Skip to main content

Behind the bonfires lay a legal process that was slow, written and secret. Inquisitors were trained lawyers, and their courts kept meticulous records. Understanding how a case moved, step by step, explains both why the tribunal terrified people and why historians today can learn so much from its files.

Edicts and denunciations

Most cases began with a denunciation. Each year, often during Lent, an edict of faith was read aloud in parish churches. It listed signs of heresy that listeners were to watch for: putting on clean clothes on Saturday, refusing pork, washing a body for burial in the Jewish way, saying Muslim prayers, praising Luther, or saying that simple fornication was no sin. Anyone who knew of such acts and stayed silent faced excommunication. Neighbors, servants, relatives and rivals came forward. Some denunciations were sincere; some settled old scores.

The tribunal relied on a network of helpers. Local priests called comisarios gathered testimony in the towns. Lay volunteers called familiares served the tribunal and in return enjoyed privileges such as the right to carry arms and to be tried in the Inquisition's own court. Theologians called calificadores decided whether a reported statement was actually heretical before an arrest was ordered.

Arrest and secrecy

An arrest was usually accompanied by the sequestration of the prisoner's property, which was inventoried and used to pay for his food in prison. If he was convicted it could be confiscated for good, and confiscations helped fund the tribunals. Prisoners were held in the secret prisons of the tribunal, cut off from their families and the outside world. The accused was not told who had denounced him. When the evidence was finally read out, the names of witnesses and details that might identify them were removed.

The defendant was not helpless. He was given a lawyer, though one appointed by the tribunal. He could call favorable witnesses. Above all he could name his enemies: if a hostile witness appeared on the defendant's list of personal enemies, that testimony could be discounted. Since he did not know who had accused him, this was guesswork, and prisoners sometimes listed dozens of names. Cases moved slowly. A year or more could pass between arrest and sentence, and some prisoners waited far longer, their property sequestered and their families left to fend for themselves. The court first gave three formal warnings, urging the prisoner to search his memory and confess, before the prosecutor presented the formal accusation.

Torture under rules

Torture was used by most criminal courts in Europe at the time, and the Inquisition was no exception. Its rules required a vote of the judges, the presence of a physician and a notary, and limits meant to prevent death or lasting injury, though these limits were not always kept. Common methods were the pulley, which hung a prisoner by the wrists, the rack, and the toca, in which water was poured through a cloth into the mouth. A confession made under torture had to be ratified later, away from the torture chamber, to count. In practice torture was applied in a minority of cases, more often in some periods than others. The notaries wrote down everything, including the prisoner's cries and pleas, which is why the records still make painful reading.

Sentences

The outcomes ranged widely. A case could be suspended for lack of proof, which left a stain but no punishment. A defendant could be acquitted, though this was rarer. Many were made to abjure, that is, formally renounce, a light or a vehement suspicion of heresy, with penances such as fasting, fines or exile. Those who confessed real heresy and repented were reconciled to the Church, usually with confiscation, prison or the galleys and the obligation to wear a penitential garment. Those who refused to repent, or who relapsed after an earlier reconciliation, were relaxed to the secular arm, which meant handed to royal officials for execution. The Church did not, in its own words, shed blood; the state did it for the Church.

Worked example: the inquisitor of Córdoba

Procedure did not always restrain inquisitors. From 1499 Diego Rodríguez Lucero ran the tribunal of Córdoba. He extracted confessions describing a vast secret Jewish movement, arrested leading citizens and burned large numbers of people. He even moved against the household of Hernando de Talavera, the elderly archbishop of Granada, who had a converso background. In 1506 a crowd stormed Lucero's prison and freed the inmates, and he fled. Investigations followed, Lucero was removed in 1508, and many of his verdicts were reversed. Talavera was cleared but died in 1507.

Apply the rules to this episode. Secrecy of witnesses made fabrication hard to detect, because no defendant could confront an accuser. Edicts and confessions that named others let one false story multiply. Yet the same written procedure also allowed later investigators to review the files and see that the evidence did not hold. The episode shows the system's two faces: a machine that could manufacture guilt, and a bureaucracy that could, slowly and partially, correct itself when powerful people pushed.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the edict of faith threaten for those who kept silent?
2. What privilege did familiares enjoy?
3. Who decided whether a reported statement was heretical?
4. What was the accused not told?
5. How could a defendant weaken hostile testimony?
6. What made a confession under torture count?
7. What did being relaxed to the secular arm mean?
8. What happened to a prisoner's property at arrest?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia