Skip to main content

For more than thirty years Singer's essay was mostly a puzzle for seminar rooms. Then, in the late 2000s, a handful of people began trying to live by something like it, and to do so with spreadsheets as well as good intentions.

GiveWell and the pledge

In 2007 two young analysts at the hedge fund Bridgewater Associates, Holden Karnofsky and Elie Hassenfeld, tried to decide where to give money and found that charities could rarely tell them what a donation achieved. They left their jobs and founded GiveWell, which researches charities in depth and recommends a small number whose impact per dollar it can best document. GiveWell asked a different question: what actually happens to the people a charity serves, and at what cost?

In 2009 the Oxford philosophers Toby Ord and William MacAskill founded Giving What We Can. Its members pledge to give at least 10 percent of their income to the organizations they believe do the most good. Ord himself went much further, committing to give away everything he earned above a modest fixed amount. The pledge offered a practical answer to the demandingness problem: a public, bounded commitment.

A name and a definition

In 2011 a group of these Oxford organizers needed a name for an umbrella organization. After a vote they chose "effective altruism," and the Centre for Effective Altruism followed. The same year MacAskill and Benjamin Todd started 80,000 Hours, named for roughly the number of hours a person works in a career, to advise people on choosing work that does good.

MacAskill has described effective altruism, in paraphrase, as using evidence and careful reasoning to work out how to help others as much as possible, and then acting on the answer. Two features of that description matter. First, it poses a question rather than giving a fixed answer: if the evidence pointed to new priorities, the movement should in principle follow it. Second, it is not the same thing as utilitarianism. A person can believe it is good to help others effectively without believing that maximizing welfare is the whole of morality.

Scale, neglectedness, tractability

How do you compare causes as different as malaria, factory farming and nuclear war? Effective altruists commonly use three tests. Scale asks how big a problem is, neglectedness asks how few resources already go to it, and tractability asks how much progress more effort would buy. Neglectedness matters because returns to extra spending usually diminish: the first million dollars spent on an ignored problem tends to achieve far more than the thousandth million spent on a popular one.

The framework helps explain the movement's unusual mix of priorities. Many members ended up in three broad areas: global health and poverty, the welfare of animals, especially those raised in factory farms, and reducing risks that could devastate humanity's future.

Money and influence

Wealthy backers soon arrived. Dustin Moskovitz, a cofounder of Facebook, and his wife Cari Tuna decided to give away most of their fortune and began working with GiveWell, a partnership that grew into the foundation Open Philanthropy. Within a decade, effective altruism had gone from a few student societies to a network directing hundreds of millions of dollars a year. That rapid growth concentrated influence in a small number of very large donors, a fact critics would later stress.

Admirers and early doubters

Admirers credit the movement with bringing rigor to giving. Charity had long run on sentiment, personal ties and moving stories; effective altruists asked it to answer to evidence. They point to concrete results, including the funding of very large numbers of insecticide-treated bed nets and of preventive malaria medicine for young children.

Early doubters raised concerns that never went away. A common early criticism was that the movement drew its members from a narrow, elite slice of society: young, mostly from a few famous universities, heavy in philosophy, economics and computing. Others asked whether any single ranking of causes could capture values that resist comparison, such as justice, beauty or loyalty to a place.

Worked example: three causes, three tests

Imagine a donor choosing among three causes: a well-funded cancer research charity in a rich country, a campaign to remove lead from paint and spices in low-income countries, and the arts center in her own town. Apply the tests. Cancer is enormous in scale, but research already receives billions of dollars a year, so it is not neglected, and the value of one more donation is hard to judge. Lead exposure is also large in scale: a 2020 report by UNICEF and the group Pure Earth estimated that roughly one child in three worldwide has blood lead levels high enough to cause concern. It receives very little funding, and its tractability looks promising, since bans on lead paint have worked in many countries before.

The framework points toward lead. Yet notice what it leaves out. The donor has ties to her town, and the arts center serves goods that do not sit easily on a single scale with blood lead levels. An effective altruist might say she should still favor lead and give to the arts center from a separate budget. A critic might say the very act of ranking these causes on one scale has already decided the question.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did GiveWell set out to do?
2. What do members of Giving What We Can pledge?
3. Who founded Giving What We Can in 2009?
4. How has MacAskill described effective altruism, in paraphrase?
5. What does the neglectedness test ask?
6. Why does neglectedness matter, on the framework's logic?
7. What did the movement's rapid growth in funding do?
8. What was a common early criticism of the movement?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia