The polio vaccine, insulin treatment for diabetes and modern organ transplants all owe something to experiments on animals. So do countless products that never reached the shelf, tested on animals and abandoned. Research is where the conflict between human and animal interests is starkest, because the human interests at stake can be life itself.
Rules for the laboratory
Britain led here too. After public alarm over experiments on conscious animals, Parliament passed the Cruelty to Animals Act of 1876, which required a license for experiments on living animals and is often described as the world's first law of its kind. Many countries now have such laws. In the European Union, a 2010 directive covers all vertebrates and also cephalopods such as octopuses, and requires that each project pass a harm and benefit analysis before it is approved. In the United States, the Animal Welfare Act of 1966 sets standards for research animals but excludes rats, mice and birds bred for research, which together make up the great majority of animals used.
The Three Rs
The most widely adopted framework for research animals came from two British scientists, William Russell and Rex Burch, in their book of 1959, The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique. They proposed the Three Rs. Replacement means using methods that need no animals at all, such as cell cultures, computer models or human volunteers. Reduction means using fewer animals to get the same information, through better study design and statistics, for example by sharing control groups between studies or by using imaging to follow the same animals over time instead of killing a group at each stage. Refinement means changing procedures to reduce pain and distress for the animals that are used, through anesthesia, better housing and humane end points. The Three Rs are written into the laws of the European Union and many other places.
Recent changes have pushed replacement further. The European Union banned the sale of cosmetics tested on animals from 2013. In the United States, the FDA Modernization Act 2.0, signed in December 2022, removed the federal requirement that new drugs be tested on animals before human trials, allowing alternatives such as organ chips and computer modeling where they are good enough.
The moral debate
Defenders of research argue that the benefits are enormous and often cannot be had any other way, and that well-regulated research already keeps suffering low. Some add that human life has greater value, so even serious costs to animals can be justified by saving people. They also note that research animals are a small share of the animals humans use: far more are killed for food each year than are used in laboratories, so a person who eats meat but condemns all research may be inconsistent.
Singer offered a test. Would the researchers be willing to perform the same experiment on a human orphan with mental capacities similar to the animal's? If not, he argued, the willingness to use the animal reveals speciesism, a preference for our own kind that has nothing to do with the capacities involved. Singer did not say that every experiment is wrong; he allowed that some might be justified if the benefits were great enough. Regan went further: on the rights view, benefits to others can never justify using an animal as a mere means, so nearly all such research is wrong.
A practical objection cuts across the moral one. Animals are imperfect models of humans. Around nine in ten drugs that enter human trials, usually after animal testing, fail: most drugs that pass animal tests fail in human trials, often because they do not work or prove unsafe in people. Defenders reply that failure rates would be even higher without animal studies, and that the answer is better science, not none.
Worked example: the brown dog
In 1903 two Swedish students in London, Louise Lind af Hageby and Leisa Schartau, kept a diary of the physiology lectures they attended. They described a demonstration in which the physiologist William Bayliss operated on a brown terrier, and claimed it had not been properly anesthetized and had already been used in an earlier procedure. A campaigner, Stephen Coleridge, publicly accused Bayliss of breaking the 1876 law. Bayliss sued for libel and won damages of £2,000. Antivivisectionists then raised a statue of the dog in Battersea, and in 1907 medical students rioted in an attempt to destroy it. The council removed it at night in 1910.
The case shows how the debate has moved. The questions in court were whether the dog was conscious and whether it had been used twice, matters the Three Rs now treat as refinement. Today a review committee would ask further questions. Could the teaching have used a film, a model or tissue instead, as replacement asks? Could fewer animals serve the class, as reduction asks? Was the educational benefit worth the cost to the dog? Those questions had little place in law in 1903. They have one now partly because of controversies like this one.
