Skip to main content

The factories and railroads of the Gilded Age produced goods in quantities no earlier society had known. Someone had to sell all of it. Out of that need came the department store, the mail order catalog, the brand name and the advertising agency, and with them a new idea of what it meant to be an American: a consumer as well as a producer and a citizen.

Palaces of goods

Large city stores grew from dry goods shops into department stores selling everything from gloves to furniture under one roof. A. T. Stewart in New York, John Wanamaker in Philadelphia, Marshall Field in Chicago and R. H. Macy in New York built stores that were tourist attractions in their own right, with marble halls, skylights and later electric lights. They changed how buying worked. A one price policy, with a fixed price marked on every item, replaced haggling over each purchase, so that a stranger paid the same as a regular customer. Many stores also let customers return goods for their money back, a new kind of trust between seller and buyer.

Department stores became public spaces where respectable women could spend a day in the city on their own, with restrooms, tearooms and reading rooms. They also employed thousands of young women as clerks, the shopgirls of the age, who worked long hours on their feet for modest pay. The historian William Leach argued that merchants and their allies built a new culture centered on desire and buying, teaching Americans to find comfort, status and even meaning in goods. Critics of his view reply that ordinary buyers were not so easily led, and that cheaper, better goods made many lives genuinely easier.

The store in the mailbox

Most Americans still lived in the countryside, far from any department store. They bought from local general stores, which often charged high prices on credit. Aaron Montgomery Ward, a traveling salesman, saw an opening. In 1872 Ward started a general mail order business in Chicago, selling by catalog, buying in bulk and shipping by rail. His first catalog was a single sheet. Early on, Ward courted members of the Grange, the farmers' organization, calling his firm a supply house for Grangers and winning trust by offering returns. Richard Sears, who began by selling watches by mail in Minnesota, joined the watchmaker Alvah Roebuck, and by the 1890s Sears, Roebuck and Company was printing catalogs of hundreds of pages.

The post office made the catalogs far more powerful. Farm families had long fetched their mail from a town post office, sometimes miles away. Rural Free Delivery, begun as an experiment in 1896, brought mail directly to farm homes, and it became permanent a few years later.

Brands and advertising

Before the 1880s, much of what a family bought was sold loose: flour from a sack, sugar from a barrel, crackers from a bin. Manufacturers who wanted loyal customers began to package and name their goods. Procter and Gamble's Ivory soap, introduced in 1879, was advertised across the country with the claim that it floated and was nearly pure. The National Biscuit Company's Uneeda Biscuit, launched in 1898 in a sealed package, replaced crackers scooped from an open barrel, promising freshness and cleanliness with a single trusted name.

Advertising grew into an industry to serve these brands. Newspapers and magazines, now cheaper to print, depended more and more on ad revenue. Early ad agents simply bought space and resold it at whatever markup they could get. In 1875 the Philadelphia firm N. W. Ayer and Son offered an open contract, acting for the advertiser at the papers' true rates plus a set commission, which helped turn the agent into a partner who planned campaigns.

The promise of rising

Alongside the new goods came a popular story about how to get them. Horatio Alger wrote more than a hundred books for boys, beginning with Ragged Dick in 1868. Later readers remembered them as rags to riches tales, but that is not quite what they were. Alger's heroes usually rise through hard work and honesty plus a stroke of luck, often a rich patron's help, and they reach a respectable middle class life, not great wealth. The stories reassured readers that the new economy rewarded character, even as it was producing fortunes and hardships on a scale that character alone could not explain.

Worked example: the catalog on the kitchen table

Imagine an Iowa farm family in 1897 with a new Sears catalog. They can compare a dozen plows, order a sewing machine at a lower price than the town store charges, and choose dress fabric from samples. The catalog brings them closer to city life and saves them money. Now look from the town storekeeper's side. He extends credit through bad harvests, knows his customers by name and pays local taxes, yet the family's cash now goes to Chicago. Both views are fair. The question the catalog raises, whether cheaper goods from far away are worth what they do to a local community, has returned with every new way of selling since.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did a one price policy in department stores replace?
2. What did William Leach argue about American merchants?
3. What did Aaron Montgomery Ward start in Chicago in 1872?
4. Which group did Montgomery Ward court early on?
5. What did Rural Free Delivery bring, beginning in 1896?
6. What did the sealed Uneeda Biscuit package of 1898 replace?
7. What did N. W. Ayer and Son's open contract of 1875 offer?
8. How do Horatio Alger's heroes usually rise?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia