Skip to main content

Most of the animals humans kill are killed for food, and most of the moral argument about animals ends up at the dinner table. The philosophical questions here are less about whether animals matter and more about what follows in practice: what kinds of farming are acceptable, what an individual shopper owes, and what the law should require.

From a book to a standard

In 1964 the British campaigner Ruth Harrison published Animal Machines, describing the indoor systems then spreading through farming. Public reaction was strong enough that the British government set up an official inquiry into farm animal welfare, chaired by the zoologist Roger Brambell. Its 1965 report proposed that a farm animal should at least have room to stand up, lie down, turn around, groom itself and stretch its limbs. These became known as the five freedoms, and later bodies recast them as freedom from hunger and thirst, from discomfort, from pain, injury and disease, and from fear and distress, along with freedom to express normal behavior. The list still shapes farm welfare rules across Europe and beyond.

Reform or abolition?

Welfare reform asks how animals should be treated while they are used. A sharper question asks whether they should be used at all. The legal scholar Gary Francione argued that welfare reforms entrench the status of animals as property, because they make animal use feel acceptable and leave the owner's interests in charge. He urged veganism as the moral baseline. Many advocates reply that animals alive now cannot wait for abolition, and that reforms reduce real suffering and can shift public attitudes step by step. The disagreement runs through the animal protection movement to this day.

The logic of the larder

Some defenders of farming offer a surprising argument. In 1896 the English writer Leslie Stephen put it bluntly: "The pig has a stronger interest than anyone in the demand for bacon. If all the world were Jewish, there would be no pigs at all." The argument, often called the logic of the larder, holds that farm animals would not exist at all without the demand for meat, so a farm that gives them decent lives does them a favor. The conservative philosopher Roger Scruton later defended a version of this for traditional, high-welfare farming.

Henry Salt replied in an essay of 1914 that gave the argument its name. He argued that coming into existence cannot be a benefit to a being that did not yet exist, since there was no one beforehand to be made better off. Singer, notably, has been less sure, allowing that for animals without a sense of their own future the argument may have some force when their lives are genuinely good. Nearly everyone agrees it cannot defend systems in which lives are not worth living.

Does one shopper matter?

A common objection to ethical eating is causal impotence: one shopper's purchases make no difference to how many animals are raised. Farms respond to millions of buyers, not to you. Singer and the philosopher Shelly Kagan replied with an argument about thresholds. Suppliers order in batches, so most single purchases change nothing, but occasionally one purchase tips an order. A small chance of a large effect averages out to roughly one purchase's worth of impact. Others answer differently, holding that it is wrong to benefit from or take part in a practice that wrongs others, whatever difference one person makes.

Law and the hatchery

Some reforms come through law, and some target practices most consumers never see. In the egg industry, male chicks of laying breeds neither lay eggs nor grow fast enough to be raised profitably for meat, so for decades billions were killed each year shortly after hatching. In 2022 Germany banned the killing of male chicks in its hatcheries, the first country to do so, and France followed in 2023. The change relies partly on technology that identifies the sex of a chick inside the egg, so that male eggs can be removed before the embryo develops far. Supporters call it a model of practical reform. Abolitionists reply that it leaves the hens' use, and their slaughter when laying declines, untouched.

Worked example: the case of 25 chickens

Suppose a supermarket orders chickens in cases of 25 and places a new order each time 25 chickens are sold. If you stop buying one chicken a week, most weeks your choice changes nothing. But about one week in 25, your purchase is the one that would have triggered a new order, and that order would have been for 25 chickens. So the expected effect of your purchase is one chance in 25 of causing 25 chickens to be raised, which comes to one chicken. Real supply chains are messier, with waste, contracts and price effects, and economists argue about the exact figure, which is usually somewhat less than one. But the basic point survives: being one of many does not make your share zero. The same reasoning applies to other choices that look too small to matter, such as a single vote or one household's energy use.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Ruth Harrison's 1964 book Animal Machines lead to?
2. What did the Brambell report say every farm animal should have room to do?
3. What was Francione's objection to welfare reforms?
4. What does the logic of the larder argument claim?
5. How did Henry Salt answer the logic of the larder?
6. What is the causal impotence objection to ethical eating?
7. What answer did Singer and Kagan give to causal impotence?
8. What did Germany ban in its hatcheries in 2022?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia