Skip to main content

From the sixteenth century, ships from Europe began to cross the Pacific. For Islanders they arrived as something new and deeply puzzling; for Europeans the islands were a source of supplies, wealth, converts and scientific curiosity. The encounters that followed transformed Pacific life within a few generations.

The first crossings

Ferdinand Magellan's fleet crossed the Pacific in 1521 and stopped at Guam, in the Mariana Islands. From 1565 to 1815, Spanish galleons sailed between Acapulco in Mexico and Manila in the Philippines, carrying American silver one way and Asian silks and porcelain the other. Guam and the Marianas became a Spanish way station for the Manila galleons, and Spain imposed missions and garrisons there from 1668. War and introduced disease cut the Chamorro population from tens of thousands to a few thousand within a few decades.

The Dutchman Abel Tasman reached Tasmania and New Zealand in 1642; in a clash with Māori, four of his men were killed, and he sailed away without landing.

The age of Cook

That changed in the late eighteenth century, when British and French expeditions combined exploration with science. Samuel Wallis reached Tahiti in 1767 and Louis Antoine de Bougainville the next year. James Cook led three voyages between 1768 and 1779, charting New Zealand and the east coast of Australia, crossing the Antarctic Circle and reaching Hawaii. His ships carried astronomers, naturalists and artists, and their reports caused a sensation in Europe.

On his third voyage, Cook arrived at Hawaii Island in January 1779 and was received with great ceremony at Kealakekua Bay. He left, was forced back by a broken mast, and found the welcome much cooler. After a quarrel over a stolen boat, Cook was killed in a fight with Hawaiians at Kealakekua Bay in February 1779.

A god or a chief?

Why the change? The anthropologist Marshall Sahlins argued that Hawaiians identified Cook with the god Lono, because he arrived during the Makahiki, a season of festivals honoring Lono, and sailed around the island in the direction the god's procession took. His unexpected return, after the season had ended, broke the ritual pattern and turned him into a threat.

The anthropologist Gananath Obeyesekere replied in 1992. Obeyesekere argued that the idea of Cook as a god was a European myth, flattering to the explorers, and that practical Hawaiians would have treated Cook as a powerful chief. Sahlins answered that Obeyesekere was crediting Hawaiians with a Western kind of common sense instead of taking their own beliefs seriously. The debate became a broader quarrel about whether outsiders can ever understand another culture's thought, and about who has the right to speak for it.

Disease, trade and the gospel

The most destructive visitors were invisible. Islanders had no immunity to diseases common elsewhere, and measles, influenza, smallpox and venereal diseases tore through communities. Introduced diseases were the main cause of the sharp fall in Pacific populations after contact. In Hawaii, estimates of the population in 1778 range from about 300,000 to far higher; by the 1890s around 40,000 Native Hawaiians remained.

Traders followed: sandalwood cutters in Fiji and Hawaii, collectors of sea cucumbers, and whalers, who made ports such as Honolulu and the Bay of Islands boom towns.

Missionaries arrived too. The London Missionary Society landed on Tahiti in 1797. Change did not always come from outside, though. In 1819, months before the first American missionaries arrived, Hawaii's own rulers, led by the queen regent Kaʻahumanu, broke the old tapu system by eating together publicly, men and women at one meal. Many conversions were led by chiefs who saw political advantage in the new faith, and Pacific Islanders themselves, from Tahiti, Samoa, Tonga and the Cook Islands, carried Christianity westward as teachers and missionaries.

Blackbirding

From the 1860s, plantations in Queensland, Fiji, Samoa and New Caledonia needed workers. Recruiters sailed to Vanuatu, the Solomons and other islands. Some Islanders signed on willingly; many did not understand the contracts, and others were kidnapped. Blackbirding was the recruiting of Pacific Islanders as laborers by deceit or force. Around 62,000 contracts brought Islanders to Queensland's sugar fields between 1863 and 1904. Then, as Australia adopted its White Australia policy, the new Commonwealth passed a law in 1901 to deport most Pacific Island laborers, whether or not they had built lives there.

Worked example: weighing the Cook debate

Take the question as a historian would. What evidence exists? Almost all of it was written by Europeans: ships' journals, and later accounts by Hawaiians educated by missionaries decades afterward. Neither source is neutral. The journals record Hawaiians calling Cook "Lono" and prostrating themselves, which supports Sahlins. But Europeans might have misread chiefly honors as worship, which supports Obeyesekere. Missionary-trained Hawaiian writers might have stressed the "Lono" story to show how mistaken their ancestors' old religion had been.

Notice what both sides share: neither thinks Hawaiians were foolish. Sahlins says they reasoned within their own cosmology; Obeyesekere says they reasoned practically. The real question is what kind of reasoning to expect from people of another culture. A careful answer begins with Hawaiian categories: "Lono" may have been a title or an honor as much as a claim about divinity, a possibility that lies between the two positions.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What role did Guam play for Spain from the sixteenth century?
2. What did James Cook's ships carry besides their crews?
3. How did Cook die?
4. What did Marshall Sahlins argue about Cook's reception in Hawaii?
5. What did Gananath Obeyesekere argue?
6. What was the main cause of population decline after contact?
7. Who broke Hawaii's old tapu system in 1819?
8. What was blackbirding?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia