War and suspicion
In the summer of 1914, as Europe went to war, CUP envoys met the Armenian Revolutionary Federation at its congress in Erzurum. They asked the party to stir rebellion among the Armenians of the Russian Empire in return for future autonomy. The party declined, saying instead that Armenians on each side of the border should serve the state they lived in. Ottoman Armenian men were conscripted like others. On the Russian side, volunteer units of Russian Armenians, joined by some Ottoman Armenians who had crossed the border, fought with the tsar's army. Ottoman leaders took those volunteers as proof of a whole people's treachery.
The Ottoman Empire entered the war on Germany's side in the autumn of 1914. That winter Enver led an army against the Russians at Sarıkamış and lost most of it to cold and defeat. In February 1915 Armenian soldiers were disarmed and put into labor battalions, building roads and carrying supplies. In the months that followed, many of those battalions were marched off and shot. Gendarmes searched Armenian villages for weapons, often torturing men until they produced guns, which were then photographed as evidence of conspiracy.
Van
The city of Van lay near the Russian front. Its governor, Cevdet Bey, a brother-in-law of Enver, arrested and killed Armenian leaders in April 1915, while killings began in surrounding villages. The Armenians of Van's city barricaded their quarters and defended themselves for about a month, until Russian troops and Armenian volunteers arrived in May. Armenians remember Van as self-defense against massacre. The government used Van as proof of an Armenian rebellion, and it remains central to the Turkish state's account of 1915. Historians generally conclude that the resistance followed, rather than caused, the killings around the city.
The law of deportation
On the night of April 24, 1915, police in Constantinople arrested Armenian intellectuals and community leaders, among them the composer and priest Komitas, who survived but never recovered his health. On May 27 the government issued the Temporary Law of Deportation, which let the army deport people suspected of treason or spying. It did not name Armenians. In practice it was applied to nearly the entire Armenian population of Anatolia, and later laws on abandoned property let the state seize and sell deportees' property, from houses and fields to shops and church estates.
The deportations reached towns in western Anatolia, such as Bursa and Izmit, and cities in the center, such as Ankara. Historians give these cases great weight, because they were far from any front, which makes a purely military explanation hard to sustain. Armenians who converted to Islam were sometimes spared, especially women and children; often they were not.
The pattern
In province after province the same sequence appeared. Men were taken from the towns in groups and shot or stabbed in ravines nearby. Women, children and the elderly were formed into columns and driven south on foot, robbed of money and clothing, raped, and attacked by gendarmes, local bands and Kurdish irregulars. A key role fell to the Special Organization, irregular units partly made up of released convicts, which operated under the CUP's direction in the east. In Trebizond, many were taken out to sea in boats and drowned. At the Kemah gorge on the Euphrates, columns were massacred and thrown into the river. Thousands of women and children were taken into Muslim households, converted and given new names.
Survivors of the marches arrived in Aleppo and were sent on to camps along the Euphrates in the Syrian desert, where thousands died of hunger, thirst and typhus. In 1916, at Deir ez-Zor, the governor Ali Suad, who had tried to keep deportees alive, was replaced, and new massacres followed, killing tens of thousands of people who had already survived the march. Assyrian Christians in the southeast and Greek Orthodox communities, especially along the Black Sea, also suffered mass killing and deportation in these years.
Worked example: the evidence from Kharput
Kharput, a province in the east whose capital is now part of Elazığ, had a large Armenian population, an American college and an American consul, Leslie Davis. Through the summer of 1915 Davis watched columns leave the town and heard reports of killings outside it. Armenians came to his consulate seeking shelter, and he hid as many as he could. In the autumn he rode out to Lake Göeljük, now Lake Hazar, south of the town, and found thousands of bodies in the ravines and along the shore. He wrote it all down for Washington.
Test the official explanation against this record. If deportation was a security move, why were the men killed close to home rather than moved? Why were women and children from a province far behind the front marched hundreds of miles into desert with no food arranged? Why was Armenian property sold off rather than held for owners expected to return? Davis's report, written for his own government with no plan to publish, answers by describing what happened, and it matches survivor accounts and German consular reports from other provinces. When an order's outcome is the same in many places and over many months, it is reasonable to infer that the outcome was intended.
