Skip to main content

The decision to partition India was taken in about three months, between March and June 1947, by a handful of leaders and a new Viceroy. The handover followed ten weeks later. Speed was the defining feature of 1947, and it is still argued over.

A deadline and a new Viceroy

On 20 February 1947 the Prime Minister, Clement Attlee, told Parliament that Britain would hand over power by June 1948 at the latest, to one government or several. Lord Wavell was replaced by Lord Mountbatten, a relative of the king and a wartime commander, who took office on 24 March.

Punjab was already breaking apart. Its Unionist premier resigned early in March under a League campaign, and killing began in Lahore, Amritsar and the Rawalpindi countryside. On 8 March the Congress Working Committee called for the partition of Punjab into Muslim majority and non-Muslim majority parts. If the League insisted on dividing India, Congress would insist on dividing the provinces the League claimed, and soon it said the same of Bengal.

From Plan Balkan to the 3 June Plan

Mountbatten's staff first drew up a scheme, nicknamed Plan Balkan, that would have handed power to the separate provinces, which could then decide whether to combine. When Mountbatten showed it privately to Nehru at Simla in May, Nehru rejected it furiously as a recipe for breaking India into pieces. V. P. Menon, a senior Indian civil servant, drafted the alternative: power would pass to two central governments, each a dominion of the Commonwealth for a time, which allowed a quick legal transfer.

On 3 June 1947 Mountbatten, Nehru, Jinnah and the Sikh leader Baldev Singh announced the plan on the radio. At a press conference the next day Mountbatten moved the handover forward to 15 August 1947, about ten months earlier than Attlee's deadline.

How the provinces chose

The plan let elected bodies decide. The assemblies of Bengal and Punjab met in two parts, one for members from Muslim majority districts and one for the rest. If either part wanted division, the province would be divided. In both provinces, the members from the non-Muslim majority districts voted to divide the province, while the Muslim majority parts voted to join Pakistan. Sind's assembly voted for Pakistan as a whole.

Two areas held referendums. The Muslim majority district of Sylhet in Assam voted to join eastern Bengal. In the North-West Frontier Province, a Congress-run province with a Muslim majority, the Khudai Khidmatgars of Abdul Ghaffar Khan boycotted the referendum because it offered no option of an independent Pashtun state. The vote went overwhelmingly to Pakistan on a reduced turnout. Ghaffar Khan, a lifelong ally of Gandhi, felt that Congress had abandoned his people.

The Indian Independence Act received royal assent on 18 July. It created two dominions and ended British paramountcy over the princely states, the roughly 565 territories ruled by Indian princes under British protection. Each ruler was advised to accede to one dominion, with geography in mind. Through Patel and Menon, almost all states next to India had signed by August. A few did not, and their stories come later.

Why did leaders accept?

Older accounts treat Jinnah as the single-minded architect of Pakistan. The historian Ayesha Jalal, in The Sole Spokesman (1985), argued instead that Jinnah used the Pakistan demand as a bargaining counter to win equal power for Muslims inside a united India, and that it was Congress leaders, wanting a strong center free of League obstruction, who in the end preferred partition. Her critics, such as Venkat Dhulipala, reply that Pakistan was a popular and well-debated idea among ordinary Muslims, especially in the United Provinces, not a lawyer's tactic. Others stress British haste and Britain's desire to leave a friendly Commonwealth behind. Most historians now see several actors pushing toward the same outcome for different reasons.

On 11 August Jinnah addressed Pakistan's new assembly in Karachi. He told its members that citizens were free to go to their temples, mosques or any place of worship, and that religion had nothing to do with the business of the state. Whether he meant Pakistan to be secular has been debated ever since.

Worked example: seventy-three days

Count the days from 3 June to 15 August: seventy-three. In that time officials had to divide an army of some 400,000 men, the railways, the treasury, the debts, the government offices down to the typewriters and the books in the libraries. A Partition Council of leaders from both sides met through the summer, and expert committees worked out formulas for each asset. The border itself was not known until after independence.

Mountbatten's defenders argue that delay would have been worse. Violence was spreading, British troops were few and leaving, and every month of uncertainty gave armed groups time to prepare. His critics answer that there was no plan to protect or move civilians, that the army was divided precisely when it was needed most, and that a deadline chosen partly for British convenience was paid for in Punjabi lives. Applying this level's ideas, notice that both sides accept the same facts. They disagree over what a responsible government owes to the people it is leaving, and over whether speed or preparation does more to prevent killing.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Attlee announce on 20 February 1947?
2. What did the Congress Working Committee call for in March 1947?
3. What would Plan Balkan have done?
4. Who drafted the plan to transfer power to two dominions?
5. What did Mountbatten announce at his press conference on 4 June 1947?
6. How did the Punjab and Bengal assemblies decide on division?
7. Why did the Khudai Khidmatgars boycott the Frontier referendum?
8. What does Ayesha Jalal argue about Jinnah?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia