The armies that left Western Europe in 1096 had no single commander, no supply system and only a vague idea of the distances ahead. Three years later, a fraction of them stood in Jerusalem. How they got there, and what they built afterward, shaped the Near East for two centuries.
The road to Antioch
The first to set out were popular bands following preachers such as Peter the Hermit. Some of these bands massacred Jewish communities in the Rhineland on the way, an atrocity that Jewish chroniclers recorded with grief and that marked the beginning of a long pattern of crusade-era violence against Jews. The bands that reached Constantinople were ferried across to Anatolia, where the Turks of Kilij Arslan destroyed the People's Crusade near Civetot in October 1096.
The princes' armies arrived in Constantinople over the winter of 1096 to 1097. Alexios demanded that their leaders swear to return any former Byzantine cities they captured, and most did, reluctantly. The alliance soon showed strain. After a siege, Nicaea surrendered in June 1097 to the Byzantines, not to the crusaders, who had hoped to plunder it. The crusaders then beat a Turkish army at Dorylaeum and crossed Anatolia in summer heat, losing horses and people to thirst.
As the main army moved toward Syria, Baldwin of Boulogne took a small force east to the Armenian Christian city of Edessa. Its ruler adopted him, was soon killed in a revolt, and Baldwin took over Edessa in 1098, founding the first crusader state.
Antioch and Jerusalem
Antioch, a huge walled city, held out for eight months from October 1097. Famine ravaged the besiegers. The city fell only through treachery: a tower commander named Firuz let the crusaders into Antioch in June 1098. Days later a large relief army under Kerbogha of Mosul trapped them inside. In the desperate weeks that followed, a poor pilgrim named Peter Bartholomew claimed that visions had led him to the Holy Lance, the spear that pierced Christ's side, buried in a church in the city. On 28 June the crusaders marched out and routed Kerbogha's army.
The leaders then quarrelled for months. Bohemond kept Antioch for himself, breaking the oath to return it to Alexios, a decision that poisoned relations with Byzantium for decades. The rest of the army finally reached Jerusalem in June 1099 and took it by assault on 15 July, followed by a massacre of many of its Muslim and Jewish inhabitants. Godfrey of Bouillon became ruler, reportedly refusing the title of king in the city where Christ had worn a crown of thorns; his brother Baldwin had no such scruple and was crowned king in 1100.
Living in the Latin East
Four states emerged, ruled by a small Frankish elite over a population that was mostly Eastern Christian and Muslim, with Jewish and Samaritan minorities. The Franks lived mainly in towns and castles. They taxed Muslim villagers but generally allowed them to worship, and they borrowed local habits of dress, food and medicine. Fulcher, who settled in Jerusalem, remarked that Westerners there had become Easterners in a single generation. Marriages between Franks and local Christians were common, and the children of such families, called poulains by later visitors, were sometimes looked down on by newcomers from Europe.
The settlers were always short of soldiers. New institutions filled the gap. The Templars began around 1120 as a band of knights protecting pilgrims on the roads near Jerusalem, living under religious vows. The Hospitallers grew out of a hospital that cared for pilgrims in Jerusalem and took on military duties over the following decades. Both orders gathered gifts of land across Europe and became wealthy international organizations, garrisoning castles such as the Hospitallers' great fortress of Krak des Chevaliers in Syria. Their members took vows of poverty, chastity and obedience like monks, yet trained and fought as knights.
Worked example: explaining a miracle at Antioch
The crusaders believed the Holy Lance won them Antioch. How should a historian handle that claim? The method is not to rule on the miracle but to ask what can be checked. First, the sources disagree about the lance even at the time. Adhemar, the papal legate, was openly skeptical, and the find came from the poorer Provençal followers of Raymond of Toulouse, which made it a matter of factional pride. In 1099, under pressure from doubters, Peter Bartholomew underwent an ordeal by fire to prove his visions and died of his burns days later. His supporters said the crowd had crushed him; his critics said God had judged him.
Second, what explains the victory itself? Muslim and Christian sources agree that Kerbogha's coalition was fractured, that several emirs distrusted him and left the field, and that the crusaders attacked with a desperation born of hunger. Third, what did belief do? Whatever the lance was, faith in it raised morale at a moment when soldiers were deserting over the walls on ropes. A sound account can say all three things at once: the army believed a sign had been given, the belief mattered, and the enemy's divisions mattered as much.
