In the 1840s Japan was a country of about 30 million people living under a political order more than two centuries old. The Tokugawa shogun ruled from Edo, roughly 260 daimyo governed their own domains, and the emperor lived in Kyoto with great prestige and almost no power. To understand why this system fell so quickly after 1853, it helps to see the strains that were already building inside it.
A society of status
Tokugawa law sorted people into hereditary status groups. At the top were the samurai, perhaps 6 percent of the population, who drew stipends in rice from their lords and served mostly as officials, since there had been no real war for two hundred years. Below them came farmers, artisans and merchants, and beneath everyone stood outcaste groups who did work considered polluting. In practice the order was looser than the law. Many samurai fell into debt to the merchants they were supposed to outrank, while rich farmers and city traders bought learning, land and influence. Edo held perhaps a million people by the eighteenth century, making it one of the largest cities on earth, and Osaka was the nation's great rice market.
Schools and books
Japan entered the modern era with a large reading public. Domain academies trained the sons of samurai in the Confucian classics, and thousands of terakoya, small private schools, taught commoner children reading, writing and arithmetic. The historian Ronald Dore estimated that by the 1860s perhaps 40 percent of boys and 10 percent of girls received some schooling outside the home. These figures are estimates, but historians agree that literacy was unusually widespread for a preindustrial society. Commercial publishers sold novels, travel guides, farming manuals and prints, and lending libraries carried books into the villages.
Rival schools of thought
Three strands of thought would matter after 1853. Scholars of National Learning tried to recover a pure Japanese way from ancient texts, free of Chinese influence. The most famous of them, Motoori Norinaga, gave new weight to the emperor's descent from the sun goddess. Scholars of the Mito domain fused Confucian loyalty with this reverence for the throne. In his New Theses of 1825, Aizawa Seishisai argued that Japan's unique national essence rested on the unbroken imperial line, and he warned that Western powers used trade and Christianity to weaken countries before conquering them. A third strand, Dutch Learning, studied Western medicine, astronomy and gunnery through books that reached Nagasaki.
Famine and failed reform
The 1830s were a decade of crisis. Bad harvests brought the Tenpo famine of 1833 to 1837, and rice riots and peasant protests spread. The shogunate's chief minister, Mizuno Tadakuni, answered with the Tenpo Reforms of 1841 to 1843. He banned luxuries, broke up merchant guilds and ordered migrants out of Edo and back to their villages. His plan to bring lands around Edo and Osaka under direct shogunal control angered the very lords and retainers he needed, and the reforms failed and Mizuno was dismissed. Some domains did better. In the same years Satsuma in the far south and Choshu in the far west reformed their finances, paying down debts and building revenue from monopolies and trade. That money would later buy them rifles and ships.
News from China
Foreign ships had been appearing off the coasts since about 1800. In 1825 the shogunate ordered them driven off by force, and in 1837 shore guns fired on an unarmed American merchant ship, the Morrison, which had come to return castaway Japanese sailors. When two Dutch Learning scholars, Watanabe Kazan and Takano Choei, wrote against this policy, they were punished in 1839 for criticizing the shogunate. Then came worse news. Britain defeated China in the Opium War of 1839 to 1842, and if the greatest power in Asia could be humbled, Japan could be too. In 1842 the shogunate replaced the order to fire with one letting foreign ships take on water and fuel, though it still refused them trade.
Worked example: the Osaka rising of 1837
In early 1837, with people starving in Osaka while rice was shipped off to Edo, a retired city police official named Oshio Heihachiro acted. A follower of the Wang Yangming school of Confucianism, which taught that true knowledge must issue in action, he sold his library to buy food for the poor. Then he called on the people to rise against corrupt officials and hoarding merchants. His small band set fires that burned a large part of the city before the rising was crushed within a day, and Oshio later killed himself while in hiding.
As a rebellion it failed. As a sign of the times it was alarming. The rebel was not a desperate peasant but a former official, and he attacked the system in the name of the very Confucian duty to the people that the system claimed to uphold. When a regime's own servants begin to judge it by its stated ideals and find it wanting, its claim to rule is already weakening, long before any foreign fleet appears offshore.
