Skip to main content

Elizabeth was twenty-five when she became queen in November 1558. She had been declared illegitimate as a child, suspected of treason as a young woman and held in the Tower. She learned early to say little and to commit to less. Over a reign of more than forty-four years she turned caution into a style of government.

A working partnership

On her first days as queen she named William Cecil, later Lord Burghley, her principal secretary. He served her for forty years, first as secretary and later as Lord Treasurer, until his death in 1598. Elizabeth sometimes overruled him and often delayed his plans, but they shared a cautious Protestant outlook and a horror of waste. Around them sat a Privy Council of about a dozen to twenty men, who met almost daily and handled everything from wars to grain shortages.

The Tudor state was small. There was no standing army and no police. The crown ruled through lords lieutenant, who mustered the militia in each county, and through justices of the peace. These men served because office brought honor and influence. Rule depended on the cooperation of the local elite, and a wise monarch kept them content.

The marriage question

Everyone expected the queen to marry. A husband would protect her, it was thought, and give the realm an heir. Parliament petitioned her repeatedly. In 1559, according to the historian William Camden, she answered that it would be enough for her if a marble stone declared that a queen, having reigned such a time, lived and died a virgin.

Marriage was a trap for a queen. A foreign husband might pull England into his country's wars, and an English one would raise one faction above the rest. Her favorite, Robert Dudley, later Earl of Leicester, seemed for a time the likeliest choice. Then in 1560 his wife, Amy Robsart, was found dead at the foot of a staircase. A coroner's jury called it an accident, but rumors that Dudley had arranged his wife's death made marriage to him impossible.

The danger of an unsettled succession became vivid in 1562, when Elizabeth nearly died of smallpox. Parliament pressed her again. She refused to name an heir, arguing that a named successor would draw ambitious men to plot around them, as men had once plotted around her.

Speaking out

Elizabeth valued counsel but not criticism. In 1579, as she weighed marriage to the French Duke of Anjou, the Puritan lawyer John Stubbs published a pamphlet attacking the match, The Discovery of a Gaping Gulf. Stubbs had his right hand cut off for the pamphlet, struck off with a butcher's cleaver in the marketplace at Westminster. Camden, who watched, recorded that Stubbs then raised his hat with his left hand and cried "God save Queen Elizabeth." The crowd was silent. Many thought the sentence cruel.

Members of Parliament also tested the limits. In 1576 Peter Wentworth told the Commons that free speech was essential to their work and complained of royal interference. His fellow members were so alarmed that they stopped him in mid speech. It was the House of Commons itself that sent Wentworth to the Tower, and the queen released him a month later. He kept pressing on the succession and died a prisoner in the Tower in 1597.

The royal image

Elizabeth ruled partly through spectacle. Royal progresses were summer journeys in which the court traveled the country and stayed with nobles and towns, which paid for the honor. At Kenilworth in 1575 Leicester entertained her for nineteen days. Courtiers praised her as Gloriana and the Virgin Queen, and painters showed her in jeweled gowns covered with symbols of wisdom and purity. The anniversary of her accession, 17 November, became a national holiday with bells, bonfires and tournaments.

Some historians see this as genuine devotion; others as anxious propaganda for an aging woman without an heir. Both may be true.

Worked example: the Golden Speech

To reward courtiers without spending money, the crown granted monopolies, royal grants giving one person the sole right to make or sell a product. By the 1590s there were monopolies on salt, starch, playing cards and dozens of everyday goods, and prices rose. In the Parliament of 1601 members read out the list. One member asked whether bread would be next.

Here was a clash between the royal prerogative and the interests of the people Parliament spoke for. Elizabeth could have insisted on her rights. Instead she announced that the worst grants would be cancelled and others tested in the courts. On 30 November 1601 she received a large delegation from the Commons and told them: "though God hath raised me high, yet this I count the glory of my crown, that I have reigned with your loves."

Notice what she did. She gave way on substance while claiming the credit, and she did it so gracefully that members left moved rather than defeated. Copies of the speech circulated widely. Her successors, who often stood on their rights rather than yielding, would find Parliament less forgiving.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who was Elizabeth's principal secretary from the start of her reign?
2. What did lords lieutenant do in Elizabethan counties?
3. Why was marriage politically dangerous for Elizabeth?
4. Why did Amy Robsart's death hurt Robert Dudley's hopes?
5. What was John Stubbs's punishment for The Discovery of a Gaping Gulf?
6. Who sent Peter Wentworth to the Tower in 1576?
7. What were royal progresses?
8. What was a monopoly in Elizabethan England?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia