Skip to main content

A categorical syllogism reasons about groups using all, no and some. The classic:

  • All humans are mortal.
  • Socrates is human.
  • Therefore, Socrates is mortal.

Picturing it

Draw a circle for mortal things and put a circle for humans entirely inside it. Socrates sits inside the humans circle, so he must be inside the mortal circle. Circle diagrams like this (Venn or Euler diagrams) make validity visible.

A common trap

  • All dogs are mammals.
  • All cats are mammals.
  • Therefore, all cats are dogs. (invalid)

Sharing a larger group (mammals) says nothing about how the two smaller groups relate. Draw it: two separate circles inside one big circle.

"Some" is not "all"

"Some politicians are dishonest" does not give you "all politicians are dishonest", and it does not tell you anything about any particular politician. Moving from some to all is one of the most common errors in public argument.

Two more valid patterns

Hypothetical syllogism (chaining conditionals): If P then Q. If Q then R. Therefore, if P then R.

Disjunctive syllogism (process of elimination): P or Q. Not P. Therefore, Q.

Disjunctive syllogism is only as good as its "or". If the two options listed aren't the only possibilities, the argument quietly becomes a false dilemma, which you'll meet in level 6.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. "All humans are mortal. Socrates is human. Therefore Socrates is mortal." This is…
2. "All dogs are mammals. All cats are mammals. Therefore all cats are dogs." What is wrong?
3. "Some politicians are dishonest." What follows?
4. "If P then Q. If Q then R. Therefore if P then R." This pattern is called…
5. "Either the battery is dead or the fuse blew. The battery is fine. So the fuse blew." This pattern is…
6. When does disjunctive syllogism go wrong in practice?
7. What tool makes the validity of categorical syllogisms easy to see?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia