Skip to main content

An official philosophy

The Ming examinations required candidates to master the Confucian classics as explained by the Song dynasty philosopher Zhu Xi. Zhu taught that a moral pattern, called principle, runs through everything, and that a learner should investigate things one by one until he grasps it. Under Yongle the court issued official compendia of this teaching, and for most degree seekers it became a body of set answers to memorize.

Wang Yangming

The most influential challenge came from Wang Shouren, known as Wang Yangming, who lived from 1472 to 1529. As a young man he decided to follow Zhu Xi's method literally. He and a friend sat before a clump of bamboo in a garden, trying to grasp its principle; according to his own later account he stared for seven days and fell ill without result. The experiment, a test of Zhu Xi's method of investigating things, convinced him that principle was not to be found by examining outside objects.

In 1506 Wang protested against the powerful eunuch Liu Jin, was beaten at court and was exiled to a remote post in Guizhou, in the mountainous southwest. There, around 1508, he had a sudden insight: the mind already contains principle. Wang taught that every person has liangzhi, an innate knowledge of good that every person possesses, whatever their learning. Sages were not made by memorizing commentaries, and in principle a farmer or a merchant could become one. Wang was also a successful general and governor, which gave his teaching authority.

His followers carried the message to wide audiences, lecturing to crowds that included artisans and traders. Critics warned that putting the inner mind above texts and rules invited anyone to call his own impulses moral truth.

Li Zhi

The most radical heir of that debate was Li Zhi, who lived from 1527 to 1602. He praised what he called the childlike mind, the honest feeling a person has before learning teaches him to say what is expected. He mocked hypocrites, took women seriously as students, and praised figures whom orthodox historians condemned. He gave one collection of his writings the defiant title A Book to Burn, expecting the authorities to destroy it. In 1602 he was arrested on charges of corrupting public morals, and he killed himself in prison by cutting his throat with a razor. His books were banned and printed again anyway.

A boom in printing

The sixteenth century saw an explosion of commercial woodblock printing. Publishers in towns such as Jianyang, in Fujian, and Nanjing turned out cheap editions of classics, exam guides, almanacs, medical handbooks, story collections and plays, often with pictures. More people could read at least a little, and they read for pleasure as well as for exams.

Long novels written in a lively mix of vernacular and classical language reached print in this period. Romance of the Three Kingdoms retold the wars that followed the fall of the Han. The Water Margin told of 108 outlaws gathered in a marsh stronghold at Liangshan, men driven out of society by corrupt officials. Journey to the West, published in 1592, followed a Tang monk's journey to India to fetch Buddhist scriptures, but its hero is his protector, Sun Wukong, the rebellious Monkey King. The Plum in the Golden Vase, a frank and often brutal novel of a merchant's household, circulated in manuscript and print around 1600, and its author, who used a pen name, remains unknown.

Stage and city

Theater flourished as well. Tang Xianzu's Peony Pavilion, finished in 1598, tells of a young woman who dreams of a lover, dies of longing, and returns to life to marry him. Its celebration of feeling over convention delighted readers, many of them women, who wrote commentaries on it.

Worked example: a reader in Nanjing, 1600

A shopkeeper's son in Nanjing has failed the examinations twice. In a bookshop near the examination halls he finds a cheap edition of the Water Margin. The top third of each page shows a woodblock picture, the bottom two thirds the text. A printed commentary in the margin tells him what to admire and when to laugh.

What does a historian learn from such a book? The format shows a publisher aiming at buyers with modest reading skills. The commentary reveals how readers were taught to judge the outlaws, sometimes as heroes and sometimes as warnings. The price, recorded in some editions, shows how widely books had spread.

The outlaws' story also carried a political edge. In the novel, decent men take to the marshes because officials abuse them, yet they long to serve a just emperor. Readers could take from it either a warning against rebellion or a charge against corrupt power. Wang Yangming's claim that every person has moral knowing and the novels' sympathy for ordinary people belong to the same age, an age in which the dignity of common people was being argued for in new ways, even as the state still burned books it feared.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was Wang Yangming testing when he stared at bamboo?
2. Where did Wang Yangming have his great insight?
3. What did Wang Yangming mean by liangzhi?
4. What title did Li Zhi give one collection of his writings?
5. How did Li Zhi die?
6. What is the Water Margin about?
7. Who is the hero of Journey to the West?
8. What is known about the author of The Plum in the Golden Vase?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia