Skip to main content

For most of the 1700s the Haudenosaunee lived between two expanding empires, France to the north and west and Britain to the east and south. The league's survival depended on diplomacy as much as on warriors, and its speakers became famous among colonists for their eloquence. That fame later gave rise to one of the most debated claims in American history: that the league helped inspire the United States Constitution.

The Covenant Chain

The league's alliance with the English colonies was called the Covenant Chain. It grew out of agreements made at Albany in the 1670s, after the English took New Netherland from the Dutch. In the language of the alliance, the first link had been a rope, then an iron chain, and finally a chain of silver, which had to be polished regularly at councils to keep it bright. Polishing meant meeting, exchanging gifts, renewing promises and settling grievances. When the English neglected these councils, Haudenosaunee speakers complained that the chain was growing rusty.

The Covenant Chain gave the league influence over other Native nations, since the English often dealt with them through the Haudenosaunee. Critics within those nations, such as the Lenape, resented the arrangement, which sometimes let the league sell or speak for lands that others lived on.

Canasatego and the Albany Congress

In 1744, at a treaty council in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, the Onondaga speaker Canasatego advised the quarreling colonies to unite as the Five Nations had done. Benjamin Franklin's press in Philadelphia printed the treaty proceedings, in which Canasatego is recorded as saying, "Our wise Forefathers established Union and Amity between the Five Nations." He urged the English to follow that example so they would be stronger.

Ten years later, in 1754, delegates from seven colonies met with Haudenosaunee leaders at the Albany Congress. The Mohawk leader Hendrick Theyanoguin sharply criticized the English for neglecting their allies and their own defenses. At the same meeting, Franklin proposed the Albany Plan of Union, which would have created a grand council of colonial delegates under a president general appointed by the Crown. Both the colonial assemblies and the British government rejected it. In a letter of 1751 Franklin had already used the league as an example, remarking, in the dismissive language of his time, that if the Six Nations could form a lasting union, the colonies surely could.

The influence debate

In the 1970s and 1980s, scholars including Donald Grinde and Bruce Johansen argued that the league had a real influence on American founders. They pointed to Canasatego's advice, Franklin's familiarity with the league, the federal idea of separate states joined in a common council, and the frequent contact between colonists and Haudenosaunee diplomats. In 1988 the United States Congress passed a resolution acknowledging the league's contribution to the development of the Constitution.

Critics, led by the anthropologist Elisabeth Tooker, argued that the documentary evidence is thin. The delegates at the 1787 Philadelphia convention left extensive notes, and they rarely mentioned the Haudenosaunee. The Constitution's design, with majority voting, a single executive, representation by population and written rules, differs sharply from the Grand Council's hereditary titles, clan mothers and consensus. The framers cited English law, colonial charters, ancient republics and European writers far more often.

Supporters also point to the bundle of thirteen arrows held by the eagle on the Great Seal, said to echo a Haudenosaunee image of unity. Critics answer that bundled arrows were a familiar European emblem; the lion of the Dutch Republic, for instance, held a sheaf of arrows. A careful position holds two things at once. The colonists clearly knew and admired the league, and Haudenosaunee leaders urged colonial union. But direct influence on the Constitution's actual text is weakly documented, and the case rests more on context than on proof.

Revolution and its aftermath

The Revolution tore the league apart, and the council fire at Onondaga was covered for a time. In 1779 General George Washington ordered an invasion of Haudenosaunee country. Long before, Haudenosaunee speakers had given Washington's family the name Town Destroyer, and in 1790 the Seneca leader Cornplanter wrote to him, "When your army entered the country of the Six Nations, we called you the Town Destroyer." After the war, the United States treated the Haudenosaunee as defeated enemies, and a series of treaties and sales took most of their land.

Worked example: the Treaty of Canandaigua

In November 1794, at Canandaigua in western New York, the United States signed a treaty with the Six Nations. The federal negotiator was Timothy Pickering. The treaty recognized the lands of the Seneca and other nations and promised that the United States would never claim them or disturb the people in their use. In return, the nations agreed not to claim other lands. The United States also promised an annual payment of goods worth 4,500 dollars.

That payment is still made. Each year, bolts of cotton cloth are delivered to Haudenosaunee communities, and families receive their share. The amount is tiny, and many recipients see the cloth not as money but as proof: the delivery shows that the United States still recognizes the treaty. When the Haudenosaunee argue about land and sovereignty today, the Treaty of Canandaigua is one of their strongest documents, because it is a living agreement between nations that both sides continue to honor in this small, visible way.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was the league's alliance with the English called?
2. What did a silver Covenant Chain need to stay bright?
3. Where did Canasatego advise the colonies to unite?
4. Who negotiated the Treaty of Canandaigua for the United States?
5. What did Franklin propose at the Albany Congress?
6. Who argued that the league influenced the founders?
7. What did Elisabeth Tooker argue about the influence claim?
8. What name did Haudenosaunee speakers give Washington?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia