Skip to main content

The Young Turks

Opposition to Abdülhamid grew among educated Muslims as well as Christians. The Committee of Union and Progress, the CUP, began in 1889 as a secret society of students at the military medical school in Constantinople, and grew through exiles in Paris and officers in the army in Macedonia. Its members, known in Europe as the Young Turks, wanted a strong, modern, constitutional empire that could resist European pressure. In 1907 Ottoman opposition groups met in Paris, and Armenian revolutionaries joined them. When officers in Macedonia rose in July 1908 and forced the sultan to restore the constitution, the streets filled with Muslims, Christians and Jews embracing under banners of liberty, equality and fraternity.

The Armenian Revolutionary Federation allied with the CUP, judging that a constitutional empire offered Armenians their best future. Armenians were elected to the new parliament, among them Krikor Zohrab, a lawyer and writer who sat for Constantinople. For a few months many Armenians believed the Armenian Question might be solved by ordinary politics.

Adana, April 1909

That hope was badly shaken within a year. In April 1909 a counter-revolution in the capital briefly seized power in the name of religion and the sultan. At almost the same moment, massacres broke out in Adana and the Cilician plain, a rich cotton region in the south where Armenians had prospered. Mobs, joined by some soldiers, killed Armenians in the city and surrounding villages. A second wave followed days later, after troops sent to restore order took part in the killing themselves. Estimates of the dead range widely, with about 20,000 a commonly cited figure.

The CUP army soon crushed the counter-revolution and deposed Abdülhamid, and some perpetrators at Adana were hanged, along with a number of Armenians. What troubled Armenians most was that the massacres came under the new constitutional regime, not under the old sultan, and that the local officials most responsible largely escaped. An Armenian deputy, Hagop Babikian, investigated and reported official complicity; he died shortly afterward. The Armenian Revolutionary Federation kept its alliance with the CUP, but trust had cracked.

Defeat and a coup

Between 1911 and 1913 the empire lost Libya to Italy and nearly all its European lands in the Balkan Wars. Hundreds of thousands of Muslim refugees from the Balkans arrived in Anatolia with stories of expulsion and massacre at Christian hands, and the government resettled many of them in the east, sometimes on land Armenians claimed. In January 1913 CUP officers stormed the cabinet in the Raid on the Sublime Porte, and the war minister Nazım Pasha was shot dead. After a further crisis that summer, Talat, Enver and Cemal dominated the government, with a small central committee behind them.

A new nationalism

Defeat pushed the CUP away from an Ottomanism that included all faiths and toward a Turkish and Muslim nationalism. Ziya Gökalp, a leading thinker of Turkish nationalism and a member of the CUP central committee, wrote that a modern state needed a shared national culture. Some party leaders went further and spoke of making Anatolia safe by changing who lived in it. In the spring of 1914, before the world war, Greek Orthodox villagers were driven from many towns on the Aegean coast, through boycotts, threats and attacks by irregular bands. Estimates of those expelled run to more than 100,000. It was an early sign that the government saw population as something to be engineered.

The reform agreement of 1914

Russia, meanwhile, revived the Armenian Question. After long talks among the powers, the Ottoman government signed an agreement on February 8, 1914, that created two inspectorates in the east under European inspectors general, a Dutch official, Louis Westenenk, and a Norwegian officer, Nicolai Hoff. They would supervise officials, police and courts in the Armenian provinces. Hoff reached Van in the summer of 1914. When war broke out, the inspectors were sent home, and the agreement was annulled in December. To CUP leaders the plan looked like Article 61 returning with Russian backing; to Armenians it was the most serious reform promise in a generation, and it vanished in months.

Worked example: one event, two readings

Take the period from 1908 to 1914 and read it first through CUP eyes. A modernizing party took power to save the empire, was nearly overthrown by religious reactionaries, then watched Christian neighbors in the Balkans seize Ottoman lands and drive out Muslims. Foreign powers then imposed inspectors on the eastern provinces. From that view, Armenian demands for reform looked like the opening act of another Balkan loss.

Now read the same years through Armenian eyes. Armenians had backed the constitution, sat in parliament and helped defeat the counter-revolution, yet they were massacred at Adana and saw the guilty go free. The reform they had waited thirty years for was signed and then cancelled. Each reading contains real grievances. The difference lies in what each side did with its fear. Armenian parties sought guarantees; the ruling party increasingly saw a whole community as a threat to be managed. That shift, from distrust of a policy to distrust of a people, is the danger sign worth recognizing wherever it appears.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which Armenian party allied with the CUP after 1908?
2. Where did massacres of Armenians break out in April 1909?
3. What most troubled Armenians about the Adana massacres?
4. Who was shot dead in the Raid on the Sublime Porte in January 1913?
5. Which three men dominated the Ottoman government after 1913?
6. Who was Ziya Gökalp?
7. What happened to many Greek Orthodox villagers on the Aegean coast in 1914?
8. What did the reform agreement of February 1914 create?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia