Skip to main content

Reconstruction is the name Americans give to the years after the Civil War, when the nation tried to rebuild the Union and to decide what freedom would mean for roughly four million people who had been enslaved. Textbooks usually date it from 1865 to 1877, but many historians now begin in 1863, when the Emancipation Proclamation made the war a fight against slavery itself. The questions raised in those wartime years shaped everything that followed: who would govern the defeated South, on what terms former rebels would return, and whether freed people would become full and equal citizens.

Contraband and the collapse of slavery

Slavery began to crumble long before any law ended it. In May 1861 three enslaved men escaped to Fort Monroe in Virginia, held by Union troops. General Benjamin Butler refused to send them back, calling them "contraband of war": enemy property that could be seized because it helped the rebellion. The label spread, and thousands of people fled to Union lines, forcing the government to decide what to do with them. Congress passed Confiscation Acts in 1861 and 1862, and from 1863 the army enlisted Black soldiers in large numbers. By the war's end about 180,000 Black men had served in the Union army. Each escape and each enlistment weakened slavery and strengthened a claim that would echo through Reconstruction: people who had fought for the Union had earned a place in it.

Lincoln's ten percent plan

In December 1863 Abraham Lincoln issued a Proclamation of Amnesty and Reconstruction. Under this ten percent plan, a Confederate state could form a new government once loyal oath takers equaled a tenth of its 1860 voters, provided the new government accepted emancipation. Most Confederates could receive a pardon by swearing future loyalty, though high officials were excluded. Lincoln wanted a quick and lenient path that might tempt wavering Southerners away from the Confederacy and shorten the war. Unionists in Louisiana and Arkansas began forming governments on these terms.

Congress pushes back

Many Republicans in Congress thought the plan far too generous. In July 1864 they passed the Wade-Davis Bill, which demanded that a majority of a state's white men swear loyalty before a new government could be formed, and it allowed only men who could swear they had never willingly supported the rebellion to help write a new constitution. Lincoln killed the bill with a pocket veto, simply leaving it unsigned as Congress adjourned. The clash previewed a lasting question: did the president or Congress control Reconstruction? Lincoln treated the task as restoring loyal governments as fast as possible, while Radical Republicans argued that the rebel states had forfeited their normal rights and that Congress could set the terms of their return.

Land and the Savannah meeting

In January 1865 General William T. Sherman and Secretary of War Edwin Stanton met twenty Black ministers and church leaders in Savannah, Georgia. Asked what they understood by freedom, their spokesman, Garrison Frazier, a Baptist minister who had bought his own liberty years before, said it meant being placed "where we could reap the fruit of our own labor." Land, the ministers insisted, was the surest basis for independence. Four days later Sherman issued Special Field Order No. 15, which set aside the Sea Islands and a coastal strip from Charleston to northern Florida for Black families, in plots of up to forty acres. Some families also received army mules, one origin of the phrase "forty acres and a mule." Within months about 40,000 freed people had settled on this land.

The Freedmen's Bureau and the end of slavery

In March 1865 Congress created the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands, usually called the Freedmen's Bureau. It was planned to last only a year after the war, though it was later extended. It gave out food, ran hospitals, supervised labor contracts and helped found schools. The Thirteenth Amendment, sent to the states in January 1865 and ratified that December, ended slavery everywhere in the country, except as punishment for a crime, an exception that later mattered a great deal. Lincoln did not live to see ratification. He was shot on 14 April 1865, days after Lee's surrender at Appomattox, and died the next morning. His second inaugural address had promised to act "with malice toward none, with charity for all," but no one can know how he would have handled the fights to come.

Worked example: the Port Royal Experiment

When Union forces captured the Sea Islands of South Carolina in November 1861, planters fled and left behind about 10,000 enslaved people. Early in 1862 Northern teachers, missionaries and cotton agents arrived. They opened schools and paid wages for cotton work, in what became known as the Port Royal Experiment, a rehearsal for Reconstruction on a small scale.

Watch the competing visions collide. The freed islanders wanted land of their own, and many preferred to grow food crops rather than cotton. The reformers wanted schools and wage labor, believing free workers would prove that freedom paid. Northern investors wanted a profitable cotton crop. When the government auctioned seized land for unpaid taxes, most of it went to outside buyers, though some freed families pooled their savings to buy plots. Every theme of the wartime years appears here: whether freedom required land, who would decide the terms of labor, and whether Washington would side with the freed people or with property. The same questions would soon be fought out across the whole South.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did General Benjamin Butler call the enslaved people who fled to Fort Monroe in 1861?
2. What did Lincoln's ten percent plan require before a Confederate state could form a new government?
3. What did the Wade-Davis Bill demand?
4. How did Lincoln stop the Wade-Davis Bill?
5. What did the Black ministers who met Sherman in Savannah stress as the basis of independence?
6. What did Special Field Order No. 15 set aside for Black families?
7. What exception does the Thirteenth Amendment allow?
8. What did the Port Royal Experiment amount to?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia