Skip to main content

The image most people hold of the Spanish Inquisition is the auto de fe: crowds in a great square, condemned prisoners in strange costumes, smoke rising. The real ceremony was different from the legend in several important ways, and the differences reveal what the tribunal was trying to do.

An act of faith

Auto de fe means act of faith, and the ceremony was designed above all as a public lesson in faith and its defense. It took place on a Sunday or feast day in the main square or a large church. The evening before, a procession carried a green cross, the emblem of the Inquisition, to the place where the ceremony would be held. On the day itself the prisoners walked in procession with officials, clergy and familiares. A sermon was preached, and then the sentences were read aloud one by one, each with a summary of the prisoner's offenses. Reading every sentence could take many hours, and great autos lasted from morning into night.

Most people who appeared at an auto were not executed. The great majority were penitents who abjured, were reconciled, or received penances. For them the auto was a ritual of public shame and return to the Church. In the early decades there were large autos, but later many sentences were read in smaller private ceremonies inside churches or tribunal halls, without public spectacle.

The sambenito

Prisoners wore a penitential garment called the sambenito, a tunic marked according to the sentence. A reconciled penitent wore a yellow one with a diagonal red cross. Those to be executed wore black garments painted with flames and devils, and a tall pointed paper hat called a coroza. Reconciled penitents might have to wear the sambenito in public for months or years.

The garment's life did not end with the sentence. When the period of penance was over, the sambenito was hung in the offender's parish church, with his name and offense written on it. Old ones were replaced with fresh copies when they wore out, so that the shame would be remembered. Grandchildren could walk under the name of a grandparent every Sunday. In a society obsessed with family honor, this public memory was a punishment passed down the generations.

Burning outside the ceremony

The burning itself did not take place during the auto. After the sentences were read, those relaxed to the secular arm were handed over to royal officials, and executions were carried out by the secular authorities at a separate site, usually outside the town, called the quemadero. Prisoners who repented at the last moment were strangled with the garrote before the fire was lit. Those who refused were burned alive. People who had fled or died before sentence could be burned in effigy, and the bones of the dead could be dug up and burned, which also allowed their property to be confiscated from heirs.

Royal spectacle

Monarchs sometimes attended, turning the auto into a display of royal piety. The most famous example took place in the Plaza Mayor of Madrid on 30 June 1680, before the young King Charles II, his queen and the court. It lasted from early morning until long after dark. The painter Francisco Rizi recorded the Madrid auto of 1680 in a vast canvas now in the Prado Museum, showing the stands, the royal balcony and the rows of prisoners in their sambenitos. It was one of the last great public autos of its kind.

Staging such an event took weeks. Carpenters built tiers of seating and platforms, the town bore much of the cost, and nobles competed for the best places. Afterward an official account was often printed. For the Madrid auto, José del Olmo, the familiar who oversaw the building of the stage, published a detailed account in 1680, listing the prisoners, the order of the procession and the dignitaries present. Such accounts were meant to edify, and they are now among the best sources for how the ceremony actually ran.

Worked example: reading the Rizi painting

Look at the painting as a historian would. At first glance it seems to show cruelty on display, but no fire appears in it. The canvas shows tiered seating, banners, clergy, nobility and the king at the center, with the accused gathered on platforms as a crowd watches. The burning, which happened elsewhere and later, is not the subject. What the artist and his patrons chose to show was the order of a Catholic monarchy, with the king, the Church and the people united against error.

That choice tells us something about the purpose of the auto. It was meant to teach the watching crowd the boundaries of the faith, to display mercy toward the penitent as well as severity toward the obstinate, and to bind spectators to the monarchy. Foreign visitors and Protestant writers, by contrast, focused on the flames, and their accounts shaped how the rest of Europe pictured Spain. Both views are partial. The auto was a festival of order for its organizers, a day of terror and humiliation for the accused and their families, and in its rarer fiery cases, a public killing. Holding all three in mind together is the honest way to read it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does auto de fe mean?
2. What was carried in procession the evening before an auto?
3. What happened to most people who appeared at an auto?
4. What was the sambenito?
5. What happened to a sambenito once the penance ended?
6. Where were executions carried out?
7. Who painted the Madrid auto of 1680 on a vast canvas?
8. Who published an account of the Madrid auto of 1680?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia