Skip to main content

Reconstruction was not simply abandoned. It was overthrown, county by county, by organized violence, and then given up by a Northern public that had grown tired of the struggle. The courts, meanwhile, narrowed the new amendments until they protected far less than their authors intended. Understanding how this happened requires following three stories at once: terror in the South, rulings in Washington, and shifting opinion in the North.

The Ku Klux Klan

The Ku Klux Klan was founded in Pulaski, Tennessee, in 1865 or 1866 by a group of Confederate veterans, at first as a social club. By 1868 it had become a terrorist movement spread across much of the South. Former Confederate general Nathan Bedford Forrest was widely reported to be its leader. Klansmen whipped, raped and murdered Black voters, burned schools and churches, and killed Republican officials of both races. The aim was political: to destroy the Republican party and restore white rule by making Black political life too dangerous to continue.

The federal response

Congress responded with the Enforcement Acts of 1870 and 1871. The most sweeping, the Ku Klux Klan Act of April 1871, made conspiracies to deprive citizens of their rights a federal crime and allowed the president to suspend habeas corpus. In October 1871 Grant suspended habeas corpus in nine South Carolina counties, and federal prosecutors under Attorney General Amos Akerman brought hundreds of cases. By 1872 the Klan as an organization was largely broken. But federal resources were thin, many cases never came to trial, and other groups soon took its place.

The courts narrow the amendments

In the Slaughterhouse Cases of 1873, a dispute among New Orleans butchers, the Supreme Court ruled 5 to 4 that the privileges or immunities clause protected only a narrow set of rights of national citizenship, leaving most rights under the control of the states. That April, in Colfax, Louisiana, white paramilitaries attacked Black men defending the courthouse after a disputed election, killing dozens, many of them after they had surrendered. Federal prosecutors charged the attackers, but in United States v. Cruikshank (1876) the Supreme Court overturned the convictions, holding that the amendments limited what states could do and gave the federal government little power to punish private violence.

The Northern retreat

In 1872 Liberal Republicans broke with Grant, nominating newspaper editor Horace Greeley on a program of civil service reform, lower tariffs and an end to federal intervention in the South. Grant won easily, but the mood was shifting. The depression after 1873 made Reconstruction seem a costly distraction, and in the 1874 elections Democrats won control of the House of Representatives. Many Northern voters had come to believe the stories of Southern corruption and to doubt that the federal government should protect Black citizens indefinitely.

The Mississippi Plan

In Louisiana the White League fought pitched battles with state forces, including a clash in New Orleans in September 1874. In Mississippi in 1875 Democrats adopted what became known as the Mississippi Plan: open intimidation and violence to keep Republicans from voting. Rifle clubs broke up rallies and killed Black leaders. Governor Adelbert Ames asked for federal troops, but the Grant administration, worried about Northern opinion, declined. Democrats swept the election. Similar campaigns followed in South Carolina in 1876, where armed men in red shirts rode to Republican meetings.

The disputed election of 1876

In the presidential election of 1876 the Democrat Samuel Tilden won the popular vote, but 20 electoral votes were disputed, from Florida, Louisiana, South Carolina and one from Oregon. Congress created an Electoral Commission of fifteen members: five representatives, five senators and five Supreme Court justices. It voted 8 to 7, along party lines, to award all 20 votes to Republican Rutherford B. Hayes, who won 185 to 184. In April 1877 Hayes withdrew federal troops guarding the Republican claimants in the statehouses of South Carolina and Louisiana, and the last Republican governments in the South fell.

Worked example: from Colfax to Cruikshank

Trace how a massacre became a constitutional rule. Step one: violence. In April 1873 armed white men surrounded the Colfax courthouse, set it on fire and shot Black defenders as they fled or surrendered. Step two: prosecution. Federal attorneys charged the attackers under the Enforcement Act of 1870 with conspiring to deprive citizens of their rights, and won some convictions. Step three: appeal. The justices held that the indictments did not properly allege a racial motive or a federal right the amendments protected against private actors.

The lesson reaches beyond 1876. A right written into a constitution depends on who is allowed to enforce it and against whom. By ruling that the federal government could punish states but rarely private mobs, the Court left Black Southerners with rights on paper and no reliable protector in practice. Paramilitary groups drew the obvious conclusion. If no federal court would punish them, local juries certainly would not, and the cost of terror fell to almost nothing. Within a few years the White League and the Red Shirts were operating openly, in daylight, without masks.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was the main aim of Klan violence during Reconstruction?
2. Which laws of 1870 and 1871 made conspiracies against citizens' rights a federal crime?
3. What did Grant do in nine South Carolina counties in October 1871?
4. What did the Slaughterhouse Cases rule about the privileges or immunities clause?
5. What did United States v. Cruikshank do to the Colfax convictions?
6. Whom did the Liberal Republicans nominate for president in 1872?
7. What was the Mississippi Plan of 1875?
8. How was the Electoral Commission of 1877 made up?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia