Skip to main content

In 1946 the outcome was still open. A British plan offered a way to keep India together, and both main parties said yes to it, at least for a few weeks. By the end of the year the plan was dead and communal killing had spread from Calcutta across eastern India. This level follows that collapse step by step.

The Cabinet Mission plan

In March 1946 three British cabinet ministers, Lord Pethick-Lawrence, Stafford Cripps and A. V. Alexander, arrived to negotiate. After weeks of talks they published their own scheme on 16 May. The Cabinet Mission rejected a full, sovereign Pakistan as unworkable: drawn generously, it would contain huge non-Muslim minorities; drawn tightly, it would be small, poor and split in two.

Instead they proposed a three-tier union. The central government would handle only foreign affairs, defense and communications. Provinces would hold all other powers and sit in three groups: one for the Muslim majority northwest, one for Bengal and Assam, and one for the rest. Each group could write its own constitution, and after ten years a province could ask to revisit the arrangement. It was, in effect, a loose federation with a Pakistan-shaped region built in.

The Muslim League accepted the plan in June 1946, seeing in the groups a route to Pakistan without partition. Congress accepted it too, but read the grouping as optional, since provinces such as Assam and the Frontier, run by Congress, did not want to be placed in Muslim majority groups.

From acceptance to Direct Action

On 10 July 1946 Nehru, newly elected Congress president, told a press conference that Congress would enter the constitution-making assembly free to change the plan as it saw fit. To the League this confirmed that the safeguards would not survive. On 29 July the League withdrew its acceptance and called for Direct Action to achieve Pakistan, naming 16 August as the day. Azad later described Nehru's remarks as a grave blunder; Nehru's defenders say the plan was failing anyway over grouping.

Calcutta, August 1946

Bengal had a League ministry led by H. S. Suhrawardy. The Bengal government declared 16 August a public holiday, which emptied offices and filled the streets. After a mass rally, fighting broke out and spread for four days. League supporters were widely blamed for the first attacks, and Hindu and Sikh gangs answered with equal ferocity. The army was called in late. At least 4,000 people were killed in the Great Calcutta Killings, and perhaps 100,000 were left homeless. Historians still argue over responsibility: Suhrawardy's government was slow to act and was accused of preparing the violence, but Hindu militant groups had also armed themselves.

A chain of retaliation

Calcutta became a story told elsewhere, and each telling called for revenge. In October in Noakhali, a district of eastern Bengal, Hindus were killed, forcibly converted and driven from their homes. Gandhi went to Noakhali and walked from village to village for about four months, often barefoot, staying in Muslim homes and urging Hindus to return. Within weeks, in Bihar, Hindu mobs killed thousands of Muslims, many in villages where Muslims were a small minority. More killing followed at a fair at Garhmukteshwar in the United Provinces in November.

Each side used the other's atrocities to justify its own. Leaders who condemned violence in public found that their followers were not listening, and others did little to condemn it at all. The violence also changed the argument: it suggested to many that Hindus and Muslims could not live safely under each other's rule.

A government that could not govern

In September 1946 an interim government took office under the Viceroy, with Nehru as its leading member. The League joined in October, with Liaquat Ali Khan as finance member, but refused to sit in the constitution-making assembly. In the cabinet the two parties obstructed each other at every turn, and Liaquat's budget of 1947 taxed business profits in ways that alarmed Congress's supporters. The deadlock persuaded Congress leaders such as Vallabhbhai Patel that a united government including the League was unworkable. A smaller India with a strong center began to look better than a larger one paralyzed from within.

Worked example: the grouping quarrel

Take Assam. Under the plan it would sit in a group with Bengal, where Muslims held a majority of the combined seats. Assam's Congress premier, Gopinath Bordoloi, refused to be outvoted on Assam's constitution, and Gandhi backed him. The League replied that grouping was the heart of the bargain: without it, the plan was just a united India with a weak promise attached. In December 1946 the British government stated that the League's reading was the correct one, but by then neither side trusted the other.

The lesson goes beyond 1946. A constitutional bargain can survive disagreement over details; it rarely survives disagreement over what was actually agreed. Each party accepted words that let it imagine its own preferred future. When those futures collided, the ambiguity that had made agreement possible became the reason it failed, and the violence of August turned a legal dispute into a question of survival.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Under the Cabinet Mission plan, what would the center control?
2. How did the Cabinet Mission treat the idea of a full, sovereign Pakistan?
3. What did the League do on 29 July 1946?
4. What did the Bengal government declare for 16 August 1946?
5. How many people were killed in the Great Calcutta Killings, at least?
6. What did Gandhi do in Noakhali in late 1946?
7. What happened in Bihar in late 1946?
8. What did the interim government deadlock persuade Patel of?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia