading a usurper's records

Suppose you are a historian studying how Yongle took power. Your main source is the official record of his reign, compiled by scholars who served him and his descendants. It tells you that Jianwen was badly advised, that the princes were wronged, and that Heaven favored the Prince of Yan.

How much can you trust it? First, notice the motive: the record was made by people whose careers depended on the winner's legitimacy. Second, look for what is missing. The years 1399 to 1402 were relabeled as Hongwu's, so Jianwen's own decrees and point of view barely survive. Third, look for sources outside the court's control, such as private writings, local histories and later accounts by scholars who admired Fang Xiaoru.

Each kind of source has its own bias. Later admirers of the loyal martyrs had reasons to exaggerate Yongle's cruelty, just as his own record had reasons to hide it. The historian's task is not to pick a side but to weigh them against each other. What emerges is a ruler of real ability, who built a capital, a canal and an encyclopedia, and who began his reign by killing those who would not call his seizure lawful. Fang Xiaoru's refusal is remembered because it put a limit on power: one man would not lend his words to a lie.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the name of Zhu Di's Jingnan campaign claim?
2. Why was Fang Xiaoru executed?
3. How did Yongle treat the years of Jianwen's reign in official records?
4. Why did rebuilding the Grand Canal matter to Yongle's capital?
5. What was unusual about how the Yongle Encyclopedia existed?
6. How much of the Yongle Encyclopedia survives today?
7. What was the Eastern Depot?
8. How did the Yongle emperor die?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia