Skip to main content

On 8 July 1853 Commodore Matthew Perry's squadron steamed into Edo Bay and anchored off Uraga. Japanese officials told him to go to Nagasaki, the one port where foreigners were supposed to deal with Japan, but Perry refused to sail to Nagasaki and insisted on handing a letter from President Millard Fillmore to high officials near the capital. He said he would come back the next year for an answer, and left.

Why America came

The United States had several motives. American whaling ships worked the northern Pacific and wanted safe harbors and humane treatment for shipwrecked crews. Steamships bound for China needed coal along the way. Many Americans also believed their young nation had a destiny to open Asia to commerce and Christianity. Perry's orders told him not to use force unless attacked, but his guns made the threat plain enough.

Asking the daimyo

The senior councillor in charge of the crisis, Abe Masahiro, did something new. He had the American letter translated and sent to the daimyo, asking for their views, and invited opinions from some lower officials as well. Most replies opposed opening the country but admitted that Japan could not win a war. Abe ordered new gun batteries built in Edo Bay and lifted the old ban on building large ships.

The Treaty of Kanagawa

Perry returned in February 1854 with a larger fleet. On 31 March the shogunate signed the Treaty of Kanagawa. It opened the ports of Shimoda and Hakodate to American ships for supplies, promised good treatment for castaways and allowed a consul to live at Shimoda. It was not yet a trade treaty, and Britain, Russia and the Netherlands soon signed similar agreements. At Shimoda a young Choshu samurai, Yoshida Shoin, rowed out to Perry's ship at night and begged to be taken to America to study. He was sent back and arrested.

Harris and the commercial treaty

The first consul, Townsend Harris, arrived in 1856 and pressed for full trade, warning that Britain and France, then at war with China, might impose far harsher terms. Shogunal officials accepted his argument but wanted cover, so they asked the imperial court to approve. Emperor Komei refused to approve the treaty. A quarrel over who should succeed the sickly shogun also divided the leadership. In 1858 the newly appointed great elder, Ii Naosuke, signed the Treaty of Amity and Commerce anyway. It opened more ports, including Kanagawa, soon moved to nearby Yokohama, fixed Japan's import duties by treaty and placed foreigners under their own consuls' courts. The Netherlands, Russia, Britain and France signed matching treaties within months.

Purge and assassination

Ii met his critics with force. In the Ansei Purge of 1858 to 1859 he confined powerful lords and punished dozens of court nobles and samurai. Yoshida Shoin, who had been teaching young Choshu men such as Ito Hirobumi and Yamagata Aritomo at a small village school, was implicated in a plot against a shogunal official, and Yoshida Shoin was executed in 1859. His students would one day run the country. On a snowy morning in March 1860, a band of men, mostly from the Mito domain, killed Ii Naosuke outside the Sakurada Gate of Edo Castle. The shogunate's most forceful leader had been cut down at its own front door.

Trade and its shocks

Yokohama grew from a fishing village into a busy port after 1859. Raw silk and tea became Japan's main exports, and silk sold especially well because disease was ravaging European silkworms. The currency suffered a sudden shock. Gold was cheap in Japan compared with silver, worth only about five times its weight in silver against roughly fifteen abroad, so traders brought in silver dollars, changed them for Japanese gold coins and shipped the gold away. In 1860 the shogunate cut the gold content of its coins to stop the drain. Prices rose sharply, hurting samurai on fixed stipends and the city poor, and many blamed the foreigners. Several Westerners were cut down in the streets in the years that followed, and the treaty ports surrounded their settlements with guards.

Worked example: asking the daimyo

Why does Abe's letter matter? For two centuries the shogunate had made foreign policy alone. By asking the daimyo, and even some lesser officials, for their views, Abe hoped to build agreement for a policy that was bound to be unpopular. Supporters of his choice argue that it was sensible: no single office could carry such a decision, and wide consultation might keep the country united.

Critics, then and since, say it was a fatal admission. Once the shogunate had asked others what to do, it could no longer claim that it alone knew best. Daimyo who had been consulted expected to be consulted again, the imperial court began to see itself as a voice in national affairs, and samurai who wrote memorials began to think of policy as their business. The episode shows a pattern that recurs in many states. A government that opens debate to win support may find that debate cannot easily be closed again, and that people who have once been asked will judge their rulers by whether they listen.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where did Perry refuse to sail when Japanese officials asked him to in 1853?
2. What new step did Abe Masahiro take after Perry's first visit?
3. Which ports did the Treaty of Kanagawa open to American ships?
4. What did Emperor Komei do when asked to approve the commercial treaty?
5. What happened to Yoshida Shoin in 1859?
6. Who killed Ii Naosuke in March 1860?
7. What were Japan's main exports after trade opened in 1859?
8. Why did gold flow out of Japan after 1859?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia