Skip to main content

For a generation after 1099, Muslim rulers in Syria treated the Franks as one more set of neighbors to fight, bribe or ally with. Turning that patchwork into a united front took more than eighty years, and it was as much a story of Muslim politics as of war with the West.

The slow revival of jihad

Some voices called for resistance early. In 1105 the Damascus scholar al-Sulami wrote a book calling Muslims to jihad against the Franks, arguing that the invasion was part of a wider Christian assault from Spain to Sicily and that Muslim disunity had invited it. Few rulers listened at first, and some Muslim princes found the Franks useful allies against their own rivals. The change came with Zengi of Mosul and Aleppo, who captured Edessa in 1144.

The fall of Edessa prompted a Second Crusade, preached by Bernard of Clairvaux and led by two kings, Louis VII of France and Conrad III of Germany. Both armies were mauled crossing Anatolia. The survivors chose an odd target, and the Second Crusade collapsed after a brief siege of Damascus in 1148, a city whose rulers had been Jerusalem's allies against Zengi. The failure discredited crusading in Europe for a generation and pushed Damascus toward Zengi's son.

That son, Nur al-Din, joined Aleppo and Damascus and made holy war the centerpiece of his rule, building schools, mosques and propaganda for the cause. Before Jerusalem was in sight, Nur al-Din commissioned a carved wooden pulpit for the al-Aqsa Mosque, to be installed once Jerusalem was retaken. It waited in Aleppo for years.

Saladin

Salah al-Din Yusuf, known in the West as Saladin, was a Kurdish officer whom Nur al-Din sent to Egypt. He became vizier of the Fatimid caliph, then in 1171 Saladin ended the Fatimid caliphate, having prayers said in the name of the Abbasid caliph instead. After Nur al-Din died in 1174 Saladin spent years winning Syria, often fighting fellow Muslims, and justified this by the war against the Franks. His rule was a family enterprise: brothers, nephews and sons governed provinces, and after his death his heirs, known as the Ayyubids, divided his lands among themselves. In 1187 he crushed the army of Jerusalem and took the city, and he had Nur al-Din's pulpit carried from Aleppo and set in al-Aqsa, where it stood until an arsonist destroyed it in 1969.

The Third Crusade

Europe answered with its greatest effort. The German emperor Frederick Barbarossa led a large army overland, but Frederick Barbarossa drowned crossing a river in Anatolia in 1190, and most of his army melted away. Richard I of England and Philip II of France came by sea to the siege of Acre, which fell in July 1191. When ransom terms stalled, Richard had about 2,700 Muslim prisoners from Acre killed in sight of Saladin's army. Richard beat Saladin at Arsuf and twice approached Jerusalem, but judged that he could not hold it once the crusaders went home. A truce in 1192 left the Franks a coastal strip. Saladin died in Damascus the next year, and his biographer recorded that his treasury held too little to pay for his burial, so freely had he given money away.

The Third Crusade is unusually well documented from both camps. Ambroise, a Norman poet who marched with Richard, wrote a long verse history in French, while Saladin's secretaries kept detailed Arabic accounts, so historians can follow many episodes from both sides of the battle line. When the two disagree, as they often do about numbers and motives, the comparison itself becomes evidence.

The crusade's fervor also struck at home. As Richard prepared to leave, riots broke out against Jews in England, and in March 1190 the Jews of York died in a massacre at the royal castle, many taking their own lives rather than face the mob.

Worked example: was Saladin chivalrous?

Saladin's reputation in Europe became so warm that Dante placed him with the virtuous pagans, and Longfellow's 1867 translation reads, "And saw alone, apart, the Saladin." Is the image deserved? Gather the evidence on both sides.

For mercy: in 1187 he let most of Jerusalem's Christians ransom themselves and leave, released many of the poor without payment and kept his word to the city's defenders, a sharp contrast with 1099. He negotiated honorably with Richard and their courts exchanged gifts. Against it: after his victory in 1187 he had captured Templars and Hospitallers executed, about two hundred men, and he personally killed Reynald of Châtillon, a lord who had attacked caravans and raided the Red Sea coast toward Mecca and Medina.

Then weigh the sources. Much of what we know comes from his admiring secretaries, Baha al-Din ibn Shaddad and Imad al-Din, who were writing to honor him. Christian writers had reasons of their own to praise an enemy who had beaten them, since a great foe made defeat less shameful. The fair conclusion is a man who could be generous and pragmatic, who killed by the hard rules of his age, and whose legend grew on both sides because each found it useful.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Damascus scholar al-Sulami write in 1105?
2. How did the Second Crusade end?
3. What did Nur al-Din commission for the al-Aqsa Mosque?
4. What did Saladin do in 1171?
5. What happened to Frederick Barbarossa in 1190?
6. What did Richard I do after Acre fell in 1191?
7. What did Saladin's biographer record about his treasury at his death?
8. What happened to the Jews of York in March 1190?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia