Lady Jane Grey's reign collapsed because the country would not follow it. Mary, Henry VIII's elder daughter, fled into East Anglia when her brother died, wrote to the Council demanding her rights and raised her standard at Framlingham Castle in Suffolk. Gentry and commoners poured in. On 19 July 1553 the Council in London changed sides and proclaimed Mary queen.
A woman on the throne
Mary was thirty-seven, devout, stubborn and popular, and the first woman to be crowned queen of England in her own right. That raised questions no one had needed to answer. English law spoke of kings. Could a queen command armies, judge and tax as a king did? And whom would she marry, since nearly everyone assumed a wife must obey her husband?
Parliament soon declared her parents' marriage valid, and Mary began to restore the old religion. Her choice of husband caused the first crisis. She chose Philip of Spain, son of the emperor Charles V, her mother's family and the greatest Catholic house in Europe.
Wyatt's rebellion
Many English people feared that the match would make England a province of Spain. Early in 1554 plotters planned risings in several regions. Most fizzled, but in Kent Sir Thomas Wyatt raised several thousand men against the Spanish marriage and marched on London.
Mary refused advice to flee. She went to the Guildhall and rallied the Londoners in person, telling them she was wedded to the realm and showing the ring of her coronation. The city held. Wyatt reached Ludgate, found the gates shut and surrendered. About a hundred rebels were executed, and so, within days, were Jane Grey and her husband, now seen as too dangerous to keep alive. Princess Elizabeth was sent to the Tower under suspicion of knowing about the plot, then held under guard at Woodstock in Oxfordshire. Nothing was ever proved against her.
Writing limits into a marriage
Mary's councillors tried to make the marriage safe. The treaty gave Philip the title of king but barred him from appointing foreigners to English offices or drawing England into Spain's wars. If Mary died without children, he would have no claim to the crown. The couple married at Winchester Cathedral in July 1554.
That spring Parliament also passed an act declaring that a queen regnant held exactly the same powers as a king. At the time it closed off arguments that a ruling queen's authority was weaker, or that it passed to her husband.
Reunion with Rome
In November 1554 Cardinal Reginald Pole, Mary's cousin, returned from exile and absolved the realm, restoring obedience to the papacy. There was a price. The nobles and gentry who had bought monastic estates would not give them up, and Parliament agreed to return to Rome only after the pope accepted that former church lands would stay with their new owners. The old church came back without its old wealth.
Mary believed herself pregnant in 1554 and 1555, but no child came. Drawn into Philip's war with France after all, England lost Calais, its last foothold on the continent, in January 1558. Mary died that November, and Pole died the same day.
Bloody Mary reconsidered
Mary is remembered for the Protestants burned for heresy, a memory fixed by John Foxe's book of martyrs. Recent historians have not excused the burnings, which horrified many at the time, but they argue that Mary's government was more capable than its reputation. Her church printed books of sermons, rebuilt parish worship and planned colleges in each diocese to train priests, an idea later taken up by the wider Catholic church. Her ministers drew up a new Book of Rates in 1558 that raised the official values of imported goods on which customs were charged, a reform that greatly helped her successor's finances. Mary also set the precedents that made a queen's rule normal. Her sister inherited a throne a woman had already held.
Worked example: "monstrous regiment"
In 1558 the Scottish reformer John Knox, in exile in Geneva, published a book titled The First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstrous Regiment of Women. "Regiment" meant rule. Knox argued that rule by women was against nature and God's law, and he had Mary Tudor and Mary of Guise, regent of Scotland, in his sights.
Test the timing. The book came out in the spring of 1558. In November Mary died and her Protestant sister Elizabeth took the throne. Knox, who wanted the new queen's help for Scottish Protestants, found that she would not forgive him. His argument proved too much: it struck at a Protestant queen as hard as at a Catholic one.
Now compare the act of 1554. Knox began from a claim about women in general. The act began from the office: whoever lawfully held the crown held all of its power. The second approach separated authority from the sex of the person holding it, and English law took that path. Arguments about whether women were fit to rule continued for centuries, but in England the office itself was settled during Mary's reign.
