Skip to main content

After the Revolution, the Haudenosaunee were divided by an international border, squeezed onto small reservations and reserves, and pressed by governments that expected them to disappear. They did not. The story of the last two centuries is one of loss, but also of religious renewal, political struggle and a stubborn insistence that the league is still a government.

A new border, new homes

Many Haudenosaunee who had fought alongside the British moved to Canada after 1783. The largest community became the Six Nations of the Grand River in Ontario, which is today one of the most populous First Nations in Canada. Others stayed in New York, at Onondaga, Tonawanda, Allegany, Cattaraugus, Tuscarora and elsewhere, while some Oneida later moved to Wisconsin and some Seneca and Cayuga to Oklahoma. The Mohawk community of Akwesasne straddles the border between the United States and Canada, as well as the line between Ontario and Quebec, which makes daily life there a puzzle of overlapping jurisdictions. The Grand Council fire was rekindled in two places: at Grand River and at Onondaga, near Syracuse, where the league's council still meets.

Handsome Lake

Around 1800, reservation life was marked by poverty, alcohol and despair. In 1799 a Seneca man named Handsome Lake, the half brother of Cornplanter, fell gravely ill and experienced a series of visions. He began to preach a message called the Gaiwiio, or Good Message. It condemned alcohol and witchcraft, urged the importance of family and ceremony, and blended older Haudenosaunee practices with new moral teachings. The Longhouse religion that grew from his teaching is still practiced today.

Handsome Lake's message also encouraged men to take up plow farming, traditionally women's work, and to live in single family homes. Supporters see this as a creative adaptation that helped communities survive. Critics, including some historians of Haudenosaunee women, argue that it weakened the authority women had held over the fields and households.

Ely S. Parker

The life of the Seneca leader Ely S. Parker shows how Haudenosaunee people moved between worlds. Born in 1828 at Tonawanda, he trained in law and engineering and helped the ethnologist Lewis Henry Morgan gather material for a book on the league. During the Civil War he served as military secretary to General Ulysses S. Grant, and at Appomattox in April 1865 Parker wrote out the final copies of the surrender terms. In 1869 President Grant made him Commissioner of Indian Affairs, the first Native American to hold that post.

Deskaheh goes to Geneva

In the early 1920s the Canadian government pressed the Six Nations to replace their hereditary council with an elected one. The Cayuga chief Levi General, known by his title Deskaheh, argued that the Six Nations were a sovereign people, not subjects of Canada. In 1923 he traveled to Geneva on a Haudenosaunee passport to bring the case to the League of Nations. Several member states showed sympathy, but Britain opposed hearing him, and the League never took up the case. In 1924 Canada imposed an elected band council at Six Nations of the Grand River, and police enforced the change. Deskaheh died in 1925, unable to return home safely. That same year of 1924, the United States Indian Citizenship Act made Native Americans citizens, a status many Haudenosaunee leaders said they had never asked for and did not need.

Land and water

In the 1960s the United States built the Kinzua Dam on the Allegheny River, flooding a large part of the Seneca Allegany territory and forcing hundreds of people to move. The Seneca argued that the dam violated the Treaty of Canandaigua, but the courts allowed it to proceed. Land claims, tax disputes and conflicts over development continue across Haudenosaunee country on both sides of the border.

Worked example: the passport and the lacrosse stick

Lacrosse began as an Indigenous game, and Haudenosaunee tradition calls it the Creator's Game, played for healing and to honor the Creator as well as for sport. Since the 1980s a Haudenosaunee team has competed in international lacrosse in its own right, not as part of the United States or Canada. Players travel on Haudenosaunee passports, which the confederacy has issued for decades.

In 2010 the team was invited to the world championship in England, but British officials would not accept their passports, and the players refused to travel on American or Canadian ones. They missed the tournament. In 2022, when the team was left out of the World Games in Birmingham, Alabama, Ireland gave up its place so the Haudenosaunee could play. The same year the team took the name Haudenosaunee Nationals. A passport and a game might seem small matters, but here they carry the same claim Deskaheh made in Geneva and Canasatego made at Lancaster: that the league is a nation among nations, and that its people can meet the world on their own terms.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which Mohawk community straddles the US and Canadian border?
2. Where does the league's Grand Council still meet in New York?
3. Who began preaching the Gaiwiio, or Good Message?
4. What grew from Handsome Lake's teaching?
5. What did Ely S. Parker do at Appomattox?
6. How did Deskaheh travel to Geneva in 1923?
7. What happened to the Haudenosaunee lacrosse team in 2010?
8. What did the Kinzua Dam flood?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia