Skip to main content

In the Gilded Age the federal courts became some of the most powerful actors in American economic life. Judges decided who could regulate railroads, whether new national laws reached the great trusts, whether Congress could tax incomes, and who counted as a citizen. Their rulings were shaped by a sincere belief in property and free contract, and they drew fierce criticism from people who felt the courts protected the strong.

Who regulates the railroads?

Farmers had won state laws regulating railroad rates in the 1870s, and at first the Supreme Court allowed them. But railroads crossed state lines, and a state's rules could reach shipments that began or ended elsewhere. In the Wabash case of 1886 the Supreme Court held that states could not set rates on shipments crossing state lines, because only Congress could regulate interstate commerce. The ruling left a gap that Congress filled the next year with the first federal regulatory commission.

The trust and the sugar case

Congress passed the Sherman Antitrust Act in 1890 with almost no opposition. Its key sentence was sweeping: "Every contract, combination in the form of trust or otherwise, or conspiracy, in restraint of trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations, is hereby declared to be illegal." The first major test came against the sugar trust. By buying rival refineries, the American Sugar Refining Company had gained control of about 98 percent of the sugar refining in the United States. In United States v. E. C. Knight Company (1895) the Court ruled against the government because manufacturing was not commerce, so a monopoly over making sugar was beyond the reach of a law about trade. Justice John Marshall Harlan dissented alone, warning that the decision left the public helpless against combinations that controlled the necessities of life.

The income tax and liberty of contract

In 1894, in the depths of the depression, Congress passed a small tax on incomes above $4,000, a level that touched only the wealthiest families. In Pollock v. Farmers' Loan and Trust Company (1895) the Court struck down the federal income tax of 1894, by a vote of five to four, holding that a tax on income from property was a direct tax that the Constitution required to be divided among the states by population. The ruling stood until a constitutional amendment overturned it. Two years later, in Allgeyer v. Louisiana (1897), the Court said that the liberty protected by the Fourteenth Amendment included the freedom to make contracts, an idea it would later use to strike down many state laws on wages and hours.

Laundries and equal protection

The same Fourteenth Amendment also produced one of the period's landmark rulings for equal rights. In the 1880s San Francisco required a permit to run a laundry in a wooden building, a rule presented as fire safety. Most laundries were wooden, and most were run by Chinese immigrants. San Francisco's supervisors denied permits to some 200 Chinese applicants while approving all but one of about 80 non Chinese applicants. Yick Wo, who had run his laundry for over twenty years, kept working and was jailed. In Yick Wo v. Hopkins (1886) a unanimous Court ruled for him. A law fair on its face, wrote Justice Stanley Matthews, could still be applied "with an evil eye and an unequal hand." Yick Wo established that unequal enforcement of a fair looking law can violate equal protection. The Court also made clear that equal protection covers all persons within a state's jurisdiction, including noncitizens, since the amendment says "person," not "citizen."

Born here

Federal law at the time barred Chinese immigrants from becoming naturalized citizens. Wong Kim Ark, born in San Francisco to Chinese parents, traveled to China and was refused reentry in 1895 on the ground that he was not a citizen. The government argued that children of parents who could never become citizens were not fully under American jurisdiction. In United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898) the Court held that a child born in the United States to Chinese parents was a citizen under the Fourteenth Amendment's opening sentence. The decision remains the foundation of birthright citizenship in the United States.

Judging the judges

Defenders of the Gilded Age courts argue that judges were applying long held principles, limited government, property rights and freedom of contract, against sudden and sometimes poorly drafted laws, and that rulings like Yick Wo show those principles could protect the weak too. Critics answer that the same courts gave corporations wide protection while doing little for workers, farmers or Black Southerners. Both observations rest on real cases.

Worked example: on its face, and in practice

Apply the Yick Wo test to a modern style rule. Suppose a city requires a costly license for food trucks parked near offices, explained as a traffic measure. On its face the rule treats everyone alike. Now suppose records show that the licenses go almost entirely to trucks owned by people with political connections, while immigrant owners with identical trucks are refused. Under the reasoning of 1886, the fairness of the text does not settle the matter. A court would look at how the rule is actually applied and to whom. The case teaches a durable lesson for any citizen judging a law: read what it says, then look at what it does.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Supreme Court hold in the Wabash case of 1886?
2. About what share of American sugar refining did the American Sugar Refining Company control?
3. Why did the Court rule against the government in the E. C. Knight case?
4. What did Pollock v. Farmers' Loan and Trust Company do in 1895?
5. How had San Francisco handled laundry permits before Yick Wo v. Hopkins?
6. What principle did Yick Wo v. Hopkins establish?
7. According to Yick Wo, whom does equal protection cover?
8. What did the Court decide in United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898)?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia