The fall of Tenochtitlan has been told as a tale of heroes, of villains, of fate and of germs. The story itself is crowded with people whose choices mattered, many of them Indigenous, and its outline is well enough established to set beside the arguments about what it meant.
An expedition without permission
Hernán Cortés sailed from Cuba in February 1519 under the authority of the island's governor, Diego Velázquez, who tried at the last moment to cancel the voyage. Cortés went anyway. On the Gulf coast his men founded the town of Villa Rica de la Vera Cruz, and the new town council named Cortés its captain, a legal maneuver that let him claim to answer directly to the king rather than to Velázquez. To stop the disaffected from going home, he had his ships run aground and stripped; the popular story that he burned them is a later embellishment.
Language was the first obstacle. Cortés had picked up Jerónimo de Aguilar, a Spaniard shipwrecked years earlier who had learned Yucatec Maya while living among the Maya. With Malintzin, who spoke Maya and Nahuatl, he formed a chain of translation from Nahuatl through Maya to Spanish.
Allies and a massacre
The first people to join Cortés were the Totonacs of Cempoala, who were glad to stop paying tribute to the Mexica. After fierce battles the Tlaxcalans joined him too. In October 1519 the Spaniards and their allies killed thousands of people in Cholula, a great sacred city allied to the Mexica, claiming they had uncovered a plot; whether there was any plot is still disputed. On 8 November 1519 Moctezuma II met Cortés on the southern causeway and lodged the Spaniards in a palace. Within days Cortés seized him and held him hostage, ruling through him.
Toxcatl and the Sad Night
In spring 1520 Velázquez sent a larger force under Pánfilo de Narváez to arrest Cortés. Cortés marched to the coast, defeated Narváez and recruited most of his men. In his absence, the captain left in charge of the city, Pedro de Alvarado, attacked unarmed celebrants during the festival of Toxcatl in May 1520, killing many nobles as they danced. Alvarado said he was heading off a rising; Nahua accounts describe a massacre. Moctezuma died at the end of June, in circumstances still disputed. On the night of 30 June 1520, which the Spaniards remembered as la Noche Triste, the Sad Night, the Spaniards and Tlaxcalans tried to slip out along the western causeway and were cut down at the bridge gaps.
Siege and fall
The new ruler of Tenochtitlan, Cuitlahuac, died within months, and his successor, Cuauhtemoc, led the defense. Cortés had thirteen brigantines, small sailing ships, built in pieces and carried to the lakeshore by allied porters, then launched them to control the water. With tens of thousands of Indigenous allies he cut the causeways and the aqueduct and fought house by house. The last defenders held out in Tlatelolco. Cuauhtemoc was captured in a canoe and tortured for treasure, and in 1525 he was hanged during Cortés's march to Honduras, accused of plotting a revolt.
The retellings
Cortés told the story first, in long letters to Charles V. The second letter, printed in Seville in 1522, cast the conquest as a loyal servant's triumph and claimed that Moctezuma had willingly handed his realm to the emperor, a claim many historians now treat as a legal fiction. Bernal Díaz del Castillo, a veteran, wrote his True History in old age, partly to answer a biography that gave Cortés all the credit, and it was published only in 1632. The Tlaxcalans painted the Lienzo de Tlaxcala, a large cloth showing their warriors as conquerors beside the Spaniards, which supported their later claims to royal favor. In 2003 the historian Matthew Restall drew such strands into an influential critique of what he called myths of the conquest, among them the idea that a handful of Spaniards won alone.
The argument is not over. In 2019 Mexico's president, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, wrote to the king of Spain and to the pope asking for an apology for the conquest. The Spanish government rejected the request, saying the events of five centuries ago should not be judged by present standards.
Worked example: how did Moctezuma die?
Spanish accounts, including Cortés's own, say that Moctezuma went up on a roof to calm the crowd and was struck by stones thrown by his own people, dying days later. The Nahua account in Sahagún's twelfth book says the Spaniards killed him and cast out his body, and the friar Diego Durán, drawing on Nahua informants, also blamed the Spaniards. Which should we believe?
Begin with motives. The Spaniards had every reason to deny killing a hostage they claimed had become the emperor's loyal vassal. Nahua narrators, speaking under colonial rule decades later, had reasons to deny that their own people had stoned their king. Next, look at the situation: the Spaniards were preparing to flee, and a captive ruler whose authority had collapsed may have become a burden rather than a shield. That makes the Nahua version plausible, but it does not prove it.
Many historians leave the question open. What the dispute does show is that from the very first tellings, the conquest was narrated to assign blame and claim legitimacy, and that the people who lost the war still managed to put their version on record.
